Anyone notice....

  • Thread starter Thread starter GTyler
  • 29 comments
  • 2,620 views
Messages
28
Messages
anfguy235
Everyone gripes about this and that... Not many take the time to truley appreciate the hard work PD put in to make an amazing driving exp. for all of us to enjoy. I myself , I love it the environments the cars. Yeah there are some things but lets not forget PD has updated a few times already, more than some games see in one life cycle. So stop griping and start driving.
 
Its sad that nobody agreed in your post. I myself agree 100% with your comment! And I´m enjoying the game like I never did with other GT games. Thank you PD!
 
I agree also,the pros of this game far far outweigh the few minor cons.people find too much rubbish to moan about.itl never be good enough for done people,myself I love it.
 
I use to be only a PC "gamer", although I don't really play that many games. Companies releasing unfinished products, getting paid now and fixxing things later was the norm. I haven't had a console till now really and I thought having a console meant games were good to go on release. GT5 is the only game I have for the PS3 and sadly this game feels more like it just graduated from Alpha stage and has only begun to enter Beta testing.

PD has updated a few times already, more than some games see in one life cycle

Read what you said there again. PD has already updated more times already then some games ever need to be updated. It is because they knowingly released an unfinished game, took payment now and all we have that they will make the game they advertised is a promise after the fact.
 
Well they could not update it. We have no contract with them that says they have to. Is it the right thing to do? Yeah. I'm very glad they are. Its felt like to me that I have gotten new features and seasonal events right when I needed them. This game didn't require updates by any means. It was pretty bug free and played very smoothly. Now they are adding stuff and it will only get better. I am glad I got it now and will progressively get to play it as they update. They could have been like, Well we pushed the game back to mid 2011 and everyone would have just griped, but instead they went ahead and released it and now everyone is wondering why its not done. I think PD was forced by Sony personally due to the incoming holiday and PS3 sales. So you get updates instead and I'll live with it. All in all I think GT5 will be the greatest racer we have ever put our hands on.
 
I agree 100%.

Before I own the game, most of the people said it sucks.
I know own it and absolutely love it.

People are getting to nit picky nowadays
 
This game didn't require updates by any means. It was pretty bug free and played very smoothly.
Sorry, I can't agree with this in any way.

If you look at how GT5 was developed, one can come to the conclusion that it is not a thoroughly planned project rather than a "let's start now and see where we get in a few years" meeting.

Sony pulled the trigger line a month ago to finally have it released, and PD just kept on doing what they did before the release: add stuff and iron out bugs. We just happened to get the finished parts somewhere in this process. And since the release version was taken out of a running programming process, we've had three patches already. GT5 is not finished, it never was. It was far enough to be released, and they keep working on it and release the new and fixed stuff as patches once in a while.

And while the gameplay itself is good, this process is borderline laughable for a multi-year multi-million-dollar software development project. One of the first things you learn when you become a programmer is that you need a proper strategy and time management. PD didn't have either, and this is the result.
 
Last edited:
Everyone gripes about this and that... Not many take the time to truley appreciate the hard work PD put in to make an amazing driving exp. for all of us to enjoy. I myself , I love it the environments the cars. Yeah there are some things but lets not forget PD has updated a few times already, more than some games see in one life cycle. So stop griping and start driving.

I'm sorry...did you say something? I was too busy griping about this and that so I did not hear you.
:sly:

Don't let the whiners get you down or uptight! Enjoy your GT5 game and Merry Christmas!!
:)
 
Well they could not update it. We have no contract with them that says they have to. Is it the right thing to do? Yeah. I'm very glad they are. Its felt like to me that I have gotten new features and seasonal events right when I needed them. This game didn't require updates by any means. It was pretty bug free and played very smoothly. Now they are adding stuff and it will only get better. I am glad I got it now and will progressively get to play it as they update. They could have been like, Well we pushed the game back to mid 2011 and everyone would have just griped, but instead they went ahead and released it and now everyone is wondering why its not done. I think PD was forced by Sony personally due to the incoming holiday and PS3 sales. So you get updates instead and I'll live with it. All in all I think GT5 will be the greatest racer we have ever put our hands on.

