Gaming forum - slightly odd organisation (suggestion/opinion)

  • Thread starter Thread starter sesselpupser
  • 3 comments
  • 834 views

sesselpupser

Pileated member
Premium
Messages
9,272
United Kingdom
United Kingdom
Messages
neema_t
So I just started a thread on F1 2012 in the Console and PC Gaming subforum after having searched inside that particular subforum for a thread on it, of course I didn't find one because there's a whole different subforum just for Codemasters' F1 series. Fair enough, I should have thought 'hang on, there must be a reason why this thread doesn't exist' but the fact is when I look at the Gaming forum list I only see some GT-related stuff, sim racing hardware and general gaming, I've never even noticed the F1, iRacing and Other subforums (exaggeration, but they do slip my mind).

Long story short, I think the Gaming forum is inconsistent and a bit weird. Examples:

- Codemasters' F1 series and iRacing are on the same level as Gran Turismo, but this isn't GTandCodemastersF1andiRacingplanet.net last time I checked! Nothing wrong with them having their own forums, but why only those two and not, I don't know, Codemasters' Dirt series, Simbin's titles, rFactor 1 & 2, Project CARS and so on as well?

- Grand Theft Auto is listed in 'Other' alongside a pile of racing/driving sims and games.

- Need For Speed, presumably referring to any and every NFS game ever, is in one subforum yet Ferrari Challenge and Supercar Challenge, two almost identical games, have their own subforums.

- Minecraft and BF3 have over 10,000 replies in their own threads but no subforum, that's well over 9,850 replies more than the entire Grand Prix Legends forum!


So that's just some of the things I don't get. My suggestion is that we have a structure like the following:

- GT5
- GT6
- GT Academy 2012
- Previous GT games
- ForzaPlanet.net link
- Racing games and sims
-- Codemasters' F1 series
-- Codemasters' Dirt series
-- iRacing
-- Etc. and so on
- General gaming
-- Minecraft
-- Battlefield 3
-- Call of Duty
-- Etc. and so on
- Gaming hardware
-- Computers and TVs (maybe?)
-- Consoles
-- Controllers
-- Sim racing wheels
-- Sim racing stands
-- Etc. and so on.

I don't know, it's just an idea, I thought I'd put it out there. No harm (nor judgement) in brainstorming, right?

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
The GT forums used to be in their own section in the index, but got merged along with the other gaming forums into one giant 'Games' section during the last(?) GTP software upgrade, so that would be reverting to an old layout which I don't think Big J likes to do if he can help it. To this day I still find it a bit odd and slightly annoying as the only forum in that section I ever go into is Console & PC gaming - I always had the GT section collapsed so I never had to see it :p
 
I think CoD and Battlefield could be merged into a Shooting Games forum. Minecraft could too be worthy of its own forum, it has three versions so its not just PC guys who can play it. And, NFS... I think it deserves more attention. For now its suitable to be a small tag but as soon as Most Wanted comes out it will need to be a proper forum so people notice it more. The reason I say that is because Most Wanted will have a heavy emphasis on Co-Op and Multiplayer.
 
Back