Shoot. I'll cross the dubs off the list then.Either way, keep in mind the golden rule: Anything small like a Civic, Jetta, Cobalt and the like really aren't designed to go above 18"... So please make the correct decision when going for new wheels/tires...
The car accelerates fine (156 horses of fury!). Besides, my new commute will be 30 miles of rural highway driving; it will not require the get-up-and-go necessary to survive the city hellscape .Personally I'd rather have the slightly smaller overall diameter, because that translates to slightly shorter gearing, and that translates to slightly better acceleration.
I prefer smaller diameter. Better acceleration, slightly better fuel economy (lighter) and less unsprung weight.
Of course, your odometer will read slightly higher, but as long as you're within half-an-inch, that's only an additional hundred miles or so a year...
For odometer effects, you could hand-calculate it (I've written my own Excel file), or you could just go to http://miata.net/garage/tirecalc.html and see for yourself.
I'd keep the 17's myself... (heck, I prefer 15's or 16's), but it's your car and your gas money, so knock yourself out.