First Floods, now Category FIVE Cyclone Hitting Queensland 10pm tonight :'(

  • Thread starter Thread starter Legendary
  • 82 comments
  • 5,880 views
Can I just make an observation with the debris in Queensland?

Why do people persist in making buildings with metal roofing near the beach? If you're gonna get strong winds at times, that would be the LAST material I would ever use for roofing. I would try to get something more solid and durable to stay on the roof itself.
 
And move them where, exactly? They'd have to find a place 3 or 4 hundred miles away to be sure of being out of the way of the storm, yet the seas are already rough enough to make the voyage difficult if not impossible, and then there's the problem of getting back afterwards, assuming you're not just going to abandon everything else you own and stay with the dang boat.

Were the coastal waters rough on monday when the warning came in?
Depends how fast the million dollar boat is I suppose to how far it can get. But I suppose it's better for insurance to just leave it and claim than give it away or risk trying to move it.
...........

Yasi changed to a category 2 storm awhile ago.
 
Can I just make an observation with the debris in Queensland?

Why do people persist in making buildings with metal roofing near the beach? If you're gonna get strong winds at times, that would be the LAST material I would ever use for roofing. I would try to get something more solid and durable to stay on the roof itself.

Because metal roofing is cheap and easy to replace. You obviously haven't lived on the beach in Hurricane zones.
 
Okay, a couple of you are getting riled up. The people involved know who they are. Of particular concern to me is the way some users are reporting posts to the moderators that, while a little questionable, appear to have been reported primarily because the poster disagrees with the reporter. The moderators are not here to silence people who disagree with you simply because you do not like what they have to say. At the same time, some of those posts that were reported did skirt the rules. Rather than handing out inividual warnings and infractions - I haven't seen anything that truly warrants it yet - I'm just going to post this message to everyone in this thread: behave yourselves, or face our wrath.
 
Can I just make an observation with the debris in Queensland?

Why do people persist in making buildings with metal roofing near the beach? If you're gonna get strong winds at times, that would be the LAST material I would ever use for roofing. I would try to get something more solid and durable to stay on the roof itself.

Alot of coastal houses up in that region are "old Queenslander's" as we call them. Basically houses that were made up to 50 or 60 years ago when the world was normal and it really didn't matter if your house was designed terribly and had asbestos in the roof. I guess when the buildings get knocked around they either pull them down after or just fix them up with the same stuff. Not like they can support a brick roof :D
 
All category 4 and below Casio.

So your point is invalid and you fail again.....it skimmed QLD, re-intensified in the Gulf of Carpentaria and then hit the NT so when it first hit landfall it wasn't a Category 5, it was a Cat 3. Not to mention it's been 24hrs here and Yasi is still a Cat 1 cyclone at Mt.Isa. Monica couldn't even keep it's strength in that time after hitting the NT and turned into a tropical depression, so Yasi is a more destructive cyclone than Monica aswell as lasting for a greater duration.


Yes it is, but feel free to argue with the meterologists and historians that reported those things.

I don't need to, you're doing all the arguing with the meteorologists.

From the Bureau of Meteorology.

---

Cyclone Laurence: . Laurence again reached category 5 strength at 1400 WST 21 December, just prior to crossing the coast around 1700 WST near Wallal, along the 80 Mile Beach, 230 km north east of Port Hedland. There was considerable damage to properties in the area and an estimated 1500 cattle perished.

Cyclone Hamish: Severe Tropical Cyclone Hamish reached category 3 intensity on the 6th March and, in conditions favourable for further development, intensified to category 5 on 7th March.

Cyclone George:George intensified to a Severe Tropical Cyclone (Category 3) on the evening of 7 March and reached Category 5 as it approached the coast. It was still at its maximum intensity when it crossed the coast 50 km northeast of Port Hedland at 10 pm Western Daylight Savings Time (WDT) on Thursday 8 March.