Really? Unless you live in an area with no false advertising consumer protection laws, we absolutely DO have a contract... Every sale is a contract to pay an agreed amount of money for the product as described. Allowing someone an after sale privilege of making the item as good as they promised is a favor extended to pd by the consumer, not the other way around.

Its really sad that consumers are so beaten down they expect to have no rights unless specifically extended to them by the seller... Its actually painfully pathetic when you think about it... Do you thank your babysitter for the 3 kids she didn't lose at the park rather than be unhappy about the one she did? Ultimate beaten wife syndrome.

As for the very idea that we should praise pd because they are still working on getting us all the promised content (where is bspec anywhere) instead of leaving us high and dry is just ridiculous... We should thank them for not making the ULTIMATE worst move?

People are enjoying the enjoyable parts of the game for sure, but that doesn't mean the shortcomings don't exist...
 
Some people will whine no matter how sweet the pie is. Some of us will enjoy it for what it is. And this pie gets better every month!
 
Some people will whine no matter how sweet the pie is. Some of us will enjoy it for what it is. And this pie gets better every month!

And its entirely possible to enjoy the good without ignoring the bad. Its not an all or nothing scenario.
 
The topic aside, discussions like this are mainly fueled by the thought that everyone who does not praise the game is a whiner. Those who condemn said whiners unfortunately do not make any effort to separate whining from actual, justified criticism. It is a process I understand and accept on a psychological level, but it is one almost everyone should be able to overcome, which is essential for having an actual debate.
 
Last edited:
i agree.

Whiners will whine no matter what, they are like gum on your shoes, very annoying and that's about it.

I just hope none of the babies get to whine on this thread.

**This game is just alpha, now maybe it's beta, what ?
**This game has patches, What! patches? that means it was released unfinished, really? ( i guess if there was no patches it was not complete, so most games released are not complete either )
**we need to backup.
**(now with backup)folks are using backup to get free cars, and whining again!

arrgghhhh!

PD should just focus to what they feel the game needs and forget about every single whining/complaining thread!
 
**This game is just alpha, now maybe it's beta, what ?

Software release cycle, I am no programmer, but Alpha is the stage where stability of the game is worked on. Beta is the stage where bugs as well as other things are ironed out. I will agree that the game is out of alpha stage and there is no maybe about it, the game is still in beta stages.



**This game has patches, What! patches? that means it was released unfinished, really? ( i guess if there was no patches it was not complete, so most games released are not complete either )

Patches for fixxing very basic problems that should have been caught in beta does show a game was rushed and released before it should have been, yes. A few of those problems and I wouldn't blink an eye at it being missed and fixxed later, but this game is riddled with it.
 
"Epic game Simulator" for me, nothing more to say! :) ohh yes! Merry Christmas to everyone! :)
 
Everyone gripes about this and that... Not many take the time to truley appreciate the hard work PD put in to make an amazing driving exp. for all of us to enjoy. I myself , I love it the environments the cars. Yeah there are some things but lets not forget PD has updated a few times already, more than some games see in one life cycle. So stop griping and start driving.

is updating a game often a good thing? LOL.. that just means it was unfinished and they decided to release it any way and fix it one step at a time.. Fewer patches the better. There is still features that arn't int he game that should be or features that don't work that need fixing. After the last patch though this game has become the best racing game on ps3.
 
HaHaHa, HaHaHa, yes, I really agree, they've done some hard work. They developed some new graphics, modeled the interiors of some cars, modeled a few new tracks ( while losing some old favorites ), copied the old cars from GT4 over, messed up the shadows from Prologue, did some really good sound sampling, did some really bad sound sampling, took $30 from nearly everyone here for 1/50th of a game to help them finish the new game ( prologue ) while giving no credit for it nor letting you transfer any cars or money...wait...maybe I don't agree...looks like 2 years of work and 4 years of promotion and parties.
It wasn't very long ago that a Japanese company as big as Sony would have fired everyone involved for releasing this game in it's current state.
 
Who ever said that the game is going into Beta obviously has never played a BETA before, or atleast is telling lies.

The game is great fun, and definatly my favourite so far. Thing is, ofcourse it could be better. The only reason it gets so much bad press here is because people were expecting different things, and tons of content like GT4, if you imagine the content of GT3 or GT1 comparrible with the standards of today's racing games, you are getting a very full game.

