Jailbreaking illegal again?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gt5 fan
  • 15 comments
  • 1,486 views
Messages
724
I was just googling about jailbreaking just now and I have seen some posts in February saying jailbreaking could become ilegal again in 2012 as part of the DMCA. Do any of you lot have a confirmation to say that jailbreaking is/is not illegal

PLEASE don't say it is/is not illegal if you DON'T KNOW.
 
You won't slow it down.

If the makers were going to get taken down I think their last ditch act would be to release the source code so others can continue to jailbreak.
 
Grayfox
YOU won't slow it down.

If the makers were going to get taken down I think their last ditch act would be to release the source code so others can continue to jailbreak.

How would I slow it down?
 
Not you, but if the jail breakers are going to be busted by the feds the last thing they will most likely do is release the source code on some server that can't be touched by the US.

Heck even if the US can get that site to remove the code anyone that has seen the code will spread it even more.
 
Grayfox
Not you, but if the jail breakers are going to be busted by the feds the last thing they will most likely do is release the source code on some server that can't be touched by the US.

Heck even if the US can get that site to remove the code anyone that has seen the code will spread it even more.

Ok.
 
Jailbreaking can't ever be illegal, you cannot be told what you can and cannot do with your own devices. In my opinion.
 
jimftr
Jailbreaking can't ever be illegal, you cannot be told what you can and cannot do with your own devices. In my opinion.

This a million times over. You bought the device with your own money from a company. After that if you want to instantly smash it onto the floor in front of everyone you can. You legally own it. Even the thought of making jail breaking illegal is disgusting. Completely taking away the freedom. Best they can legally do is not honor the warranty of your device if it was jail broken and something went wrong. That is fair.

These companies think they can do anything just because they have lots of money and pay off all these government officials to vote for bills that they want. Look at the mega upload guy. If you have been following the case they charged him for crimes he didn't commit and did it with all the wrong warrants. He is suing and so far winning all the battles.
 
The mega ulpoad guy is weird as fuu though haha

Im not really worried about jail breaking or internet censorship, as there will always be a way. lol
 
This a million times over. You bought the device with your own money from a company. After that if you want to instantly smash it onto the floor in front of everyone you can. You legally own it. Even the thought of making jail breaking illegal is disgusting. Completely taking away the freedom. Best they can legally do is not honor the warranty of your device if it was jail broken and something went wrong. That is fair.

These companies think they can do anything just because they have lots of money and pay off all these government officials to vote for bills that they want. Look at the mega upload guy. If you have been following the case they charged him for crimes he didn't commit and did it with all the wrong warrants. He is suing and so far winning all the battles.

The problem is when jailbreaking cuts into online services. Such as iPhone's getting apps for free and people modding online on the PSN. You don't own those services therefore they can make it illegal, since most, if not all forms of jailbreaking cut into something other than the device you're doing it to.
 
I think if you are hacking the software itself, then it is technically illegal.

Much like any game you own, or for example Windows. By buying the game/OS you buy a license for personal use (sometimes can be used on several computers). You are not permitted to edit or distribute it in any way, free or otherwise.

That's why there's usually a little check-box when you first open/switch on/start/run any software or hardware [I have read and agree to the terms and conditions] that we all tick but never actually read.
 
If you have been following the case they charged him for crimes he didn't commit and did it with all the wrong warrants. He is suing and so far winning all the battles.

I've been following it, and that had me in stitches. And he gets free publicity for his new projects (rumored music project)

On the rooting (i hate the jailbreaking term), I understand the industry like Sony, who argues that the material (hardware) is infact yours, and you can do with it what you want, but the software is theirs (especially when they update it the whole time).
I understand it, but on the other side, it is still not fully regulated what in the modern time is considered a good and a service, when talking about digital media.

Games for exemple for me are goods. Updated MP's are services. MS had to take a bullet in this sector a few months ago, when they sued a german company that buys and sells old Win keys.
Windows lost. The keys are legit keys and were considered goods by the judge.

This is long from over. And we the customers need also to make a stand for it, because if it would go the companies will, everything would be a service, meaning more regular fees, discontinuation of use as they please,...

In germany for exemple you pay a small fee on every recording device (CD's, usb sticks, dvd players,...) to the content industry to compensate for the private copy which is legal. But it is illegal to bypass security mesures to make a private copy. Making it impossible in modern days to make a private copy, yet you still pay the extra fees. Kind of ridiculous

And for the rooting, it's the process of rooting that is in question?
So in theory, you could root it outside the US during holydays and be one the legal side?
 
Jailbreaking they can't stop even with a million laws people won't care and will still do it. They are just mad that they have a team of pros and spends millions of dollars to make this software than like 2hrs after its released some 16yr old kid finds a loop hole. They could possibly try to go after the head people, but again it won't do anything look how many people are in the world another person will pop up and take over. This whole copyright media laws in general are useless. What helped them make money in the past is actually hurting them now. They have to figure out creative ways to make the customer not want to jailbreak or pirate movies, software, etc. its not gonna be stopped its like the war on drugs you will never win. Quit while your head and put all your man power into ways to make it seem less attractive.
 

Latest Posts

Back