Articles on left foot breaking vs right foot breaking

  • Thread starter Thread starter cypher2004
  • 74 comments
  • 10,086 views
I am not old enough to drive but when I take out my Mum's Automatic car I brake with the left foot (Got used to it from GT5P)Manuel However some rally drivers use LFB but it will be very difficult.
 
As far as I know, one of the rules on automatic is to never break with your left foot. It should always rest aside and you should only accelerate and break with your right foot. I'm talking about road cars, of course.
 
I am not old enough to drive but when I take out my Mum's Automatic car I brake with the left foot (Got used to it from GT5P)Manuel However some rally drivers use LFB but it will be very difficult.

Thats cute and all, but in real life you're just going to school orthe grocery store; you dont need to drive like you're in a go kart.
 
As far as I know, one of the rules on automatic is to never break with your left foot. It should always rest aside and you should only accelerate and break with your right foot. I'm talking about road cars, of course.

Yes it is some what different to Race cars but I feel if you got used to it You actually React better because your left foot is already on stand by whilst in case of RFB you have to remove your right foot and then brake which is slower.Of course the biggest danger is confusion (Applying both brakes and throttle in the same time)which is not an issue in RFB but the article is really wonderfull has some great Valid points most of us didn't know .Thanks for posting 👍

Edit :Yes agree with you 100% redcouch 👍
 
IRL I have always used my left foot for braking when driving an automatic and right foot with driving a manual. I found early on that I could drive much faster and safer on twisty roads if my left foot was right there ready to tap the brake as needed while the right was always ready to apply the throttle. It seemed liek a no brainer to me. You have two pedals and you have two feet why not use them.
 
For me left foot braking is useful in only a few circumstances in both GT5 and real life:

-Kart Racing where it's not really an option
-Loose surfaces and wet or icy conditions when you are constantly feathering the throttle and brake to keep longitudinal and lateral G's to a minimum.
-Priming an AT for launch (dangerous if the torque converter isn't ready for it)
-Corners in an AT which you don't want the transmission to pull out of gear (very rare for me as I find just keeping it in a locked gear mode sufficient for most times)

When I check my telemetry from GT5, even with right foot braking, there's not that much time lost in going from the throttle to the brakes. Most of my recorded laps look like the brake and throttle are two sides of one axis with very little overlap and only a very short time at zero, usually while waiting for the suspension to catch up.
 
IRL I have always used my left foot for braking when driving an automatic and right foot with driving a manual. I found early on that I could drive much faster and safer on twisty roads if my left foot was right there ready to tap the brake as needed while the right was always ready to apply the throttle. It seemed liek a no brainer to me. You have two pedals and you have two feet why not use them.

I also use two feet with automatic. It allows you to throttle an break faster with less delay. The only reason why one might consider using only their right foot with an automatic is to reduce the risk of breaking and throttling at the same time.
 
well , i have 1 sequencial/automatic car in real life and drove several, left foot is no good in real life, in gaming i use both.
 
well , i have 1 sequencial/automatic car in real life and drove several, left foot is no good in real life, in gaming i use both.
Maybe no good for you but that is not to say it is no good. I've been doing it for over 30 years trust me it is fine if you know how to do it. In fact I have no problem whatsoever using either foot for braking. I am just as comfortable using either foot in an auto and of course in a manual left foot clutch right foot brake. I have 2 cars. Thunderbird and Mustang both auto trans the Mustang also has TCS and a F150 which is a manual. I always drive the cars with left foot brake unless my knee is hurting then I use the right foot for the brake. The truck, well I try to avoid congested areas as the clutch causes my knee to swell if I have to use it a lot in stop and go traffic.

btw the only issue I have ever had using left foot braking is in the older cars at night. Specifically the ones with the dimmer switch on the floor. Sometimes you may find yourself braking for a corner and meet an oncoming car where you need to switch to low beams but your foot is already in use. The solution, brake with the right foot at night when going into blind corners. Of course this is not an issue on any of the newer cars as they are pretty much all on the steering column now.
 
Last edited:
IRL it'll depends on car type, corner type, transmission type and road surface; because braking is simply not just for slowing down.
 
