Best choice:
1994-1996 Volvo 850 Turbo sedan
1994: $3800-$5200
1995: $4500-$6000
1996: $5500-$6900
- 222-horsepower 2.3-liter turbocharged five-cylinder
- 0-60 in 7.1 seconds
- 1/4 mile in 15.2 seconds @ 93mph
- Standard power sunroof, heated leather, tri-mode automatic transmission, heated power mirrors, 16" alloy wheels, four-wheel all-disc ABS, dual-zone automatic climate control w/ five vents, side airbags (95-96)
- EPA rated 22.5mpg
- The best performance-oriented used car under $10000
-
Drive it before you say no: this thing is QUICK
Or...
1990-1994 Mitsubishi Eclipse GSX
1990: $1300-$2200
1991: $1600-$2500
1992: $2000-$3000
1993: $2400-$3500
1994: $2900-$4100
- 195-horsepower 2-liter turbocharged four-cylinder
- 0-60 in 6.9 seconds
- 1/4 mile in 15.1 seconds
- Same vehicle as Eagle Talon, owned by Chrysler; you said you didn't want "mopar products" so you might prefer the Mitsubishi, but the Talon depreciated more so it'll be cheaper used
- All-wheel drive standard, or you could get the Eclipse GS Turbo, which was front-drive only
- EPA rated 24.5mpg (w/ manual transmission)
- The best performance-oriented used car under $5000