GT4 has the bumps, but the game's slot-cars-that-understeer physics hardly make for any exciting racing. Whenever I screw up on the GT4 'ring, I'm not thinking, "aw, I braked too late for that corner," I'm thinking, "god I wish Polyphony Digital would go out and actually try driving a car." It also kinda bothered me that pretty much any average car you'd find on the street could get airborne on the Flugplatz, when a 1967 F1 car with no downforce only got this high:
http://im.edirectory.co.uk/products/1231/i/latpv011070.jpg
Oh, and GT4's inability to comprehend the fact that banked turns help you corner makes the Karussell a chore rather than a thrill.
Enthusia's 'ring may be smooth and graffiti-less, but other than those two factors I actually think the track looks more accurate in certain places. Besides, Enthusia's 'ring is
the correct size. Ever felt claustrophobic on GT4's 'ring? Ever noticed how easy it is to post sub-8-minute times in all kinds of cars? Yeah. Polyphony Digital may have gone out and surveyed the track, but I think they accidentally dropped their data in with their laundry (which they could do at their office, if you haven't seen that episode of X-play) and left the washing machine on the "cold" setting.
My best
no-black-flag time with a E30 BMW M3 Sport Evo is about 8'50", and the real-life lap record with that car on the ~1.8 mile longer, 24hour version of the course is 9'17". I've checked some of Enthusia's reference times, and the R-class cars are too fast, but everything else is pretty darn close; see for yourself, and compare some laptimes with other Enthusia cars that are listed here
:
http://nurburgring.de/?rubrik=rekorde&lang=eng
To get a
low-7-minute time in GT4, all you need is a sorta-sporty car. In Enthusia, the
SLR McLaren gets a time of about
7'40", and that's if you drive it like a madman.
(Sorry for the ranting, but I'm one of the many who was disappointed with GT4...)