Cyclone Rosita: Tropical Cyclone Rosita was one of the most severe tropical cyclones to cross the west Kimberley coast in the last 100 years. It crossed the coast as a category 5 cyclone 40 kilometres south of Broome at 0100 WST 20 April.

Cyclone Ingrid: It crossed the Queensland east coast south of Lockhart River at Category 4; moved across the Gulf into the Northern Territory and impacted on the small islands north of the Arnhem Land coast as a Category 5 cyclone

---

And no offence to those picture you're showing, because obviously it's a great impact to those who have had houses effected. But a lot of those are just missing steel roofing or some street signs.

I mean, look:
252889-black-street-tully-yasi.jpg

In the background is a weatherboard house raised on timber and it's still standing perfectly fine with little damage.

Jay
See mafia_boy you forget, this means nothing to Casio because their streets always look like this in Melbourne.
Nah, I can't see any needles in those pics.
 
Last edited:
I do agree with Casio's observations on the damage itself. Ultimately its not flattened houses and matchsticks stuff around.

Obviously it is early days so we must wait, but the pictures, at first look, does not seem that bad *yet*
 
_51079955_cairns_cyclone2_464map.gif

This gives an idea of the scale of the storm.
By the way I don't mind it being known that I reported more than one of the posts in this thread.
 
Last edited:
wow, the ignorance in this thread is amazing. You see, the people that build these houses are not stupid. They understand they live in an area that is battered by cyclones regularly so building are build a hell of alot different. Most houses up there are now built to survive hurricanes upwards of cat 5. Their building regulations are completely different thus you won't find many houses outside the centre of the eye with massive damage.
 
Noteworthy photos I've come across:







 
Last edited:
Now, it's flooding here. We had to move the car out since it's pretty low and our car port was quickly getting filled, water came up to where the bumpers/sideskirts started so we quickly moved it into a higher ground. Eventually my entire driveway became a river since the road's water builds up into our driveway. The road outside my house is uncrossable with a car, I have honestly never seen water this high before. And that was only with 10 minutes of extremely hard rain.
 
Damnation. Got a screwdriver handy to pop out the ECU just in case?
 
Ah it's fine now at higher ground, the water level would have to triple to reach there, if that doesn't stop it, nothing will.
 
Ah it's fine now at higher ground, the water level would have to triple to reach there, if that doesn't stop it, nothing will.

Sooo, you seem to like paying me out about North Lakes becoming a 'North Lake' yet you are in a worse position then I ever was while my whole state was underwater :lol:.

Sorry but thats pretty ironic :D.
 
wow, the ignorance in this thread is amazing. You see, the people that build these houses are not stupid. They understand they live in an area that is battered by cyclones regularly so building are build a hell of alot different. Most houses up there are now built to survive hurricanes upwards of cat 5. Their building regulations are completely different thus you won't find many houses outside the centre of the eye with massive damage.

This. My uncle and Aunt's house in Cairns is built to withstand a Cat 4 I think. I believe their plan was to stay in a windowless room and if that was breached then some walk in wardrobe or something... I hope that worked out for them...
 
We in Ashburton here in Melbourne got within probably 20cm of having to shift out for the night on safety grounds... Gardiner's Creek rose about 8 metres or something dumb like that.
 
wow, the ignorance in this thread is amazing. You see, the people that build these houses are not stupid. They understand they live in an area that is battered by cyclones regularly so building are build a hell of alot different. Most houses up there are now built to survive hurricanes upwards of cat 5. Their building regulations are completely different thus you won't find many houses outside the centre of the eye with massive damage.


I was wondering why some people were calling for loads of death and destruction, when I thought that, logically, the buildings *should* be able to withstand some form of cyclones and strong winds as the area often seems to get battered like a boxer's nose quite often.

I was surprised at the metal roofing stuff, but having read some members reasoning for it, it sounds ok....just a bit counterintutive to me.

However, the picture of the boats...just wow.
 
So after a month of floods and now this cyclone, basically the only unaffected city in Queensland is the Gold Coast, right?

P.S: I feel for those Queenslanders affected
 
Back