Signs of water seen on planet outside solar system

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pebb
  • 8 comments
  • 679 views
Messages
16,737
England
Southampton, UK
Messages
Pebb--
Messages
Pebb
Source: Yahoo News

2007_04_10t204222_450x360_us_planet_water.jpg


Evidence of water has been detected for the first time in a planet outside our solar system, an astronomer said on Tuesday, a tantalizing find for scientists eager to know whether life exists beyond Earth.

Travis Barman, an astronomer at Lowell Observatory in Flagstaff, Arizona, said water vapor has been found in the atmosphere of a large, Jupiter-like gaseous planet located 150 light years from Earth in the constellation Pegasus. The planet is known as HD 209458b.

Other scientists reported in February that they were unable to find evidence of water in this planet's atmosphere, as well as another Jupiter-like planet.

"I'm very confident," Barman said in an interview. "It's definitely good news because water has been predicted to be present in the atmosphere of this planet and many of the other ones for some time."

Lowell Observatory, a privately owned astronomical research institution, announced the finding, which has been accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal. The research was backed by
NASA, it said.

The detection of the presence of water vapor was possible because this planet, from the vantage point of Earth, orbits directly in front of its star every 3-1/2 days, allowing crucial measurements to be made. It is what is known as a transiting planet.

Scientists searching for signs of life beyond Earth are keen to learn about the presence of water on other planets -- both in and beyond our solar system -- because water is thought to be fundamental to the existence of life.

Barman noted that a Jupiter-like gaseous planet such as this one, as opposed to a rocky one like Earth, is highly unlikely to harbor life, and said the finding about water vapor in its atmosphere does not answer one way or another questions about the existence of extraterrestrial life.

'PART OF PUZZLE'

The findings, he said, "are not adequate to really address a question as deep and profound as the existence of life elsewhere. We're not there yet."

"Certainly this is part of that puzzle -- understanding the distribution of water in other solar systems is important for understanding whether or not conditions for life are possible. The presence of water does not exclude the possibility of life, but it doesn't mean it's there, either," Barman added.

He said his findings do provide good reason to believe other planets beyond our solar system also have water vapor in their atmospheres.

The conclusions stemmed from an analysis of
Hubble Space Telescope measurements by Harvard University's Heather Knutson and new theoretical models developed by Barman, Lowell Observatory said.

Water is plentiful on Earth and has been found elsewhere in our solar system, for example in large deposits of ice at the north and south poles of Mars.

Planet HD 209458b also was the first planet outside the solar system found with an atmosphere and the first detected transiting planet. There are more than 200 known planets outside our solar system.
 
You really spread news everywhere, don't you? ;)

On topic, I think this is a great discovery, not just because water might be there, but the fact we might have discovered it. This is what has impressed the most in the past years:

Wasn't it in 1995 we discovered the first planet in another solarsystem? I heard National Geographic saying something like that. And look as us now, 2007 and we are able to view lightyears into space 👍

Correct me if I'm wrong BTW 👍
 
One thing I'll never understand is why we as humans think the only way life can survive is if it has water. For all we know life elsewhere could have evolved to drink and survive in other liquids.

This is cool though, with water on another planet there is a chance for us to find life similar to ours.
 
One thing I'll never understand is why we as humans think the only way life can survive is if it has water. For all we know life elsewhere could have evolved to drink and survive in other liquids.

This is cool though, with water on another planet there is a chance for us to find life similar to ours.

I agree with you there, how can they be certain that all living things have to be based on an oxygen environment, of course this is how it happens on earth but it could surely happen another way on one of the planets put there.

Perhaps a more informed person could clarify why it is only water that supports life and there can't be any substitute?

Or does this have something to do with the fact that if it functions in a different way it isn't classed as 'living'.
 
One thing I'll never understand is why we as humans think the only way life can survive is if it has water. For all we know life elsewhere could have evolved to drink and survive in other liquids.

This is cool though, with water on another planet there is a chance for us to find life similar to ours.

Well one reason that we look for water is because typically if there is water then there is also life. Also the only life that we know of needs the conditions on earth in some way. If we found a planet that had life but under different conditions then we know that can support life then we would look for planets with similar conditions to that planet and earth.
 
Or does this have something to do with the fact that if it functions in a different way it isn't classed as 'living'.

That's pretty much the best thing I can find for an explanation. I would assume Mr. Famine would have more of an expert and a better informed opinion on the subject.
 
Read this

To claim that there's life anywhere else is pretty crazy if you ask me. The extreme particulars here on earth that allow life would have to be perfectly copied.

Wikipedia
The distance of the Earth from the Sun, as well as its orbital eccentricity, rate of rotation, axial tilt, geological history, sustaining atmosphere and protective magnetic field all contribute to the conditions necessary to originate and sustain life on this planet.


Not only that, but even the other planets in our solar system that can't even sustain life, still help Earth to.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comet_Shoemaker-Levy_9

So, to me finding some water vapor somewhere isn't anything for me to get excited over. Just my $.02
 
There are literally billions and billions of planets in our galaxy alone, and if they odds are 10 billion to one that life will spring up you are likely to see at least a few planets that have life in the galaxy, not counting the other galaxies.
 
HD 209458b

These scientists are so very clever, but they lack any kind of imagination.

If we did find life their, we'd have to call them HD (High Definition and Aliens, coincidence? I think not ;)) 209458bians
 
Back