Last edited:
Oh you Yanks and your Autos xD

Manual all the way, right foot braking.
LOL If you had my knees you might reconsider that a bit. Actually I saw a Vette a few years back that I wanted desperately and had the cash to buy it. The only thing that kept me away from the car was that it had the stiff mechanical clutch and I had to drive in heavy traffic every day. No way my knee could have stood the torture. Even in my truck which is hydrolic after an hour or so in traffic I would barely be able to walk from using the clutch so much. I ended up buying the Thunderbird which has auto and cruise control. Much easier on the body over the course of the day.
 
Many moons ago when I was a moto-x devotee I would read dirt bike test that talked about how a bike would turn or not, and how they would use the front brake to help the thing turn. I was racing scrambles at that time because my bike wasn’t good enough for moto, and we would just flick the scooter into the turn and slide it through the corner. The whole concept of using a front brake to assist the bike to turn was foreign to my sensibilities of how it reacted to braking while turning. Usually the bike would wash out and seconds later I would be on the ground grinding my knee gard into it.

That ability to use the front brake in a turn that I would read about, portrayed by the magazines as some fix all for bad handling scooters that would be used by these great test riders always bugged me in that I was never able to understand how to use it to make my bike turn better. Then I was racing at Marysville in the second moto and my front brake cable got pinched in a first turn crash. After I got going again and was pounding hard to get caught up, I got to this one turn that I was having trouble with in the first moto before the first turn calamity and the turn was completely different after the crash, the turn was now easy and no big deal, I couldn’t figure it out until after the race was over.

When I was washing the front wheel and tried to spin it, it wouldn’t turn freely, there was a slight drag on the wheel by some mysterious force. So after looking at all the players in the braking orchestration I found a small crimp in the cable. That got me a thinking about how much benefit was gained by just the slightest amount of front wheel drag. After that everything made sense to me in how to use the front brakes to help me get through a turn faster.

My next quest for the understanding of the front brake assisted turning methodology was when I used it in car racing. My dedication to the mastering of the front brake while turning took another leap. When you race motorcycles you can use body English to make the bike do your bidding versus when your in a car, your just along for the ride. That was one of the biggest things I had to get over and find some sort of way to make the car transfer weight like I could do so easily on a motorcycle. The use of the front brake while turning was what filled in the blanks.

I used to love it whey back when I would see NASCAR races on TV because they would go into detail showing split screen shots of the car and the foot peddles. I was fascinated how fluid the drivers were when they would move there feet back and forth, up and down, left and right across the peddles. The accuracy of their foot work was just head shaking and I was envious as to how they made it look so easy. It was as though they were communicating with the car using some foreign language that only the car and the driver could understand.

I knew I had to be that good or I just couldn’t go forward. I did everything I could to understand and use my left foot to brake while turning and I had a manual clutch. I would trade feet, using my right while down shifting (heel and toe) and then bring in my left foot to work through the turn while using the gas w/ my right foot. I think you can tell that I’m an advocate for left foot breaking and I am still learning to perfect the dark art.
 
Wow, I don't even know what to say to that. ^^

Doesn't matter what kind of car/kart/motocross bike(?)/horse your driving, just do what feels right to ya.
 
LOL. I read all this IRL stuff and I wonder how many of you actually drive all out performance cars. I have tried the LFB thing and there is a HUGE difference when it comes to driving around town and driving fast. I wonder how many of you have actually tried threshold braking with your left foot? I know I have tried it several times in my 240sx and there's no problem. It's actually quite easy with those softer brakes and economy tires. But then I tried it in my Evo and wow it's not as easy as I once thought. Those Brembos with semi-race pads are so quick to lock up. You definitely need some seat... or should I say left foot time with your car. Especially if it can stop on a dime. I know I found myself hitting that seat belt before I knew what happened. Maybe I just suck really bad.
 
