CSR Elite pedals vs. G25/7 pedals

  • Thread starter Thread starter Crisp
  • 16 comments
  • 6,476 views

Crisp

Premium
Messages
1,636
United States
Pittsburgh, PA
Messages
CrispWheels
Hey all! This is my personal compairison and what I had noticed with using my new CSR Elite pedals that I got about a week ago.
IMG_0062.jpg

I will start by talking about the obvious differences externally about the pedals. The Logitech pedals use a plastic base with steel pedals and pedal arms. They use semi metallic springs that are covered by the red sheilds on the back of the pedals. The CSR Elite pedals are mostly aluminum and only the base it self is plastic. The CSR Elite pedals can also be tuned a bit for your liking right out of the box. There are two nuts on the clutch pedal spring and the accelrator pedal spring. You can adjust this by turning the nut to compress the spring thus making it stiffer. The way you change the braking is by turning a knob on the bake of the brake pedal and this changes the sensitivity of the load cell scale. I go over this in the third paragraph.(Here is a good size compairison of the pedals below)
IMG_0074.jpg

IMG_0073.jpg

As you can see by the photographs there is a consiterable diffence in realistate where you can put your feet on the pedal faces vs. the Logitech pedals. Both the logitech and fanatec pedals can be inverted however the CSR Elites have the availablility to be inverted and still use the stock pedal base. It costs 49.99 USD for the inversion kit. That would bring the total to about 200 USD for the pedals alone. Logitech pedals come with the wheel that costs 300 USD for the bundle. Now you may be wondering, "sounds like the CSR Elite pedals are over priced just to be made of aluminum, be able to be inverted in the base and have bigger pedals" Read the following below on what makes the CSR Elite pedals stand out from the logitech pedals.

The CSR Elite pedals use a "load cell brake" (pictured underneath) now what this technology is, is basically a very precise scale. It measures the amount of force being applied to the pedal and that is how it applies the braking in game. You can adjust how much force you want to apply in game by turning a knob on the back of the pedals and this will change the amount of force that you need to apply to the brake pedal to achive full braking potential. The logitech pedals use a potentiometer style of pedal which measure the distance traveled. This is a good methood however if you are in a "realistic" game and you are not running ABS, this may be a problem since you will most likely lock up your brakes in an emergency situation, such as a car cutting in front of you or loosing grip and trying to use the brakes to control the vehicle. G pedals have modifications available such and the "nixm" modded pedals sets wich make the brake pedal feel much better. I have not used a nixm modded pedal set yet so I could not tell you the differece personally. This is an "out of the box" compairison anyways. Brakes may be the most important part of the pedals since out breaking someone is how you win races usually.
IMG_0063.jpg


I would appricate some feedback on how this review was. It is my first one about sim racing equipment so let me know what I could improve on for future ones.👍
 
Last edited:
I went from G25 pedals to CSP's which aren't the same as the CSR Elite's are similar Fanatec pedals. The CSP's are by far faster, the G25 pedals were by far more reliable. As many races I've won because of that awesome load cell brake, I've lost or DNS'ed as a result of issues with these unreliable CSP's.

CSP's will win you races but will hinder winning championships. I won at least one online championship in a league with those G25 pedals.
 
I went from G25 pedals to CSP's which aren't the same as the CSR Elite's are similar Fanatec pedals. The CSP's are by far faster, the G25 pedals were by far more reliable. As many races I've won because of that awesome load cell brake, I've lost or DNS'ed as a result of issues with these unreliable CSP's.

CSP's will win you races but will hinder winning championships. I won at least one online championship in a league with those G25 pedals.

In what way were they unreliable?

@OP Hi nice review. I have G25 and find the pedals to be very loud at times, like when you need to lift off the accelerator quickly to press the brake or when you hit the stop on the pedals it can be loud too. What noise difference is there between the two pedal sets, if any?
 
CSP are quiet generally.
May need lube now and again because of squeaks.
 
In what way were they unreliable?

@OP Hi nice review. I have G25 and find the pedals to be very loud at times, like when you need to lift off the accelerator quickly to press the brake or when you hit the stop on the pedals it can be loud too. What noise difference is there between the two pedal sets, if any?
There is some noise of course but I think that the logitech pedals are louder overall with brake and clutch spring. However what your question pretains to is dependant upon how stiff you make your accelerator spring.

CSP are quiet generally.
May need lube now and again because of squeaks.
Yes I used some model train oil that you can find at any hobby shop.👍
 
Last edited:
Yeah, im unsure on that reliability comment as well. I have put close to 500 hours on my csps, lugged em to mates houses, work etc. Never had a problem with mine either.
 
Caz
Yeah, im unsure on that reliability comment as well. I have put close to 500 hours on my csps, lugged em to mates houses, work etc. Never had a problem with mine either.

Wait? You say your unsure but you are agreeing with him? Or are you telling me something to change in the review?
 
Nice to read your thoughts on the pedals and comparison.
Did you try any of the different holes in pedal positions?

I would encourage you to get the extra kit and having the 2UP 1 Down for throttle is very comfortable. Also adding a bit more support to the pedals themselves with the metal brackets included. These pedals also look fantastic with the Rennsport wheelstand.

With the very emoitional and stressing start to the year I have had on a personal level I just havn't been in the frame of mind or mood to finish off my own pedal comparison. For me the pricing strategy isn't right on these because most people will prefer to buy the CSP over the CSR Elite with the Pedal Kit. I would encourage Fanatec to try and offer a CSR Elite & Pedal Kit Package for an approx £30/$30 reduction to the CSP if purchased together.

However the CSP are not for me the best all out pedals, CSR Elite may have advantages for some, particularly d.i.y cockpit users as they are much more adaptable. These are great pedals but CSP edge them out in quality/build and features.

Your review however hits the mark and a scenario that SRT completely missed in their review.
The CSR Elite pedals are a superb choice and upgrade for those already owning G25 pedals, while you havn't done so their are many people who have modified their G25/G27 pedals as hanging in their cockpits.

For example why spend so much money on "Perfect Pedal" when you can get the Elite Pedals with loadcell, improved spacing between pedals offering d.i.y fitting options and a fantastic look as money better spent.
 
Last edited:
I chose the CSR E pedals mainly for the load cell and the inversion ability for when I finally have the time to build my cockpit. The stock fanatec pedals were too soft and the Logitech pedals feel dated. So load cell was the only way I was going to put many more happy hours into sim racing.
 
Currently looking into an upgrade from my G27 pedals.

This is a good review, especially the side by side pics.

What are the major differences between the CSP, and the CSR elite pedals other than price?
 
G27 pedals with APELETTRIC load-cell here and I'm fine with them!
With this modification my lap was improved about 1sec' and more.
 
The csp pedals are a bit thicker and heavier than the csre's and also the build quality is a little bit better such as the pedal movement feel. Other than that both are pretty close.
 
Back