Double whammy penalty for Speed

  • Thread starter Thread starter graveslids
  • 39 comments
  • 1,406 views
@Graveslids- Your opinions are fair I suppose which gives little point inarguing them. However...
Graveslids
As far as everyone going on about how it's unfathomable that it was DC he tore into, I have to stop and ask, what has DC done that is so esteemable as to "demand" respect on a level that for all intents and purposes seems to rank directly DC below directly below a head of state? Yes, the man is a marvel in setting his chassis, and true assest for any team due to his technical inclinations, a dedicated tester and an all around quality pilot, a strong proponent for increased driver safety, but a World Champion? no. Which in reality is the measuring stick for what makes a pilot a pilot in F1.
The reason DC is so highly valued and respected is because he is consistant and has proven his talent in a variety of cars with a wide spread of ability. And yet he still continues to do fairly well, and is almost guarnteed to score points throughout the season.

The best example to your comment on a championship being the measuring stick is Jacques Villeneuve. He was a champion in '97 as you well know, and since then he did have a lengthy period out. But, you must have noticed thats since he has come back he has not shown much of that championship winning quality. He has scored reasonably well this season so far, but little better than many other non-championship winning drivers.
 
He is also very well respected because he gets on with everyone, is polite, always speaks his mind (without going in to rants), and respects everyone else in the paddock (except maybe Sato!!!).

Scot Speed is none of this.
 
ExigeExcel
@Graveslids- Your opinions are fair I suppose which gives little point inarguing them. However...

The best example to your comment on a championship being the measuring stick is Jacques Villeneuve. He was a champion in '97 as you well know, and since then he did have a lengthy period out. But, you must have noticed thats since he has come back he has not shown much of that championship winning quality. He has scored reasonably well this season so far, but little better than many other non-championship winning drivers.

And yet Jacques will go down in histroy as champion, which is a rarified group of individuals, therefore demanding respect in honor of the acheivement, reagrdless of how he currently stands in points or performance. Which in turn supports my statement.

However, Exige, I must truly comend you, and the others on this thread who have refrained from turning this into a flame war, the conversation and points brought forward have been enjoyable to argue and consider. Yet you are 100% correct in saying that opinions are moot to argue as a person is already decided before the first word is spoken. 👍
 
graveslids
And yet Jacques will go down in histroy as champion, which is a rarified group of individuals, therefore demanding respect in honor of the acheivement, reagrdless of how he currently stands in points or performance. Which in turn supports my statement.

I do not believe this is true.

Although it has never happened, it is possible for a world champ to be a total jerk and lose all respect.

Having been a world champ does not mean you will always have respect regardless of your actions.
 
I totally agree with Dunk there, for example well done to Jaques he's managed to win the championship once, but I still think theres a lot of better drivers than him who've never won the championship throughout their careers or upto this point in their careers and I respect a lot of drivers more. I resepct a hell of a lot of drivers more than Schumacher, I know he's been the best since he started his winning streak but he's also done some dirty stuff like when he bumped Hill off the track when his car had a failure. I had far more respect for Hill than Schuey, yet Schuey was at that time far more sucessful.
 
graveslids
Not a single person in this world can convince me that if a driver had a chance to legally pass another, he would not pass due to respect.

As far as I can tell no one has said otherwise?


graveslids
............but a World Champion? no. Which in reality is the measuring stick for what makes a pilot a pilot in F1.

So that would make the following second class drivers in F1 then?

Stirling Moss
Gilles Villeneuve
Clay Regazzoni

All three first class drivers, yet never World Champion.


graveslids
with safety as the primary focus, bring on the new breed.
Which in my opinion brings us back to the main point. Speed passed a car under yellow, which means that safety was not the prime focus. The reason why you can't pass under yellow is principally safety related, break that and you potentially put the safety of yourself and the other drivers at risk.

By doing so (intentionally or otherwise) Speed broke rules that would have been covered in every driver briefing he would has attended in single seater racing, these briefings are not optional even at this level and failure to attend would revoke a drivers permission to race.

Speed was aware of the rules and aware of the potential penalties, as such his outburst was in no way at all needed, appropriate or justifiable. The only person at fault here was Speed himself, and that would still be the case if DC & Team had reported him (which they did not officially do).

Given the awful safety record of F1 until the '80s there is a very valid reason why the rules and regulations are taken seriously, quite simply they save lives. Any breach of these rules of conduct (intentional or otherwise) should and must be dealt with.

Personally if Speed can't or won't accept this and responsability for the incident in question then he should not be driving, and the same would apply for any other driver who reacts in the same way.

Being 'pumped up' from the action is no excuse or justification at all for his outburst and reaction, as quite simply there is no justification. If he was than angry at the situation then he should have held his temper until he got back to the team bus and kicked a few walls.

