330 P4 in Supercar challenge vs. GT5

[ziadjs]

has anyone tried to drive this car in both games on let's say Monza? any clear preferences?

 

[TheCracker]

I don't know how they drive in Supercar Challenge, but in GT5, the 330, XJ13 and Ford Mark IV and '69 GT40 (along with the Chaparrals, 512BB and Miura) all perform much better than they would do IRL. Maybe Supercar Challenge, with it being a bit more of a serious attempt as a console Race Sim, does the job of simulating it more realistically?

 

[Minardi]

I 'd be interested to know what people find.

I haven't tried to compare same cars on same tracks in both games, but in general I prefer SCC. And not just for the sounds, It is the complete feel of driving a racemonster what I consider really well done in SCC.

 

[jjaisli]

I have:

Supercar Challenge:
+ engine sounds
+ strong and communicative FFB
+ Good physics simulation but some quirky behavior at the limit.

GT5:
+ superior visuals
+ excellent physics
+ better tuning options

 

[Hun200kmh]

I don't have a Monza video recorded, but I do have a Nurburgring GP one so you can get an idea. A difficult beast to tame (first corner pile-up made me LOL, didn't remember such a mess )

[YOUTUBEHD]mtfG_L1TPhA[/YOUTUBEHD]

Can't comapre it with the GT5 version yet. I only did a lap or 2 with the P4 in this game, and never actually took it to a race, off or online.

 

[Minardi]

Great driving Hun ! God, I miss those real time time differences in GT5.

 

[pixel_geist]

These guys on YouTube are HUGE supporters of GTplanet, and they had an interview w/ the GTplanet founder a few months ago.

Sadly they've only done two side-by-side comparisons, and i recommend everybody subscribe to these guys on YouTube.

 

[ziadjs]

thanks guys I will need to go back to SCC to try the P4, I recall the FFB was great driving the classic Ferrari's on SCC, dare I say better than GT5 (?)