Famine's Review: Shark Tale

  • Thread starter Famine
  • 20 comments
  • 1,022 views

Famine

GTP Editor, GTPEDIA Author
Administrator
88,487
United Kingdom
Rule 12
GTP_Famine
Dross. I'd rather die than watch it again.















Okay, I'll be a bit more expansive.

The "nice touches" in the animation's background are less detailed and less imaginative than Futurama. In fact, they're marginally less imaginative than a photocopier.

The voice "talent" is exceptionally weak. GMTV presenter Fiona Phillips (a replacement for the UK release) is abysmal as the news reporter. The plot is as bad as it gets - and the excuse that "it's a cartoon" doesn't wash, in the face of The Simpsons, Futurama, Shrek 1 & 2, Toy Story 1 & 2 and, most importantly, Finding Nemo - which did the same job but much, much better a year earlier.

But above all - the one unforgivable thing that I was most worried about - is the racial stereotyping. The white trash golddigger (Angelina Jolie) was poor. The downtrodden ghetto girl (Renee Zellweger - whom I loathe) was straight out of Hollywood Formulaic Character Manual #2. The Rastafarian jellyfish were awful. The Italian Mafiosi sharks were dreadful to the point of laughable. But the worst of the worst - and my number one HATE in films - was Will Smith's "Hey look at me! I'm black! Isn't that hilarious?". He does it in every frickin' film, although not to the extent of the abominable Martin Lawrence (I'd guess he was second choice for the role). Guys - Sydney Poitier refused to take any role which required him to be black. Take a leaf. Pointing out skin colour and the amusing differences between the various races ISN'T emancipation. It's propagation.

Scooping out your brains with a salt-covered ladle, fashioned from the baked remains of your own scrotum is prefereable to this.
 
The Ultimate review...

My little brother (7) and sister (10) thought it was so crap they didn't even murmur when all the DVD ads were on TV.
 
My nephew and neice didn't like it much either, Finding Nemo on the other hand is a film they both loved. I'd agree with that review.
 
You know ...

I haven't seen the movie yet, but from the first picture on I've always thought it is a bad copy of "Finding Nemo" trying to ride its tidal wave. The first things I have seen of it were some short TV teasers, after that the scenes from the music video "Car wash". Yesterday it popped to my mind again, so I watched a trailer on the internet. Only then I noticed that this was my first glance at the movies actual storyline. And now I've read your review, and I must say I'm even more eager to see it now.

You can call me mad but your review has made me curious about this movie. I want to see if I find it as bad as you. I guess it has become a one way street anyway, as I wasn't expecting much in the first place. But I like to give every movie a fair chance, so I'll try to watch this without being biased. Regarding the quality of your review, I suppose I'll get to the same conclusion though. Most of the user reviews which are more like "Cool action and beautiful girls all 'round: go see this!" do make me curious too, but in another way. Usually I discover that these kind of people get a totally different picture of a movie than I do, cause they pay attention to other things (such as girls and action).

Anyway, I'll try to get my hands onto "Sharks Tale" as soon as possible, to see if we really do share our opinion. :sly:

EDIT:
Take a look at http://www.madagascar-themovie.com. Looks very promising if you ask me. :dopey:

Cheers,
the Interceptor
 
With the amount of Fish tanks in our house, was there a doubt that I'd see this film?

After having seen this movie, I have no doubt in my mind that it will win an Oscar.


















Oscar Meyer Weiner, that is.

Yes, bad joke, but certainly funnier than this movie.

AO
 
Famine
Dross. I'd rather die than watch it again.


I've seen the movie -- and it's not that bad...

But above all - the one unforgivable thing that I was most worried about - is the racial stereotyping. The white trash golddigger (Angelina Jolie) was poor. The downtrodden ghetto girl (Renee Zellweger - whom I loathe) was straight out of Hollywood Formulaic Character Manual #2. The Rastafarian jellyfish were awful. The Italian Mafiosi sharks were dreadful to the point of laughable. But the worst of the worst - and my number one HATE in films - was Will Smith's "Hey look at me! I'm black! Isn't that hilarious?". He does it in every frickin' film, although not to the extent of the abominable Martin Lawrence (I'd guess he was second choice for the role). Guys - Sydney Poitier refused to take any role which required him to be black. Take a leaf. Pointing out skin colour and the amusing differences between the various races ISN'T emancipation. It's propagation.

Propogation it may be, but why blame the actors (i.e. Will Smith etc.)? Why not blame the producers, the directors, or even the person/people who wrote the screenplay. They are the ones really responsible for the outcome of the film.