Ofcourse there is more this game can have, but I'd be lying if I said people saying this game is "Bad" or "incomplete" doesn't make me feel angry.
 
Everyone gripes about this and that... Not many take the time to truley appreciate the hard work PD put in to make an amazing driving exp. for all of us to enjoy. I myself , I love it the environments the cars. Yeah there are some things but lets not forget PD has updated a few times already, more than some games see in one life cycle. So stop griping and start driving.

Well said mate! Seems the more I look on here, the more bad comments I see...
People need to stop bitching about the bad and start liking the game for what it is......
 
I totally agree. No video game is perfect but GT5 is a fantastic game. They've told us that their going to send out updates often and that is fantastic.

PD could screw us like Codemasters did with F1 2010. I like F1 2010 but Codemasters saying the one patch would be the only patch, was a slap in the face.

GT5 is great and I'm sure with the upcoming updates, it'll get even better. Those that complain about the game just need to relax.
 
HaHaHa, HaHaHa, yes, I really agree, they've done some hard work. They developed some new graphics, modeled the interiors of some cars, modeled a few new tracks ( while losing some old favorites ), copied the old cars from GT4 over, messed up the shadows from Prologue, did some really good sound sampling, did some really bad sound sampling, took $30 from nearly everyone here for 1/50th of a game to help them finish the new game ( prologue ) while giving no credit for it nor letting you transfer any cars or money...wait...maybe I don't agree...looks like 2 years of work and 4 years of promotion and parties.
Pretty much the same thing I thought.

I doubt they slacked off, but they seem to have spent far too much time painstakingly laboring upon minute details, and headbutting technical issues with features they refused to compromise (thus the graphical glitches marring their trademark attempt at photorealism). So I'm sure there was hard work, but it was terribly misguided and poorly organized. "Overambitious" doesn't even apply, because it was far from impossible for them to deliver what they promised.

At least the game drives pretty good. It's clear someone at PD was actually paying attention to the other driving sims that have come out since GT3/GT4.
 
I replied to a thread not too long ago, and I said it once, I'll say it again..

Well, it usually comes down to this. People only complain about something because they love/like it so much. So yes, it's worth nitpicking about.

If you didn't like GT5 in the beginning, you'd probably let all the downfalls slide and say meh, then move along and play something else.
 
Everyone gripes about this and that... Not many take the time to truley appreciate the hard work PD put in to make an amazing driving exp. for all of us to enjoy. I myself , I love it the environments the cars. Yeah there are some things but lets not forget PD has updated a few times already, more than some games see in one life cycle. So stop griping and start driving.

I do have a few gripes about the game...

But I'm enjoying and appreciating the game the whole time I'm playing it.

That's the main reason that you don't see people going on about how awesome a game is, because they're too busy playing it. :)
 
To the guys saying it feels like beta, or alpha: give me a break. Are you trolling or what?
Does it lock up? No.
Does it get you stuck in menus with issues? No.
Does it have screen tears or any other kind of serious bug? No.
Does the online communication have issue? No.
What are you talking about?
Oh, maybe it doesn't have this or that feature you wanted.
Thats not beta testing, that just means you wish it was different.
Big Deal. I wish iMovie on my mac didn't use an intermediate codec when converting HD content like final cut pro does so I guess I should go whine instead that its beta.
I think it's pathetic. If your that unhappy hit up ebay with your copy and stop whining. Or go make a company, learn how the biz works and make something that satisfies you.
From the way all the whining posts here read, it should be easy.
 
haha :) I Still just LOVE IT! Im now level 28 i've seen alot in this game.. ITS AWESOME! just like any game it have something that can be done better.. still AWESOME :)
 
agree man, i love this game so much that i dont evenc are about all the flaws and problems, this game surpass my expectations ! thanks PD !
 
i agree.

Whiners will whine no matter what, they are like gum on your shoes, very annoying and that's about it.

I just hope none of the babies get to whine on this thread.

**This game is just alpha, now maybe it's beta, what ?
**This game has patches, What! patches? that means it was released unfinished, really? ( i guess if there was no patches it was not complete, so most games released are not complete either )
**we need to backup.
**(now with backup)folks are using backup to get free cars, and whining again!

arrgghhhh!

