GT5 + FM4 chalk and cheese?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gallinho
  • 12 comments
  • 1,768 views
Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
36
United Kingdom
United Kingdom
Messages
GALLINHO
So I've been playing the Gt series forever, only ever having owned playstations, but after all the hype surrounding Forza I thought I'd buy a second hand xbox and see what all the fuss was about. I got the fanatic csr and sold my g25 and was expecting great things, I imagined forza to be pretty much the same as Gt only tighter, slicker and more community focused.

So after playing it for just under a month I have to say I don't think it's anything like Gt! There's no endurance racing (in the whole event list you dont race more than ten laps in one race and you dont have to pit once in your whole career!) ,no day/night cycle, no dynamic weather, no open wheel racing, no race series or championships with leaderboards and there's no rally.
What it has got though is an incredibly slck interface and menu's aswell as awesome online integration with leaderboards for practically everything you do. Rivals is also very addictive! But I feel this game is aimed very much at the casual gamer, it practically throws money and cars at you and makes coming back to grind credits on Gt5 even more laborious!

So, here's the thing, after reading all the reviews and all the fanboys baiting each other I thought that playing forza would make forget all about Gt5 but it's actually made me appreciate it more. After knocking off a few events and doing a few rivals on fm4 it leaves me wanting something abit more substantial and that's why I've started playing Gt5 again , doing all the endurance races and trying to gold all the specials.

So instead of these games being direct rivals i actually think they compliment each other really well!
 
'GT5' and 'FM4' in the same thread title = locked thread.

There is a GT5 vs FM thread somewhere that you can compare them in.
 
I actually enjoyed reading the OP and agree. FM is for the casual racer and GT is for the enthusiast. Great OP 👍
 
Cool comparison. 👍 :D
 
So I've been playing the Gt series forever, only ever having owned playstations, but after all the hype surrounding Forza I thought I'd buy a second hand xbox and see what all the fuss was about. I got the fanatic csr and sold my g25 and was expecting great things, I imagined forza to be pretty much the same as Gt only tighter, slicker and more community focused.

So after playing it for just under a month I have to say I don't think it's anything like Gt! There's no endurance racing (in the whole event list you dont race more than ten laps in one race and you dont have to pit once in your whole career!) ,no day/night cycle, no dynamic weather, no open wheel racing, no race series or championships with leaderboards and there's no rally.
What it has got though is an incredibly slck interface and menu's aswell as awesome online integration with leaderboards for practically everything you do. Rivals is also very addictive! But I feel this game is aimed very much at the casual gamer, it practically throws money and cars at you and makes coming back to grind credits on Gt5 even more laborious!

So, here's the thing, after reading all the reviews and all the fanboys baiting each other I thought that playing forza would make forget all about Gt5 but it's actually made me appreciate it more. After knocking off a few events and doing a few rivals on fm4 it leaves me wanting something abit more substantial and that's why I've started playing Gt5 again , doing all the endurance races and trying to gold all the specials.

So instead of these games being direct rivals i actually think they compliment each other really well!
Exactly and

DUHHH. lol 👍

I agree with Cowboys965 and Jedi09. I don't ever see people comparing the games like this.
 
Sounds like you messed up by selling your wheel... Maybe you should have waited.
 
There's no endurance racing (in the whole event list you dont race more than ten laps in one race and you dont have to pit once in your whole career!) ,no day/night cycle, no dynamic weather, no open wheel racing, no race series or championships with leaderboards and there's no rally.

... bwahahahahahah
 
trk29
Sounds like you messed up by selling your wheel... Maybe you should have waited.

Yeah was thinking that, went for it bcoz of the multiplatform compatibility but tbh you get faster laptimes on the controller in forza, which is wierd bcoz I can't even play gt5 with the pad!
Still it's a good wheel just hoping they fix all the bugs and issues.
 
Sounds like you messed up by selling your wheel... Maybe you should have waited.
The CSR is compatible for more games than the G25. I only know this because I checked to see how much it cost. Too much.

I DIDN'T know about the bugs.
 
I love both games and each have pros and cons but the biggest disappointment for me with FM4 is the fact that there are no endurance races. Other than that I am enjoying it.
 
I guess you can´t be considered a true GTPlanet member until you get your first Forza vs. GT thread locked :D

Anyway, I liked your comparison. You got the points straight. Really good, man. To be honest, although I´ve also been a GT player (since the late 90´s in my case), I wouldn´t ming getting my hands on Forza. Looks like a fair game to me, at least better than any other racer other than GT.
 
Flogging...horse....you get the picture.

There is already a "vs" physics thread in the GT5 Q&A section and a "vs" thread in the Forza section - please add your thoughts where appropriate to those ones. 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back