Regards

Scaff
 
DQuaN
Although it has never happened, it is possible for a world champ to be a total jerk and lose all respect.
It has to my knowledge in other sports, and I see F1 as no different, although it has thakfully yet to happen.
DQuan
Having been a world champ does not mean you will always have respect regardless of your actions.

In the eyes of the general public it does. Regardless of how great a driver one has been, by and large people only care about winners. It's quite myopic, but that's the reality of things. Not to denegrate the performance of many non-champion drivers, however, typically, only those who care about a given sport recognize the accomplishment that said non-champions have acheived.

Look at it this way, Mike Tyson, former heavy-weight champion of the world, convicted wife beater, ear-munching fighter. Still people see him and go "Oh! It's Mike Tyson, let me get his autograph!" The back story is forgotten due to the shiny belt he once held. Same for a good number of the american football players, by and large they have been "spoiled" since showing exceeding talent in high school, helped through college, paid multi-million dollars when joining the NFL, go about their way peddling drugs, beating wives, drivng drunk, so on, so forth. Regardless, at the point of recognition, specifically record holders or those who have played in the super bowl, still held in regard high enough to be treated in a way elevated from the general public in spite of outside issues.


Scaff
As far as I can tell no one has said otherwise?

This statement is in regards to what Exige had to say. It is me trying to expound my thought processes on what Exige was saying about the sport being dependant upon respect. Which it is, but I still firmly believe, that given the opportunity, a driver will do near whatever is neccesarry for track postion. One only needs look at Montoya's punting of Trulli at Spa I think it was, or Schumi's continual weaving across the track when starting from pole. Or the first corner pile up's that still occur. F1 is a brutal sport just barely kept in check by it's participants due to the highly dangerous penalties of getting out of line.


Scaff
So that would make the following second class drivers in F1 then?

Stirling Moss
Gilles Villeneuve
Clay Regazzoni

All three first class drivers, yet never World Champion.

See above, in the eyes of the general public, only winners count.

Scaff
Which in my opinion brings us back to the main point. Speed passed a car under yellow, which means that safety was not the prime focus.
...as did Ralf...
Scaff
The reason why you can't pass under yellow is principally safety related, break that and you potentially put the safety of yourself and the other drivers at risk.
...in this and every other racing series I can think of...
Scaff
By doing so (intentionally or otherwise) Speed broke rules that would have been covered in every driver briefing he would has attended in single seater racing, these briefings are not optional even at this level and failure to attend would revoke a drivers permission to race.

Speed was aware of the rules and aware of the potential penalties, as such his outburst was in no way at all needed, appropriate or justifiable. The only person at fault here was Speed himself, and that would still be the case if DC & Team had reported him (which they did not officially do).
...as I have said numerous times, I am not defending what was said, merely applauding the young one for standing his ground. For all the reasons that have been brought foraward of him going after Coulthard, it would really have to take some confidence to go after him, especially given the pennance that could be headed his way. Be it right or wrong, and wrong he was, he felt passionately enough about his situation to give voice to his opinion...
Scaff
Given the awful safety record of F1 until the '80s there is a very valid reason why the rules and regulations are taken seriously, quite simply they save lives. Any breach of these rules of conduct (intentional or otherwise) should and must be dealt with.

Personally if Speed can't or won't accept this and responsability for the incident in question then he should not be driving, and the same would apply for any other driver who reacts in the same way.
...if safety were truly the be all, end all, pay drives and Yuji Ide would not exist in F1...
Scaff
Being 'pumped up' from the action is no excuse or justification at all for his outburst and reaction, as quite simply there is no justification. If he was than angry at the situation then he should have held his temper until he got back to the team bus and kicked a few walls.

Regards

Scaff
No doubt the team bus would of taken the frutrations better, but I know from personal experience, adrenaline is a wicked modifier of behaviour. Which is why I brought that point forward.
 
graveslids
Look at it this way, Mike Tyson, former heavy-weight champion of the world, convicted wife beater, ear-munching fighter. Still people see him and go "Oh! It's Mike Tyson, let me get his autograph!" The back story is forgotten due to the shiny belt he once held.
They also reconise great talent regardless of being the champ or not. Sure people woiuld get Mike's autograph, but that doesn't mean they think he's a decent guy, I know I don't, hell I've even met him. Champ or not, I think he was a great boxer, but I don't resepct him.

Also I think most would agree, people like Sterling and Giles are considered legends in the racing world, almost were's. And they hold them in a very, very high regard.

No doubt the team bus would of taken the frutrations better, but I know from personal experience, adrenaline is a wicked modifier of behaviour. Which is why I brought that point forward.
It can show your temper control capabilities, that's what it can do, or in this case, lack of them. He acted like a moron, sure it was in the heat of the moment, but that's no excuse, you keep saying you agree it;s no excuse but it was because of this he did it. So what, he shouldn't have acted like he did, all he told me about himself was that he's a bit of an asshole who may never take responsibility for his own mistakes.
 
graveslids
This statement is in regards to what Exige had to say. It is me trying to expound my thought processes on what Exige was saying about the sport being dependant upon respect. Which it is, but I still firmly believe, that given the opportunity, a driver will do near whatever is neccesarry for track postion. One only needs look at Montoya's punting of Trulli at Spa I think it was, or Schumi's continual weaving across the track when starting from pole. Or the first corner pile up's that still occur. F1 is a brutal sport just barely kept in check by it's participants due to the highly dangerous penalties of getting out of line.