All my cars for the last twenty years have been a stick, the last time I was driving a automatic (rental) I about put my head through the windshield after my left foot hit the brake thinking it was a clutch. :lol:
 
With the DFP and GT(3-5) I use left foot braking. In normal driving I use whatever foot works best for the situation. 90% of the time its the right foot because 90% of my driving is just going to work, etc. There are several situations with both manual and automatic transmissions where the left foot works best. All of my "motorsport" activity is rock crawling (I use GT for my fast driving) and you are always switching your feet around.

Check out this video for some amazing footwork. BTW this is one of the videos that shows the crazy spectators of the Group B days.
 
All my cars for the last twenty years have been a stick, the last time I was driving a automatic (rental) I about put my head through the windshield after my left foot hit the brake thinking it was a clutch. :lol:

LOL that reminds me of my first job. I was a car wash for a rental company. If I had a nickle for every time I did that.

Check out this video for some amazing footwork. BTW this is one of the videos that shows the crazy spectators of the Group B days.


Wow great video!
 
All my cars for the last twenty years have been a stick, the last time I was driving a automatic (rental) I about put my head through the windshield after my left foot hit the brake thinking it was a clutch. :lol:

man that happened to me once! :scared:
 
i do not have the same precision and control with my left foot for anything besides my clutch. when i go to the track (IRL) the thought of using left foot for breaking has never come up; partly because i'm not an expert racer, but also because my braking and acceleration are always separated by a period of turning. maybe if i was rallying it'd be different, but in any traditional pavement course that don't have my slaloming constantly, i don't see any need for left foot braking.

also i don't see why anyone would bother doing it for regular driving; seems completely useless, like driving with one hand on top of the wheel and your seat cranked way back. just for show.

EDIT: i forgot that you could need gas while braking for downshifting purposes, but i've pretty much gone my whole track driving career heel-toeing.
 
I learned to drive on a manual gearbox so I've always used my right foot to brake, whether I'm driving an automatic or not. I do the same when playing (I use a DFGT) but sometimes I wonder if my times would be better if I started using my left foot.
 
FWIW, I haven't read the linked articles yet, so forgive if anything I say is a repeat of info within them.

I've spent the last 25+ years driving real cars both on the streets and on tracks, automatics & standard transmissions. I use whatever fits the situation.

Braking hard into a corner that involves downshifting in a manual, I heel - toe with right foot braking. Almost any other situation where the clutch isn't involved (which can include corners on a track that don't require a downshift, just a touch on the brake pedal) I brake with my left foot.

Someone upthread mentioned that they're usually hard on or hard off the brakes and that their foot-switching time isn't that relevant. While "Full on brakes - full on gas" is an ideal, it's seldom a reality on any track ever designed. There are often times where the quickest line through a corner doesn't need more than a touch on the brakes in order to set up the entry, sometimes without even lifting throttle. At other times, you can use a little brake to adjust your line in traffic mid-corner without lifting throttle. As for foot-switching time not mattering, I've compared my own data logs (in-game and real life) and I certainly make the transition both quicker & smoother when using two feet. While I haven't won many races by thousands of a second, the couple I have would likely have been lost with right-foot braking.


If you can't modulate your left as well as your right, it's likely just because you haven't practiced it as much.
 
Wow, I don't even know what to say to that. ^^

Doesn't matter what kind of car/kart/motocross bike(?)/horse your driving, just do what feels right to ya.

Let me see if I got this right, you have commented on other peoples post 26 times of which you have given me your 2 cents twice. We don’t know anything about you or what you bring to the discussion, so I’ll be waiting to read your first thread and see what I can find to give you your 4 cents back to you on. Negative energy will only keep your friend count where it is presently.

elephant-balance.jpg
 
As far as I remember even Senna the greatest racer of all time never used his left foot for braking he used to use heal and toe method according to car type, track and weather conditions.
 
It depends on the car, fact is that if you're playing a game and you don't need to use the clutch there is no advantage at all in using right foot braking.
 
Personally, I don't want to read an article discussing the differences between left foot breaking and right foot breaking... having either of my feet break would be bad!

:)

I treat GT5 much like I do with karts; I left foot brake. I just find it quicker. Driving on public roads in real life though, I stick to right foot for gas and brake.
 
Back