first picture of damage in Prologue appears (likely fake)


Closed
 
Thread Tools
Oct 22 2008, 4:38 AM #1
the Interceptor The stupid, it burns!
EDIT:
There's clear evidence that the picture has been run through Photoshop, therefore it will be called a FAKE until we learn more!




Mik23 of the german GT forum GTRP posted a picture of a crumpled Renault Clio, obviously photographed of a TV running Prologue.



Since the picture states "Gran Turismo 5 Prologue" in the lower right corner, one can assume that we will see a damage model in Prologue. The source is PS3-Tools.de. Unfortunately, the thread opener doesn't state where the picture is from, so there are no further details to date to back the originality of this picture.
Last edited by the Interceptor; Oct 22 2008 at 5:57 AM.
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:40 AM #2
The-BNA GTP Enthusiast
Interesting!
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:41 AM #3
Christhedude Diamond Member
Thanks for that Interceptor, but i have my doubts on that, but please correct me if i'm wrong...which i hope to be in that case lol.

It looks photoshopped to me, i dont know about you guys, or maybe it is just hard for me to believe that PD is showing us something new...and that would be damage then :S

anyhow, if it is real HURRAY

Chris
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:42 AM #4
Famine No offence, Jon...
Looking closely, you can see the typical TV beat pattern all over the image - background, car, tyre wall - but not on the "damaged" parts, and the front-left wheel looks quite 2 dimensional.

Without any corroborating information, I call Photoshop.
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:42 AM #5
Jay   
I have already looked at this picture (was posted in another thread earlier) and I am pretty sure it is a fake (IMO).


EDIT - Exactly what Famine said.
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:42 AM #6
AutoAki Racing addict
...in other forum, most people is guessing somebody is teasing us with Photoshop.
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:44 AM #7
Palleraa Junior Member
Well, could easily be photoshoped, but I'm gonna stay positive and say "Hurray"
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:45 AM #8
the Interceptor The stupid, it burns!
The damage looks kind of fake if you look closely, but since we have no idea in which state the programming was at the time the picture was taken, that's no actual indication of a Photoshop.

The source is a bit shady at the moment, but I guess we'll quickly learn whether this picture is real or fake. After all, we know that PD is working on the damage model, and we also know that there are plans to include it in Prologue, so the possibility of this being genuine is there.
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:46 AM #9
P3nT4gR4m I can haz custom titels!
Famine View Post
Looking closely, you can see the typical TV beat pattern all over the image - background, car, tyre wall - but not on the "damaged" parts, and the front-left wheel looks quite 2 dimensional.

Without any corroborating information, I call Photoshop.
+1, was exactly what I was thinking
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:46 AM #10
The-BNA GTP Enthusiast
Yeah. It could be leaked. But otherwise I agree, that it's a weird time to show us anything. And that it would be a single screenshot - no, not even a screenshot, but a photograph of the screen.
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:48 AM #11
Famine No offence, Jon...
the Interceptor View Post
The damage looks kind of fake if you look closely, but since we have no idea in which state the programming was at the time the picture was taken, that's no actual indication of a Photoshop.
It's not the nature of the damage that looks fake. It's the fact that the damaged parts look smooth.

Whenever you photograph a television, you see an interference pattern on the image. The pattern is clearly visible on all parts of that image apart from the "damaged" parts of the car.

He'd have done better to take a screenshot, or to create a noise layer to make the interference pattern uniform over the image.
 
Oct 22 2008, 4:51 AM #12
Christhedude Diamond Member
so now let me point out 2 things.

1.) TV Patterns all over the image, just not on the damaged parts

2.)PD supposedly gave us a picture taken of a TV - not an actual screen shot like usuall

3.) weird time (even tho i dont understand why it would be a weird time)

Chris
 
Oct 22 2008, 5:01 AM #13
GTP_DONK Super Blades Men
Christhedude View Post
so now let me point out 2 things.

1.) TV Patterns all over the image, just not on the damaged parts

2.)PD supposedly gave us a picture taken of a TV - not an actual screen shot like usuall

3.) weird time (even tho i dont understand why it would be a weird time)

Chris
Definately looks like a photoshop.

And you said let me point out 2 things then you listed 3
 
Oct 22 2008, 5:02 AM #14
Danny
I choose to believe!
 
Oct 22 2008, 5:06 AM #15
P3nT4gR4m I can haz custom titels!
Danachronism View Post
I choose to believe!
I have an advance beta testers version of the damage spec. If you drop 100bucks in my paypal account I'll send you it
 
Oct 22 2008, 5:08 AM #16
Jay   
P3nT4gR4m View Post
I have an advance beta testers version of the damage spec. If you drop 100bucks in my paypal account I'll send you it


Is your name Bruno?
 
Oct 22 2008, 5:10 AM #17
P3nT4gR4m I can haz custom titels!
VIPERGTSR01 View Post
Is your name Bruno?
for 100 bucks you can call me what you like.

And I'll throw in a free toaster for the first 50 customers
 
Oct 22 2008, 5:11 AM #18
iLex Senior Member
Definate +1 for photoshop.

I really tried to believe, really! But the guy/girl who photoshopped this just didn't do a good enough job.
 
Oct 22 2008, 5:13 AM #19
NLxAROSA Mini-me
P3nT4gR4m View Post
I have an advance beta testers version of the damage spec. If you drop 100bucks in my paypal account I'll send you it
You already have my bank account. Could you please deduct the 100 bucks from the 20 million you agreed to transfer to my account, your royal African higness?
 
Oct 22 2008, 5:20 AM #20
Touring Mars gran TurisMo
It's fake, there's no airbag!

A quick play around with the image in Gimp reveals that it's clearly been doctored - a straight photo from a TV screen it most certainly ain't...
 
Closed

Thread Tools

Forum Jump