PD should just focus to what they feel the game needs and forget about every single whining/complaining thread!

I love how the most adamant defense comes from the most ignorant point of view... Kaz said the game was released unfinished... and your logic that simply having patches means it was not complete is a really weak attempt at flawed logic: patches to fix technical issues or improve performance are not a sign of unifinished, however patches to introduce promised content that wasn't there at release is exactly a sign of an unfinished game.

Who ever said that the game is going into Beta obviously has never played a BETA before, or atleast is telling lies.

The game is great fun, and definatly my favourite so far. Thing is, ofcourse it could be better. The only reason it gets so much bad press here is because people were expecting different things, and tons of content like GT4, if you imagine the content of GT3 or GT1 comparrible with the standards of today's racing games, you are getting a very full game.

Ofcourse there is more this game can have, but I'd be lying if I said people saying this game is "Bad" or "incomplete" doesn't make me feel angry.

To the guys saying it feels like beta, or alpha: give me a break. Are you trolling or what?
Does it lock up? No.
Does it get you stuck in menus with issues? No.
Does it have screen tears or any other kind of serious bug? No.
Does the online communication have issue? No.
What are you talking about?
Oh, maybe it doesn't have this or that feature you wanted.
Thats not beta testing, that just means you wish it was different.
Big Deal. I wish iMovie on my mac didn't use an intermediate codec when converting HD content like final cut pro does so I guess I should go whine instead that its beta.
I think it's pathetic. If your that unhappy hit up ebay with your copy and stop whining. Or go make a company, learn how the biz works and make something that satisfies you.
From the way all the whining posts here read, it should be easy.

So can I make up my own definitions of words to invalidate your statements too?

Both of you guys, have you ever played Minecraft? It's still in Alpha, is a barrel of fun, runs reasonably well and basically goes against everything else you have set forth as rules for why GT5 is not a beta.

definition: a nearly complete prototype of a product (as software) <released in beta> <the beta version>

So when the game is released unfinished (thus incomplete) and we are still waiting for features a month after release... that is pretty much the exact definition of a beta.

And since as I said the defense usually comes from a position of ignorance, before you ask what feature were missing:

Invite friends from within game (back of box) still not there
Race Bspec against other Bspec still not there
Bspec anywhere still not there
Online events still not there
Online matchmaking still not there
Cr for online races was not there at launch
Mechanical damage not there at launch

The list goes on.

Beta through and through.
 
Well I loved the game since day 1, but the latest update has just pushed this game even further up in my top racing games of all time list.

For me, this is the best racer, I've played the game every day bar 1 (the day I got the DCUO beta) since launch date, and even now I am as excited to play the game as I was on day 1. GT5 just makes me so happy, after the disappointment of F1 2010, I am so relived and happy that GT5 turned out so good!
 
If you take a step back and look at the situation, it boils down to this in my opinion:

There are of course whiners, and they do whine for no reason. But those who criticise the game actually are the people who dare to analyze the situation as it is. I understand that there's a lot of emotion involved, and when someone comes along and says that the game you love and spend every spare minute on has huge faults, he is basically criticising you and your decision to love it, which obviously feels bad. Noone likes to hear that, and that's perfectly reasonable.

If you look at those who post criticism however, you will notice that almost all of them do play the game as well. And Mr Laocean is absolutely right in saying that noone would do anything he doesn't like to do in his spare time. Simple conclusion: these people must enjoy GT5 as well. And they do - I do, too. I'm at level 24/23, and I wouldn't be there if I wouldn't enjoy the game.

Nonetheless, I have embraced that even the things I enojy doing can have faults. Learning that was a long and hard process. Previously, I saw pretty much every criticism as a personal attack on me and on the decisions I made, so naturally I began defending me and the things I did. But I learned to see beyond that, and I am thankful that I can do that today. Of course there still are emotions involved, there will always be. But when you feel those emotions and the decision and the actions they fuel, simply ask yourself whether it is actually you and your brain who are responding, or whether it's your angriness furiously fighting off something which wasn't even meant as an attack.
 
Last edited:
Back