Codemasters has provided some high points and some low points. The Toca series in general met expectations and Toca 3 provided hours and hours of entertainment. The original DIRT was a refreshing concept and the Pikes Peak Hillclimb was worth it's weight in gold. The handling however was a huge dissappointment for me (with the G25). I managed to adapt to it, but it never felt realistic at all. GRID turned out to be a dissappointment (handling physics)but I still got my money's worth out of it.
To me the best thing that can be said about Codemasters is the HUGE improvement that they made to their handling physics in DIRT2. With the G25 I really feel connected to the car and also feel the car's connection to the ground. Last night, I was racing with a friend who was complaining that he didn't like the handling physics because the car was always sliding around like it was on ice. I mentioned that he may simply be "overdriving" the car and that my motto was "Go slow to go fast". He just backed it down a notch and the game came to him immediately and he was delighted with the difference.
One negative aspect to their philosophy (to me anyway) is their desire to be "all things to everybody". Toca was filled with such a variety of vehicles and while I also enjoyed racing the lawntractors, it was mostly as a novelty and not something I was passionate about. I wish they would focus more and limit the types of cars/vehicles in a game.
I have been enjoying DIRT2 immensely and think it's a really great game. However, as others have said, I wish they had focused more on making a Rally game with longer stages, variable weather and daylight variations. I could easily do without many of the vehicle classes they've included.
The best thing Codemasters could do right now would be to provide DL content giving us the Pikes Peak event from DIRT and expand/extend the rally stages. I'd have my wallet out faster than an X-Games Colin McRae
Oh yes, one other thing ... Codemasters needs to get their servers squared away. Setting a new World's Record and not having it register on the leaderboards is a major glitch. If they are going to tout the concept of "Compare your times to your friends" on a special section of their web site, the least they can do is allow it to happen from a technical standpoint. 👎