Originally posted by M5Power
Pfft, you're a liberal - you love paying taxes.
Well, I have a theory on Stamp Duty in NSW.
Since it's an upfront requirement (i.e. you can't finance it, you have to cough up the money on top of your deposit), I contend that if you remove it, the following will happen (bear with me, the logic's a little complex).
Since you no longer have to find a large sum of cash up front, then under the concept of present value, if you think of the large lump sum as the present value of a stream of payments, you'd be prepared to pay extra each month on top of your mortgage in place of the upfront tax payment - e.g. you'd pay an extra $654 a month on your mortgage a month to avoid a $10,000 payment at the start.
On this basis, I believe that if they abolished stamp duty, then the value of a $700,000 house in Sydney would go up by about $100-150,000 overnight.
So, having paid this tax, I am of course now in favour of dropping it.
I don't have that much of an issue with well-planned taxes. Unfortunately, taxes are the price of civilised government, and as much as we'd be loathe to admit it, the government's not actually that bad - compare it to places like Afghanistan, Iraq, heck, even Russia, and you've got to admit things are pretty good.
I do have an issue with taxes on fixed assets - like a property tax - which kicks in through increases in property values. If you own your property, you should only have to pay for services to it, you should not be worried that one day, thanks to the market deciding your land is great, you might have to pay tax on it - that's unfair.
As I've mentioned in other threads, I think consumption type taxes, like sales tax and the GST here in Australia and New Zealand, is a much smarter form of taxation for modern economies.