Best Grand Theft Auto ever?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Golfman
  • 110 comments
  • 17,309 views
I was touched by the story in GTA IV, best writing I've seen in a GTA game so far, choices in missions are always a plus. That said here go my reasons for not playing the game anymore after I finished it:

It's realistic how when you fall from a rooftop you die on impact, too bad that spoils the fun.

It's realistic how you can't go on 6-star rampages anymore, too bad THAT was fun.

It's realistic how tanks don't come out when you get up to 6 stars, too bad driving those was awesome.

It's realistic how cars need a lot more care and finesse to drive, even IF they handle like they have no shocks. Too bad it's a hassle to drive anywhere now.

It's realistic how when you hop out of a moving car Niko tumbles and rolls, even at slow speeds he lays on the ground suffering from the impact. Too bad you get shot to death in those seconds where you can't move.

Once realism gets in the way of fun, the game has failed. Regardless of how blown away I was when I saw the damage modeling on vehicles in GTA IV and the detail put into the city, I can't bring myself to play the game anymore because it feels like a chore, not a game. Even running around with the character is a task in itself, Niko sometimes does these movements that basically keep him in harms way until the movement sequence finishes, like turning around 180 when you're walking or running.

Bonuses like calling up that girl to replenish your health work only when the game feels like it and it seldom does, it certainly never worked while I was on a mission, you know, when it would actually come in handy. I liked the pool minigame in SA, it's astounding to see how just how bad they messed up even that in IV.

No taxi missions... all I can say is WTF. I liked those, great way of getting to know the streets while making money at the beginning of the game experience. And what's up with the music?! Even without the gangsta rap, SA had some great tunes in it. The music in IV is unspeakably bad.

Anybody ever notice how in "vigilante" missions, if you can call them that anymore, the time allotted to get to the scene of the crime is calculated by how far away you are from it physically? Like the game draws a STRAIGHT line from your location to the destination and then assumes all you need to get there are 15 seconds, it takes that much time to go around half a block for crying out loud, if you could fly over the buidlings and not have to take the streets you'd totally make it though.

So my vote goes for San Andreas as well. I wouldn't give GTA IV more than a 6 out of 10. Sweet visuals, great story, no fun. Whatsoever.
 
GTA San Andreas is the best. It takes one ghetto hood kid from the (realistic) Los Angeles, through San Francisco and Las Vegas, only to know you end the game were you started: at home. CJ is one of the coolest guys, and the small things were cool, you could enlist gang members, you could have people take a photo of you. Girlfriends, oysters, gangs, ACTUAL LANDSCAPES (not just one big city). I hope that San Andreas returns, soon, because IV was a first attempt and fared well, now they should have the abilty to do what they did with Liberty City, recreate it, get rid of outrageous cheats (flying cars are fun, but useless), but keep the badlands. The storyline is intense, surely Nikos is great, but the characters are just understated. Look at SA, you had OG Loc (Gangsta Baby!), Ryder (Eazy-E) the evil police dude who I cant remember his name, and the radio had all our classics, from Lazlow (real guy, by the way) to Fernando. Others, like Zero, are close in resemblance (no I DON"T PLAY WITH AIRPLANES), to Catalina, who resembles your loving Ex-wife. GTA IV falls short on stuff after the story, unless you have Episodes from Liberty City.
My lineup:
1. GTA San Andreas
2. GTA IV
3. GTA TBoGT
4. GTA Vice City
5. GTA Vice City Stories
6. GTA TLaD
7. GTA Liberty City Stories
8. GTA III
 
It's realistic how you can't go on 6-star rampages anymore, too bad THAT was fun.

I don't get this one, GTA is more fun running from the cops in an actual car, trying to survive, mashing cheat codes at record speed. And there is a cheat for 6 Stars, on case you have trouble doing that.
 
To rephrase myself, on the full wanted level you won't survive long, as opposed to the previous games where you'd hunker down in one spot and give cops hell. I only drove with a full wanted level to restock armor/health or switch weapons. I don't use cheats.
 
GTA San Andreas was really great, GTA 4 is good, but in my opinion GTA the first one with the GTA London expansion is true masterpiece.

K.
 
I forgot about the eating/working out in SA. Otherwise its certainly my favorite.

1) San Andreas, for its huge map, variety of vehicles, ability to purchase all the things you do, car customization, and pretty much everything else from its feature list. Countryside. Semi-trailers! Monster Truck!

