My hardest-ever client needs a laptop

GilesGuthrie

Staff Emeritus
11,038
United Kingdom
Edinburgh, UK
CMDRTheDarkLord
Yep, I have been instructed by none other than my mother to source a laptop for her. And, Planeteers, I need your help.

Requirement: to use the internet for communication with friends and family. Some photo sharing, but mainly photo viewing. Perhaps some Skype use, but probably audio-only. Online shopping. Some writing of letters. No games. Probably some video (mainly BBC iPlayer) watching. Something with at least a 14" screen, but I'm not sure that a big 17" beast is really required.

The Location: My parents' house is quite big, but is adequately covered by a WPA-secured wireless network connected to an ADSL internet source running at around 5Mb. There's little scope for leakage. My father has a computer, and there is to be absolute security of data between the two PCs. If either of them suspects that the other is spying on them, it will be a nightmare. I am the sole source of support for both parents, and they are 300 miles away.

Operator Knowledge: None

Prerequisites: It has to be a PC, because I have to be able to remotely support it, which means I have to be able to imagine what's on the screen, and I simply don't know enough about Mac OS to do that.

Budget: Unlimited. But see "other factors"

Other Factors: The machine has to last for at least three years - barring any force majeur mishap. It has to be something she wants to use, so something a little "interesting" to look at, and probably less than 3Kg. She's going to go on a residential training course for people of her age, so can be considered to have a very basic knowledge of using a computer.

Thoughts?

I've seen a Sony Vaio (VGN-CR42) that I thought might fit the bill. One of the ultra-light Toshibas is a possibility too.
 
Seeing the things she will be using the computer for, I'd say even a 1Gb dual-core machine is pure overkill and waste of money. A 512Mb RAM Intel Celeron machine would do that job perfectly, or get a cheap machine at Dell (Vostro series, with XP)
 
Yeah, XP would be good, because it would be easier for me to support (I'm yet to make the move to Vista at home or at work). But shooting that low on the performance scale will sell me short come 2010. I think she's expecting to pay £800-£1000, and I might as well make use of that latitude in sourcing something she can use for a while. Dell are a potential source because of the ease of availability of on-site support.
 
I just build 2 Dell's and both came within £60 of each other but spec-wise that £60 is pretty big. Since Dell stopped letting you see your E-Value code, I had to go with a pdf (see attached).

Alternatively, a stock (no add-on's) Inspiron 1525 clocks in at £379. Personally, I'd never go with a Celeron, especially when a C2D can be had for a few £'s more.

And for the record, I love my Inspiron. :D
 
Before you buy GG check out CCL Computers

They are a local store to me in Yorkshire but do deliver to rest of UK, they are cheap but they stock all types of makes and models. As far as computer choice goes, I would have said a Mac but as you point out you need to be able to sort it out for her if the need arrises, Sony, Toshiba or IBM are your best bets.

Hope that helps.
 
Found this on Sprite's CCL site: http://www.cclonline.com/product-info.asp?product_id=19521&category_id=585&manufacturer_id=0

* Acer Extensa 5620 Notebook
* Intel Core 2 Duo (T5250) 1.5 GHz Processor with 667 MHz FSB and 2048 KB L2 Cache
* 2048MB DDR2 Memory
* 120 GB Serial ATA Hard Disk
* 15.4 inch WXGA TFT display
* DVD-Super Multi Double Layer drive
* Fax/Modem 56 Kbps
* Gigabit LAN and Wireless LAN
* 5 in 1 Card Reader
* Microsoft Windows XP Professional
* 1 Year Carry in Warranty


Looks like it fits the bill, and is 428.08 GBP w/ VAT.
 
Back