nowadays, before I tragically lost my PS2, I drove with stock cars that had oil change and chassis refresh done. but, here are the cars I used.
BMW 120i - neutral handling when driven calmly, tendency to oversteer when stepping on it. destroyed cars like M coupe and other 300bhp+ cars after tyres had warmed up.
Mazda MX-5 - any of the new ones. you can not avoid drifting in this one, because it's so easy and fun to do in this car. again, I was able to destroy cars that had twice the power.
Toyota MR2'86 - killed NSX with ease on El Capitan. fast and nimble, and good drifter.
Lotus Elise/Esprit - these cars have no competition on tighter tracks, but beware of TVR's, these can not match their straight speeds.
Audi A3, RS6 - if you want nimble and fast car that loves to rev, A3 is the choice. and if you feel that you want to humiliate opponents with an estate, RS6 avant is your tool.
Nissan Skyline - nuff said. R32 and R34 are the best ones.
Toyota Supra - in its stock setup, it pushes 349bhp and plenty of torque, achieving 180 mph.. and tail happy in corners.
Corvette ZR-1 - corvette that has power and torque way up in the rev range? must have! handles pretty well too, as long as you know how to do weight transfers.
3000GT/GTO - it's beautiful, fast, nimble and loaded with luxury, and willing to swing that pretty butt in the corners. can't live without one.
Mitsu Lancer 1600 GSR - this old car is faster than one thinks.. the key is it's lightness.
Tommykaira ZZ-II - swap softer tyres and this beautiful, ferrari-looking car shows M5 his rearlights on any track. nimble and FAAAAASSSSTTT!!
NSX - any of these are beautifully balanced cars, despite old chassis design.. if MR2 can eat these for lunch, what does this eat? you got it: upper class cars.
these are the ones that come in mind. I hope you find it helpful.