CLOSED POLL: 2.0 Advanced Competition 64 (W: zambuca)

[ShadowPeter]

Feedback, please!

Is the light?? lol

 

[Beeblebrox237]

Can have some feedback, please? Thanks.

Yep, I'm going to be a git and quote my post in an effort to get feedback. I probably was overlooked because it was the last post on that page. Anyway, I would be very grateful to anyone offering criticism.

 

[fkxpro]

oh yeah! mazda787 breaks my shutout, thanks dude!

 

[RED3MON]

Don't know why I didn't make it to the poll..... ><

Wolf &amp; Dog by RED3MON, on Flickr​

 

[DarkR]

Congratulations Zambuca nice entry 👍

And thanks to those who voted for my entry 👍

 

[zambuca]

Congratulations Zambuca nice entry 👍

And thanks to those who voted for my entry 👍

Thank you so much DarkR! But it isn't over yet Also a big thanks to those who voted for my entry. (It's a nice compensation for my total failure in the tourney. If I win this I can have some fun being judge now that my PS3 is closed down)

 

[SVX]

This is a great car/scenery balance. The slight bend makes your car look twisted though.

Thanks mate, I'll keep that in mind for next time.

 

[Jacob]

can i have feedback on mine please ?

Nice shot, love the reflections on the car. Good composition and sense of speed. But the car shouldn't be black, or the pic should've been brighter. It blends into the wall and makes it hard to distinguish what is what. No real complains whatsoever, just that the others were better.

Feedback please, and just to clarify if im opperating within the rules.

http://i676.photobucket.com/albums/vv129/lucagt1/EigerNordwandShortTrackBW.jpg

Yeeeeeeeaah, adding a B&W semi-artistic filter wasn't really what I was looking for, it's overcontrasted and yeah... Overedited in general.

Feedback please?

http://i660.photobucket.com/albums/uu328/GTPlanet_SVX/Competition Entries/pmc2064edited.jpg​

Nothing major here, good and competent entry. Can't complain, among the last to get cut. A touch of colour tone and desaturation might've improved even more.

Could i please have feedback on this?

(too many Rs 6's maybe)

Yeah, competent in every single way. Just that I liked the others better. Too may RS6, it may have been. /Yoda.

http://i1193.photobucket.com/albums/aa348/FordMKIVJ5/London-1.jpg

Feedback?

Odd saturation editing on this one along with the shadow of the car falling onto the rear which is the center of my attention, it makes it slightly boring to look at, no major faults here either though. Just too much great shots to compete with.

Can have some feedback, please? Thanks.

The "Too-many-RS6s"-syndrome here as well. Slightly uninteresting to look at, a higher and more zoomed-out view would've improved the image. It is a bit like Zambuca's shot in concept, but his has got a lot more editing and a more interesting view in front of the Audi's rear.

feedback? is it the tree? haha!
​

Nope, not the tree. I really like this one, especially in the preview size, but it looks very oversharpened in the full size, edges become a bit jagged and there a lot of artifacts. I very rarely sharpen myself, so I'm a bit allergic to that. Lose the sharpening and you've got a winner. 👍

Feedback, please!

Is the light?? lol

Slightly boring composition, uninteresting view over the Mt Aso landscape, and felt like it hadn't been edited. Not a requirement, but other which were edited were better.

Don't know why I didn't make it to the poll..... ><

​

The yellow-ish hue gives it a slightly odd look, nothing else really, the other just went along better with my taste. Simply put, too many RS6s.

Sorry for being an ass by throwing out some idiotic feedback (does it show that I don't know all too much about photography in general? ), but that's my "reasons" for this and that.

Lastly, a congrats to Zambuca for his "2 Fast 4 Ü". Great entry, and great editing.

 

[Beeblebrox237]

Thanks for the feedback

 

[RED3MON]

Hey thx for the feedback I did try to get some wagon in the UCD for a few days, but no luck there.... So I just went ahead and purchase the RS6....I gotta be prepare next time and stock up some odd cars for future competitions lol

 

[ShadowPeter]

Slightly boring composition, uninteresting view over the Mt Aso landscape, and felt like it hadn't been edited. Not a requirement, but other which were edited were better.

No, it was edited, in fact I hardly edit my own photos. But thanks for the feedback.

 

[Jacob]

No, it was edited, in fact I hardly edit my own photos. But thanks for the feedback.

Ah, okay. Well, what can you do, actually. It's that kind of shot where you carefully think, should I keep the sky detailed, or make it washed out and go for enhancing other parts... Just keep trying though. 👍

 

[ShadowPeter]

Ah, okay. Well, what can you do, actually. It's that kind of shot where you carefully think, should I keep the sky detailed, or make it washed out and go for enhancing other parts... Just keep trying though. 👍

Ok, thanks.

 

[SVX]

Thank you very much for the feedback Fishy.

 

[jus1029]

The poll is closed and zambuca wins!