Remove "normal car" restriction from seasonals?

  • Thread starter Thread starter iLex
  • 13 comments
  • 2,438 views
Messages
1,155
Messages
gtp_iLex
I've been wondering for some time now: Shouldn't PD remove the 'normal car' restriction from seasonals?
I mean the A-spec seasonals and not the time trials.

Here's my train of thought:
Because of the way PP is calculated and the fact that there is no restriction to tyres, winning any A-spec event is very easy. It's just a case of picking the right car, putting RS tyres under it and you have the lead at the end of the first lap. The 'normal car' restriction does not make it harder to win the event. It just locks out a few cars that would make it just as easy as any of the other normal top cars.
In other words I don't see any spoiling of the events when tuned cars are allowed.

If the PP system works a bit the racing modifications should give a car a relatively hight PP value (for the horses and kilos of the car) and should be as competitive as a normal car of the same value.

For people who actually like the challenge nothing changes. I've driven seasonals on tyres that were a grade below allowed, I've driven cars many PPs under average and I would certainly be able to find some nice "TC" cars that will give me a challenge too.

As seasonals have a feeling of a 'track day' I like using them instead of using the Practice mode to try out new cars. If I really want to know lap times I go to practice mode, but for the enjoyment of the handling I use seasonals.
I bought a nice set of tuned cars in the first DLC. Most of these cars aren't even close to competitive in the high PP range events (which do permit race cars). All the TC cars are just in my garage waiting to be driven. Ofcourse I could go arcade with them, but as I stated before I like the seasonals better.
Besides that, the monetary gain from seasonals helps me get more cars, which by now becomes interesting for me.

I see no reason to keep the 'normal car' restrictions there. Your thoughts please :D

edit: I am not talking about time trials, I am talking about the A-spec seasonals in which you compete against AI opponents.
 
Last edited:
Example:
Time Trial Challenge , time to beat 1:30:000 [Normal Car]
The time to beat was make a beat with a normal car
u want beat it with a Gran Turismo Red Bull X2011 Prototype '11 ?
These are rules.
 
Uhh, the OP excluded time trials from his suggestion.

To the OP: In general, PD seems to have a strange philosophy of withholding very simple-to-make content from the players, as well as preventing players from generating their own.
 
I think the normal car restriction is a good thing.
I would even like the time trials to have a list of cars to chose from.

That way people can not just limit the power on the GSX-R 4 and the 2J to meet the power limit.
And we might see some other cars in the top 100 ;)
 
Guys, I specifically EXCLUDED time trials!

The reason why I did this was that in Time Trials your competition is the rest of the world. Those might indeed need even more restrictions. That's not what I want to discuss.

I am only talking about the A-spec seasonals in which you compete against AI opponents.
 
Doesn't make sense to make DLC cars available, then limit the use of them!

In addition to the TCs in seasonal, you can't use the DLC Mini in A-spec mini challenge
probably other restrictions, that should be fairly easy to patch/update
 
Guys, I specifically EXCLUDED time trials!

The reason why I did this was that in Time Trials your competition is the rest of the world. Those might indeed need even more restrictions. That's not what I want to discuss.

I am only talking about the A-spec seasonals in which you compete against AI opponents.

In that case you might be on to something.
I'd love to take the capuchino RM to the 500PP seasonal.

But there might be a chance we'll get something for it.
 
I'd like to see this as well. Before they removed all the older seasonals, that was pretty much how I messed around with all my new cars, racing and road-legal. More fun than just making laps alone in practice mode, and it earned some cash at the same time. It's still trivial for players to make the A-spec seasonal events ridiculously easy even with the restriction (just slap some racing softs on a max-PP road car or use one of the many gimmick race car prototype "road cars" in the game and it will destroy the rest of the field by the halfway point, even if you drive like Steven Wallace), so the non-racecar restriction seems pretty pointless.
 
I think the normal car restriction is a good thing.
I would even like the time trials to have a list of cars to chose from.

That way people can not just limit the power on the GSX-R 4 and the 2J to meet the power limit.
And we might see some other cars in the top 100 ;)
I am with you on this idea, but IMO having TT's with a list of available cars does not make much difference from having a TT restricted to one model of car only. everyone would just pick the fastest car within the parameters for their TT as long as there are more than one model of car to use, and not really fair to those who do not own the fastest of the bunch (like the latest spa dry TT the fastest drivers all ran R390GT1 Road Car, and that is something not in my collection nor has it appeared in my used car lot for a year and something since GT5 came around).
 
There's a ****load of stuff PD needs to fix before they get this far.
 
mattmflok
I am with you on this idea, but IMO having TT's with a list of available cars does not make much difference from having a TT restricted to one model of car only. everyone would just pick the fastest car within the parameters for their TT as long as there are more than one model of car to use, and not really fair to those who do not own the fastest of the bunch (like the latest spa dry TT the fastest drivers all ran R390GT1 Road Car, and that is something not in my collection nor has it appeared in my used car lot for a year and something since GT5 came around).

I've had the r390 appear 3 times in the ucd if memory serves me right.
 
In that case you might be on to something.
I'd love to take the capuchino RM to the 500PP seasonal.

But there might be a chance we'll get something for it.

That and all my DLC TC cars!!!

I'd like to see this as well. Before they removed all the older seasonals, that was pretty much how I messed around with all my new cars, racing and road-legal. More fun than just making laps alone in practice mode, and it earned some cash at the same time. It's still trivial for players to make the A-spec seasonal events ridiculously easy even with the restriction (just slap some racing softs on a max-PP road car or use one of the many gimmick race car prototype "road cars" in the game and it will destroy the rest of the field by the halfway point, even if you drive like Steven Wallace), so the non-racecar restriction seems pretty pointless.

I completely agree.


There's a ****load of stuff PD needs to fix before they get this far.

This has nothing to do with fixing anything. With each new seasonal they create a set of restrictions. The only thing they have to do is not use the 'normal car' restriction on new seasonals.
But then again, a thread without this comment is no valid thread I guess...
 
Back