Tuning Competition Week 16 - RESULTS

  • Thread starter DuckRacer
  • 6 comments
  • 858 views

DuckRacer

Premium
10,164
Lotus Elise @ Deep Forest

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

sucahyo
11

VQuick
29

PARAGON GT
41

ChromeBallz
43

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Winner: ChromeBallz. Congrats!

Thanks to 2078TM for judging this week. :cheers:
 
2078TM's Ratings:


SUCAHYO
Turn-in (entry to corners)
Ranking (1-10): _2______

Mid-Corner response (whether the car under/oversteers mid-corner or holds the racing line well)
Ranking (1-10): ____2___

Corner exit (how quickly you can exit a corner whilst staying in good control)
Ranking (1-10): ____1___

Stability (rear end staying in line, car not 'jumping' or feeling skittish in turns)
Ranking (1-10): ____1___I’d give this a zero if I could

Grip (start-offs, how much power can be used without the drive wheels losing traction? Does the car oversteer excessively?)
Ranking (1-10): _____1__

High-speed controllability (whether the car becomes 'frantic' and turns far too sharply at high speeds)
Ranking (1-10): _____1__

Handling while braking (are you able to easily turn the car while braking, and without going into oversteer?)
Ranking (1-10): ____2___

Acceleration (how good is it? Is there a lot of traction while doing it?)
Ranking (1-10): _____1__

Total Combined Ranking: ____11____

Final Thoughts: _Absolutely undriveable. I was unable to complete a single lap without spinning out no matter how slow I went. The extreme (and unbalanced) settings conspire to make an already twitchy car positively evil.

VQUICK
Turn-in (entry to corners)
Ranking (1-10): _3______

Mid-Corner response (whether the car under/oversteers mid-corner or holds the racing line well)
Ranking (1-10): ____3___

Corner exit (how quickly you can exit a corner whilst staying in good control)
Ranking (1-10): ____2___

Stability (rear end staying in line, car not 'jumping' or feeling skittish in turns)
Ranking (1-10): ____2___

Grip (start-offs, how much power can be used without the drive wheels losing traction? Does the car oversteer excessively?)
Ranking (1-10): _____8__

High-speed controllability (whether the car becomes 'frantic' and turns far too sharply at high speeds)
Ranking (1-10): _____6__

Handling while braking (are you able to easily turn the car while braking, and without going into oversteer?)
Ranking (1-10): ____1___

Acceleration (how good is it? Is there a lot of traction while doing it?)
Ranking (1-10): _____4__

Total Combined Ranking: ____29____

Final Thoughts:VQUICK’s comment that he slapped this together and drove it two laps inspired me to give the same amount of effort judging it.

PARAGON
Turn-in (entry to corners)
Ranking (1-10): _5______Best turn-in of the group

Mid-Corner response (whether the car under/oversteers mid-corner or holds the racing line well)
Ranking (1-10): ____4___

Corner exit (how quickly you can exit a corner whilst staying in good control)
Ranking (1-10): ____4___

Stability (rear end staying in line, car not 'jumping' or feeling skittish in turns)
Ranking (1-10): ____4___Too sensitive to lift-throttle oversteer

Grip (start-offs, how much power can be used without the drive wheels losing traction? Does the car oversteer excessively?)
Ranking (1-10): _____8__Not enough power to cause a problem

High-speed controllability (whether the car becomes 'frantic' and turns far too sharply at high speeds)
Ranking (1-10): _____5__Stiff springs can unsettle the rear

Handling while braking (are you able to easily turn the car while braking, and without going into oversteer?)
Ranking (1-10): ____6___

Acceleration (how good is it? Is there a lot of traction while doing it?)
Ranking (1-10): _____5__

Total Combined Ranking: ____41____

Final Thoughts:At first I thought this would be my winner as it FEELS very quick. But the setup that actually tames this car’s understeer does at the cost of too much rear end instability at high speed.

CHROMEBALLZ
Turn-in (entry to corners)
Ranking (1-10): _4______

Mid-Corner response (whether the car under/oversteers mid-corner or holds the racing line well)
Ranking (1-10): ____4___

Corner exit (how quickly you can exit a corner whilst staying in good control)
Ranking (1-10): ____5___

Stability (rear end staying in line, car not 'jumping' or feeling skittish in turns)
Ranking (1-10): ____5___The most settled of the group.

Grip (start-offs, how much power can be used without the drive wheels losing traction? Does the car oversteer excessively?)
Ranking (1-10): _____8__Not enough power to cause a problem

High-speed controllability (whether the car becomes 'frantic' and turns far too sharply at high speeds)
Ranking (1-10): _____6__The best this week.

Handling while braking (are you able to easily turn the car while braking, and without going into oversteer?)
Ranking (1-10): ____6___

Acceleration (how good is it? Is there a lot of traction while doing it?)
Ranking (1-10): _____5__

Total Combined Ranking: ____43____

Final Thoughts: Very understeery but nevertheless the quickest this week. This was the only car that could be really hustled through the high speed turns without worrying that the rear would come around

Overall comment: The challenge this week was to tame the relentless understeer as well as lift-throttle oversteer of this car. Both ChromeBallz and Paragon had decent setups but I have the feeling that taking some front downforce away would provide better high-speed balance while having minimal impact on low-speed understeer.
 
I'm sorry I couldn't get my results up by the deadline, I had some troubles - both with PS2 (Disk Read Errors) and family... I preferred Paragons setup, but again - only by a small margin. Sucahyo's setup was too extreme (It seems like the only kind of setups he does - the Caterham and Holden were the same), and VQuick's was mediocre...
 
woo hoo. 2nd place.

Not to bad for the first try.

Gingiba: I'd still like to see your comments if possible. (just to help me in the future.)
 
Wow whats happened to these comps?!?

...Must get myself a 2nd hand PS2 or summat. Can I ask what Elise exactly was used? The classic?
 
Back