2) GTAIV, for its graphics, physics, and everything that came with the new console. Great story, though when its all done I didn't feel as compelled to just play around. In San Andreas I'd be entertained for HOURS to go take anything that seemed remotely capable of off-road out in the desert or up the mountain.

3) GTAIII - it started all the free-roam games, it is likely one of the most important games for the gaming industry. The city feels very real and the islands aren't massively different like SA, where the whole climate changes as well.

4) Vice City - Not a whole lot of reasoning for this, mainly that I played it a few days ago on the PS3 and it was very disappointing. Controls felt a little funky but that could be due to how the DualShock3's sticks are tuned compared to the DS2. It was hard to gently steer a car (and I had forgotten just how unrealistically good everything handled).



The next GTA really, really, really, really needs a Countryside like GTASA. That was a whole game full of interesting. Especially with the usual Rockstar humor. However doing so will be extremely hard considering that GTAIV's Liberty City was somewhere close in size to the whole GTASA map.
 
One of the things I loved about San Andreas was the open country in between the cities. That mountain was always good for a laugh - getting a wanted level then tearing up the mountain on a motorbike and having a laugh as the cops tried to follow you in their pickups, only to lose footing and fall off the edge. Brilliant! Although it did seem a bit strange how cops would appear from further up the mountain and try to come down after you.
Also I always found it fun to, when at the top of the mountain, drive the parked vehicles at the edge then get out and watch them roll all the way down.
 
Vice City, But San Andreas had the best soundtrack.
 
Last edited:
Its gotta be vice city for me the whole story and setting worked so perfectly shame they aint gonna remake it for the ps3
 
For me it has to be Vice City and Vice City Stories, I love the era and the feel. SA was way too bloated.

If Rockstar don't make GTA V set in a realistic 2010 Miami I am going to cry! :scared:

Robin.
 
i tried to like Vice City Stories. i did finish game, however, and had an okay time.

I have to agree with you there it was missing so much from GTA VC the highlight of VCS was Phil Collins :P haha but the graphics were poor at best
 
Okay, so I have had a couple of beers.. but GTA as a series is just epic..

I did play GTA 1 & 2 all those years ago, and yes, they were good, amusing a wierdly addictive, but I was never really IN to them.

GTAIII, however, I wanted to dislike... I was well into the Driver games and saw GTAIII as a threat to my enjoyment of Driver & Driver 2, but, one autumnal day whilst in Liverpool, I bought it from the Virgin Megastore... 2 days later when I got home.. I couldn't believe it... "I know a place on the edge of the Red light district where we can lay low..." those words marked a new phase in my life!

Now I'm not a "gamer" by nature.. GT, GTA and driver.. are pretty much the only games I ever bothered with since I was little and used to play 'Creatures' on the C64, and then Doom on the PC in high school... but GTA enveloped the player so much, masses of fun, so much character a really immersive experience, unlike anything I'd played before... the freedom, it was amazing.

I was playing GTAIII when I was going through a difficult period of my life.. (y'now.. heart break then alcoholism etc etc)... I can't think about that period of my life without remembering all the good times I had playing GTAIII..

When Vice City came out, things weren't much better! I'd moved, changed jobs and was taking other drugs to deal with stuff, prescription ones, rather using the grand old drink of the south to ease the pain! Billie Jean... the rain, the lightning... the colours... Tommy Vercetti... VICE CITY was here... Sitting around with my housemates playing VC.. it was great... it wasn't like a game it was part of day to day life.. Me and Lance, strafing the bad guys from the helicopter, Phil Collins on the Radio... Listening to V-Rock whilst cruisin' on the bike.... good times ineed..

.. good times, not like real-life.. I'd moved back to my parents to try and save up some money.. this was about when San Andreas came out.

Wow.. I hated it to begin with, after VC, it felt it lacked any kind of feel... and maybe it did, but what it may have lacked in character it made up for in mind-blowing scale, freedom, attention to detail... it was massive, with so much to do.. I think back and remember trying to tag all of Los Santos for the cause -- then cruisin' the strip.. and stealing planes.. working out.. keeping the girlfriend happy, dancing in clubs.. taking photos of random sh** and hoping it was a 'photo opportunity'.... I can't believe it was all in one game.. EPIC should be spelt GTASA.....

By the time the Liberty and Vice city stories came out, I'd moved again, living on my own in my first flat.. with not much to do I'd hit the PSP... a PSP bought simply for playing GTA... I'd even drive around with the PSP plugged into the car stereo listening to the radio stations from the options menu...

..

