On another subject, could you do it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LoudMusic
  • 55 comments
  • 1,443 views
He was in a sort of canyon...no trees there. I would rather die than sever a part of my body off...even if it was a toe.
 
Originally posted by DODGE the VIPER
He was in a sort of canyon...no trees there. I would rather die than sever a part of my body off...even if it was a toe.
I'd eat my fingers and toes... hang on, skip the fingers. How else would I type these words?
 
I heard about this story this morning. I think once the human body and mind once pushed to a certain point, you could do amazing things. I think I would do it. Still amazing story! Gave my arms pains just thinking about it.
 
Well if I was stting there with a boulder on my arm for 5 days, I would have cut my arm off in sheer boredom. Then I would have died from the bloodloss, mainly because I wouldn't have a freakin' (™ Christiaan) clue on how to tornicay the wound.
 
I'm sure that in five days sufficient desperation would have kicked in and I would have tried it as well. Right now, the thought of doing that to myself makes me feel sick, but then I haven't been lying under a rock for five days.

I wonder why nobody thought to go looking for him...
 
ok, good luck trying to knaw the bone away w/ a pocket knife. i just don't see it happening. i thing the bone may have been broken buy the boulder and it was amputated there, in the shattered section of bone.
 
At first thought about that experience, the first thing that came to mind was: Could I do that?....

My first gut reaction would be, No Way, but after further thinking about the alternatives..., and the fact that his arm's nerves were probably already dead from the injury and the shock, or that the pain threshold was so high at that point, you can see that extreem of a solution being administrated by extreem actions.

I just hope that I'm never put into that situation... :eek:
 
First off,... all this talk about 'could saved the arm',... first thing that comes to mind is "hindsight is always 20/20" ;)

This dude climbed 49 of CO's highest cliffs,... he knows what he's doing. If he cut his arm off, it was for a good reason.

And yeah, I'd do it too.
 
DAMN. now that's some really freaky stuff. i couldn't rightly say what i'd do if i had my arm stuck under a thousand pound boulder...but thinking about cutting my arm off is really unnerving. there are so many things that would be nearly impossible without it, like playing drums, and playing bass, and using a mouse and a keyboard at the same time.
 
Yes, of course, the pain of sawing off his arm was terrible, said Ralston, 27, a mechanical engineer-turned-adventurer. “I’m not sure how I handled it. I felt pain. I coped with it. I moved on. ...
“I did what I had to do.”

‘GOING THROUGH EACH OPTION’
“I began laying plans ... and the next five days until I was rescued … I spent going through each option,” he told reporters Thursday at St. Mary’s Hospital in Grand Junction.
He threw himself against the boulder, over and over, to shift it.
He used the rope and pulleys in his climbing gear to rig a hoist to lift it.
He used a “multiuse tool” — similar to a pocketknife, but with multiple blades for different tasks — to try to carve the rock away where it was pinning his arm, just below the wrist.
No dice.
Finally, by April 29, his third day in the canyon, his food and water — a liter of water, two burritos and crumbs on a couple of candy wrappers — were running low. Ralston concluded that he would have to cut off his arm if he were to survive. By then, he said, “the courage became more about pragmatics.”
Before beginning, Ralston prepared a tourniquet, pulled some bicycling shorts out of his backpack to put on the wound and packed his other belongings so he could quickly leave after he was done.
“Essentially, I got my surgical table ready,” he said.
But his initial attempt to sever the limb was sobering. He was using the same knife with which he’d tried to carve away the boulder, a folding device that typically has knife blades, pliers, screwdrivers and other gadgets.
It was “what you’d get if you bought a $15 flashlight and got a free multiuse tool,” he said. It was so dull by then that “I couldn’t even cut the hair off my arm.”
The next day, after finishing the last sips of his water, he tried again. This time, he was able to puncture the skin, but he found he couldn’t cut the bone beneath.
By Thursday morning, he concluded that he had only one more chance.
“I realized that it was the last opportunity that I could have and still have the physical strength to get out where help would find me,” he said.
This time, he twisted his arm, torqueing the bones until they broke.
“I was able to first snap the radius and then, within another few minutes, snap the ulna at the wrist, and from there, I had the knife out and applied the tourniquet and went to the task,” he said.
“It was a process that took about an hour.”
But Ralston’s ordeal was by no means over. Blue John Canyon is as remote as it gets in Canyonlands National Park, and he had many miles to navigate, bleeding and dehydrated, before he could hope to find help.
With the stump of his arm wrapped in the makeshift tourniquet, Ralston still faced a 150-foot crawl through a rock-clogged fissure. Then, one-handed, he had to rappel down a sheer face of rock. Then came a hike of about six miles. Only then did he run into the Dutch tourist family who went for help.


Now, after reading that, I can honestly say if I was in his place I would have died there. There's no way in hell I could do what he did. That's a lot more than just cutting an arm off.

Do any of you still think you could do it?
 
That is just incredible. Watching that interview he gave on TV was amazing (yet sad) to listen to. He sounds like a very, very educated and smart man.
 
Animals are known to chew their own foot off when caught in a trap. I guess in life or death situations we tend to revert a bit (:
 
After having your arm pinned under 200 pounds of rock, I doubt he would have been able to feel much. The arm was most definitely "dead," meaning the tissue and nerves etc. were cut off from blood supply for so long that they simply die.

Though his whole arm was probably somewhat numb, I assume the gore factor would be the hard part to get over, in that he was actually cutting his own arm off.

But please spare me the "human spirit" crap, it's cliche. Sorry demon, but I can't stand these kinds of stories, particularly when they put them on the local news and end off with a line like yours. GAG!

On second thought, what makes this story unique was the fact that he then had to shimmy down a rock and hoof it to safety, and do it "with one arm tied behind his back!" Sorry, couldn't help myself.
 
couldnt he have just dislocated his elbow, and then tear it out? i mean, u wouldnt have little fragments of bone and sharp point and nasty tiwsted snapping...anyway, some family friend had her finger pulled clear off in like half a second by an automatic garage door...just had the little rope tied around when sumone pushed the button :dopey: .
 
Well 2 of my Uncles and 1 Aunty all cut their Ring finger off with a Butcher knife. Exactly the same for all of them. How's that for chance?
 
Anderton
But please spare me the "human spirit" crap, it's cliche. Sorry demon, but I can't stand these kinds of stories, particularly when they put them on the local news and end off with a line like yours. GAG!
Dude, he wasn't saying spirit as in soul, he meant spirit as in the force that might keep one from giving up. Are you really that moronic?

I don't think I could do it, I imagine I'd die up there. :scared:
 
Drifting Thunda
Well then if he has such a problem with something like that then he doesn't belong on a message board. Just my $0.02. Deal with shiot.
Dude, a message board is exactly for this type of stuff. It's called an opinion, and everyone's got one.

You need to calm down. 'Bout a 9 on the tension scale...
 
Back