Scooping out your brains with a salt-covered ladle, fashioned from the baked remains of your own scrotum is prefereable to this.

Hmmm. Sounds like fun! :sly:

Not really... :ill:
 
Will Smith does it in every film he's in - although usually to a tolerable extent, unlike Martin "I Am The AntiChrist" Lawrence.
 
I'm not big on computer animated movies, so I wasn't going to see it anyway......... and looks like it will stay that way(thanks for the heads up).

P.S. I did like Finding Nemo. I'd give it an "C+".
 
Famine
Guys - Sydney Poitier refused to take any role which required him to be black.

Somehow I doubt films like "In the Heat of the Night" would have made any sense whatsoever if Poitier wasn't black.

;)
 
Famine
Will Smith does it in every film he's in - although usually to a tolerable extent, unlike Martin "I Am The AntiChrist" Lawrence.

I wouldn't say he's that bad. Look at Chris Rock - he made jokes about it at the Oscars. Actually, it was one of the first things that he said.
 
ala the John Travolta being Oprah's favourite white boy? Yah, I think racial white people jokes are getting a little overboard. I'm sure if a white guy said "and here's John's favourite black man..." there'd be a helluva'n uproar. Will Smith just seems to play on the stereotypical black guy platform, but that's always kind of been him. And wasn't Christina Aguilera and Sean Paul also in Shark Tale? I know it had a lot of famous people in it anyway. You may have already mentioned Aguilera...I just don't care to go up and sift thru and check.
 
Firebird
Somehow I doubt films like "In the Heat of the Night" would have made any sense whatsoever if Poitier wasn't black.

;)
Yeah I was thinking that, the whole racial issue in that film did require a black actor for that part.
 
Propogation it may be, but why blame the actors (i.e. Will Smith etc.)? Why not blame the producers, the directors, or even the person/people who wrote the screenplay. They are the ones really responsible for the outcome of the film.

I think the reason it follows will smith arouond (certainly to a lesser extent than others) is because he ad-libs a lot of his comedy. I'm sure that as the funnyman he gets to write a lot of the jokes as well - and that's why his comedy style remains fairly constant.
 
I enjoyed it. Not really sure why everyone hates it soo much. I think it has something to do with it coming out after Shrek 2. Kinda hard to follow that up.
 
Jack Black may have been the funniest thing in the film, and he's not that funny.

It was ok.

But good gosh, Robert D. Niero(sp)?
I guess he was only in it b/c he "fit" the Shark Mafia thing.
 
Famine
Will Smith does it in every film he's in - although usually to a tolerable extent, unlike Martin "I Am The AntiChrist" Lawrence.

I concur. Martin Lawrence should have remained in stand-up where he was actually funny (at least in my opinion). But I do think even Martin Lawrence is funnier and wittier than Will Smith. In Bad Boys and Bad Boys II, for example. Now, neither of those movies is what you could categorize as "stellar," but they had their respective funny bits. And all of those funny bits were the responsibility of Martin Lawrence.

Every time I see Will Smith walking down the carpet at some movie premier of his or some awards show, strutting like a big male peacock, I start to gag. Doesn't anyone remember how much of an absolute doofus Smith used to be? He had one of the WORST fades in the history of the African-American male, and he personified the most horrifying aspects of the late 80s and early 90s. His rap SUCKED and his Fresh Prince of Bel Air show was mildly amusing at best (but I was usually laughing at Carlton or Uncle Phil).

So why all of a sudden do we have to respect this "fine actor?" Screw Will Smith. Jaime Fox showed more talent in In Living Color than Smith has displayed his entire career. He ruined Ali, he ruined Independence Day (okay, lots of things ruined that movie, including Bill why-is-this-moron-still-allowed-to-act-in-movies Pullman), he ruined (?) Wild Wild West...

In fact, he's ruined virtually every movie he's been in, since he has one character he's able to portray, and that's WILL SMITH. I liked the Men In Black movies, but not because of Will Smith and his torturous music videos.

End rant.
 
*finds self agreeing with Anderton*

That's unusual...

*checks coffee for barbiturates*
 
Famine
But the worst of the worst - and my number one HATE in films - was Will Smith's "Hey look at me! I'm black! Isn't that hilarious?". He does it in every frickin' film, although not to the extent of the abominable Martin Lawrence (I'd guess he was second choice for the role). Guys - Sydney Poitier refused to take any role which required him to be black. Take a leaf. Pointing out skin colour and the amusing differences between the various races ISN'T emancipation. It's propagation.


Heh:tup:

You made me imagine Will Smith in "The Passion Of The Christ".
 
Back