.. But as real-life started to get in the way, I played them less and less.. then when IV came around, I bought a PS3 just to play it... except I could never afford a HD TV.. my old rear projection just made the game unplayable... couldn't read the phone, couldn't make out the radar.. just struggled to get into it. didn't really play it in the end.... so I sold my PS3.. (I was also financially f*'d and had to sell pretty much everything I owned)..

I got another PS3 last christmas basically just for the GT:TT demo... and also bought Episodes from Liberty City, but again, never played it... I'd moved again, gone from rubbish rear projection TV to a poxy 21" portable and just couldn't be bothered with trying to enjoy gaming.. I have hardly play GT since December..

.. basically... GTA has been one of the better parts of my life during some not so good times, and I still have pretty much all of the the PS3 GTAage to enjoy... once I get a half decent TV :)

I really cannot emphasize how good I think GTA has been...

.. but there you go, I've blathered too much.. just wanted to verbalize my feelings about the GTA series.
 
GTA: San Andreas is probably my current fav GTA game, but i love them all pretty much, especially GTA 4 (and both add on packs) and the 80'sness of the two Vice city GTAs.

Really loved how Phil Collins played himself in GTA: Vice City Stories and also am a huge fan of the Skyline in GTA: San Andreas.
 
I've enjoyed a good number of them, Vice city is right up there, but for me, San Andreas has to take the crown.
 
IV.

San Andreas is empty when you play it now, with few cars or pedestrians. Compared to SA, IV is a work of art. So it was slightly more realistic, but that's because Rockstar are like Bowie or Madonna; create something and change when poor imitations come along.

I wouldn't be too proud to say my hard work was ripped off by the likes of Saints Row.
 
I liked the top view GTAs... GTA2 was fun to screw around in... Burp/Fart button haha, no game has that anymore nowadays.

I couldnt remember my way around the place at all. But whenever I found those line of drive-thrus I would always buy a ton of oil slicks and create a pond on an intersection, shoot up some people and watch cops slide all over the place... of course I eventually get hit. That's when I turn off my PS1 and go do something else.

good times......
 
Although I haven't played many of them...

Vice City is by far my favourite.... just loved the feel of it and the story was ok.... It was fun and that's the main thing, I'm not a ghetto kind of guy and so the whole sterotype tropical paradise owning the street thing I really enjoyed.

GTA2 was great fun... driving around running people over randomly... good senseless fun. No real characters or anything and everyone looked similiar just dooing basic things.


San Andreas started and hated... Really didn't like it.


GTA2 was fun.

Vice City had a great feel. I had the power at my fingure tips. + all teh fun, boats, cars, coppers, and heaps of mods for pc. Say hello to chitty chitty bang bang style car on water, launching cars onto boats, antigravity stuff all good fun.

San Andreas made me feel like I had to grow up in the game.

If Vice City was a sunny day outside, San Andreas was a cold dark day.


TO me, GTA2 was sensless, SA was too much a 'hard realistic felling' for me.. Vice City was just right
 
GTA3 is something special, a true classic, It has the best atmosphere of any gta game, it is a masterpiece, I feel the PS2 version was better to play than the PC one though.

SA was awesome and kept on giving, but the only reason it is alive today is because of the SA-MP multiplayer mod, and it's infinite server scripting possibilities, combined with just about every vehicle you could ever want, and a huge map that didn't require a loading screen between regions.

IV may be the highest grossing game (has it been beaten yet?) of all time, but it took a hell of a tumble and backlash from players, which is why there are so few playing it.

Hated Vice City, but the new advancements could not be ignored (crouch ability), but I expect the new Vice City might be to my liking, since I hated the new liberty city, there was nothing to find or do, I played it online a lot (mods saved it) but it is a hot, sweaty, sickly game with stale atmosphere.

1-III
2-SA
3-IV
4-2
5-Vice
 
GTAIV made you love Niko. I know it made me. :)
The best story I've ever seen in a game. Movie-worthy.
Niko is a great choice, russian badboy haha.
SA was great too, a lot of great memories.
Huge world, a lot of things to do, great storie also, variety of missions was superb.

My humble opinion.
 
Funny GTA4 while fun is maybe my 4th fave GTA my list is:

1. San Andreas

2. GTA3

3. Vice City

My reasoning isn't even the storyline or anything as much as the stuff you can do. I just thought maybe the Improvements made for San Andreas would carry over into GTA4. Also just my opinion here but The TV shows and Radio Stations didn't seem as great either. Not bad, Just not better than the last game.
 
Back