You Tube now supports 1080p, So can we upload GT5 replays in 1080p?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jedaye
  • 50 comments
  • 6,295 views
Do you know how big 1080P video's would be?

Better start searching for a provider that offers a connection with an upload speed that's at least 10 Mbit ;)
 
Last edited:
Fruitcake
Do you know how big 1080P video would be?

Better start searching for a provider that offers a connection with an upload speed that's at least 10 Mbit ;)
Click to expand...

Agree. A two minute 1080p vid would be simply massive!
 
Last edited:
A 5 minute 10 Mbit/s (1.25 MByte/s) video would already be 375 MB :D

So with the max upload of ADSL (1 Mbit) that would take 48 minutes to put it on Youtube.

But cable/fiberglass ISP customers and students have access to 100 Mbit upload connections so it is possible ;)
 
Last edited:
But but but... what if..


Sony and Google have deals going, what if.... Google was given their own GT5 compilier, so you only have to send a small replay file and google will compile it into a full 1080P GT5 replay (video) much the way GT does when you load a replay? Although that sounds like google would be stuck with a ridiculous amount of data storage when everyone starts uploading every single thing they do (if the uploads were only replay data).
 
Jay
But but but... what if..


Sony and Google have deals going, what if.... Google was given their own GT5 compilier, so you only have to send a small replay file and google will compile it into a full 1080P GT5 replay (video) much the way GT does when you load a replay? Although that sounds like google would be stuck with a ridiculous amount of data storage when everyone starts uploading every single thing they do (if the uploads were only replay data).
Click to expand...

What if Google had a GT5 compiler and just rendered and streamed the video in real time, so they wouldn't have to store anything but the replay data.

Would be awesome, but is never gonna happen. :(
 
OK I understand game to run 1080p, but watching it on youtube in 1080 i do not care.. but viewing pictures from PHOTO MODE, we need more then 1080p.
 
Fruitcake
A 5 minute 10 Mbit/s (1.25 MB/s) video would already be 375 MB :D

So with the max upload of ADSL (1 Mbit) that would take 48 minutes to put it on Youtube.

But cable/fiberglass ISP customers and students have access to 100Mbit upload connections so it is possible ;)
Click to expand...
You can see how big the files are by downloading them from GTTV on gt5p.
5 minutes can be over 520mb. based on 2 minutes of the FT-86 HD video taking 209mb of space.
 
for photos yes, but 1080?? who has fast internet and a large resolution? not many people...
im doing 1280x1024 and i have 2.5Mb/s not very fast :/
 
Personally I wouldn't even want to view peoples (or my own) replays and footage on youtube in 1080P, just a waste of bandwidth.
 
Jay
But but but... what if..


Sony and Google have deals going, what if.... Google was given their own GT5 compilier, so you only have to send a small replay file and google will compile it into a full 1080P GT5 replay (video) much the way GT does when you load a replay? Although that sounds like google would be stuck with a ridiculous amount of data storage when everyone starts uploading every single thing they do (if the uploads were only replay data).
Click to expand...

Not gonna happen. Encoding all those videos would require too much processing power. It's a lot cheaper to just store the data.
 
Dravonic
Not gonna happen. Encoding all those videos would require too much processing power. It's a lot cheaper to just store the data.
Click to expand...


Your right, it would require a crap load of processing power. The amount of processing units required would be staggering as would be the cost (unless you wanted to be in a queue for 2 years :p ).
 
Frankly I don't really care about exporting to YouTube. Being able to export 720p/1080p video files to the hard drive for copying to a computer and editing would be great.

I mean, why watch a big video on Youtube when you can download a replay file that's measured in KB? Unless it's something that someone cleverly edited on their computer?
 
yaywalter
Frankly I don't really care about exporting to YouTube. Being able to export 720p/1080p video files to the hard drive for copying to a computer and editing would be great.

I mean, why watch a big video on Youtube when you can download a replay file that's measured in KB? Unless it's something that someone cleverly edited on their computer?
Click to expand...

I think it will be possible, I remeber KAZ mention or was it on the news that you can export either to YouTube or PSP, so to transfer to PSP you will have to save it to HDD first.
 
Im going to guess here.

In the GT5 Features list Youtube uploads was confirmed. So maybe you can upload your replay directly from the game to youtube if you're connected to PSN.

So you race, do your thang, then you know in that menu where its got start race, view replay, settings etc etc.. there must be an option called something like "Upload replay to Youtube via PSN".

but maybe depending on your connection speed it will depend on weather or not it will be a 1080p or 720 or whatever..
 
Hold on a second. I really hope the youtube feature is in, but why was it on the first features list (japanese) and not on the second one from TGS?
 
Why not introduce a sharing system on the PS3 itself, just like you can download the top 10 replays from a time trail event?

Every user gets his own (limited) GT5-space where he can post replays (the very small files), pictures from photo mode, setups, etc.

No huge files to upload or download, no need to contact other parties for huge amount of data storage, everything can be shared in 1 place.

The could even (and maybe they will) integrate this in Playstation Home.
 
I think I would rather prefer if you could save the replays into your PS3 hard drive at 720p/1080p in a video file format, like mp4 or WMV or something of that kind. That would certainly end the "recording off-screen" videos in Youtube and more quality videos would be able to be produced without the necessity of a capture card.

Imagine having the video file being saved to your PS3 hdd right from the game, and then using a flash drive or external hard drive to send that file to your home computer. Much more simple than having a capture card, or recording with a camera.
 
Exactly, I would create my own simple videos with super basic editing tools. Because for people like myself, we don't wanna buy capture cards.
 
The thing is though youtube will compress the file further.

I am uploading some test videos at the moment for example the below video I uploaded the original size of the video is 83.1meg and 1080p @ 11Meg Data rate and 29.70 FPS.




When I upload it youtube then convert it to a lower codec. Just because youtube are supporting 1080p that is only the resolution of the video it does not mean they will keep the bittrate of 11meg.
 
Am i the only one who thinks it looks pretty bad?
Theres a lot of pixelation going on (my monitor can handle 1080p).
 

Latest Posts

Back