F1 is far from a brutal sport that is barely kept in check, for motorsport of that style simply check-out most touring car series or the V8brutes.

Yes given an oportunity a driver will do all they can to pass, but they will also be aware of the marshalls and the priority of the other drivers on the track. If a driver should yeald to a pass, because the other driver has the position they will do.

Thats not to say that they will give up a place, they will fight (in most cases fairly) for position but to say that if a driver had a chance to legally pass another, he would not pass due to respect. is patently redicuolous and having re-read the enture thread no one has said or suggest such a thing.

In regard to the drivers who have driven in the manner you have described, then (as I have previously said) they should, and often have been warned and in some cases penalised for it.


graveslids
See above, in the eyes of the general public, only winners count.
In the eyes of the general public most figures in motorsport are unknown, champions or not. Walk up to most people in the street and show them pictures of Rossi, Scumacher and Loeb dressed in 'everyday' clothes and most would fail to recognise them.

However exceptions do happen, Stirling Moss is a name that a good number of people in the UK would recognise, even if they had no interest in motorsport.

To those that have a true interest in Motorsport these drivers are legends, that they failed to win the World Championship is a great shame, but it certainly does not make them less reconisable as the talent they were/are.

That is however totally irelivent, as that is not what you said. You stated that being a World Champion ...is the measuring stick for what makes a pilot a pilot in F1.

To put it bluntly if you don't class the three drivers I mentioned as some of the best to have ever sat in a car (particularly Stirling Moss) then quite frankly you don't have a clue what you are talking about.



graveslids
...as did Ralf...
Ahh you mean the driver than in the same race broke the pit-lane speed limit and got given a drive through penalty. Which he took and still managed to finish third, all without blaming someone else and swearing at anyone, remarkable that.



graveslids
...in this and every other racing series I can think of...
Which is why Speed's actions and reactions are all the more inexcusable, its not like it was a new thing.


graveslids
...as I have said numerous times, I am not defending what was said, merely applauding the young one for standing his ground. For all the reasons that have been brought foraward of him going after Coulthard, it would really have to take some confidence to go after him, especially given the pennance that could be headed his way. Be it right or wrong, and wrong he was, he felt passionately enough about his situation to give voice to his opinion...
No he felt angry and frustrated and lashed out in a totally unprofessional and aggressive manner. Confidence had nothing to do with it hot-headed stupidity would be more appropriate terms.

I've lost count of the number of drivers who have lost wins (not a point but a win) because of a technical infringement (sometimes actually reported by another team) and have accepted it as part of the job. They may have gone and kicked the cat afterwards*, but they did not start swearing at whomever they thought was to blame.

The best example I can think of was when Carlos Saintz engine failed a few hundred yards from the finish of the last stage of the last rally of the year (1998 IIRC), which cost him not a single point, or a win, but the entire World Championship.

Yes he was angry, and he did put his helmet through the back window of the car, and seconds after that he had half a dozen TV cameras in his face. He simple and politely told them 'no comment', shrugged his shoulders and walked away. No swearing, no trying to blame anyone else; and that from a man who had just lost the world championship by a few hundered yards.

Speed would do well to watch the tape of that and learn from it.



graveslids
...if safety were truly the be all, end all, pay drives and Yuji Ide would not exist in F1...
No if safety was truely the be all and end all the cars would be limited to 5mph and fitted with big cushions all around.

Pay drivers and Ide still have to meet a certain standard before they can sit in the cockpit of the car and obtaining the required licence for F1 is not like getting your driving licence.

They are few are far between as far as a major problem goes and have never been a huge problem in F1. For a true insight into what has made F1 a much safer sport than it was 20 years ago read Life at the Limit by Prof Sid watkins, that will give you all the insight you need.


graveslids
No doubt the team bus would of taken the frutrations better, but I know from personal experience, adrenaline is a wicked modifier of behaviour. Which is why I brought that point forward.
And if speed can't keep his adrenaline under control when hes out of the car, then will he be able to do so in the car?

If he can't then he's not going to have a very successful career in F1 and he will end up posing a danger to all around him.

For the sake of his own career he needs to learn some self-discipline and fast.

Regards

Scaff


* Scaff in no way supports the kicking of cats - it bad and you should not do it (or chase them with chainsaws, throw dogs at them or anything like that)**


**No, honest I mean it, leave the cat alone.***


***Look if you get arested for animal cruelty now, you can't blame me
 
Back