- 21,286
- GR-MI-USA
- YSSMAN
- YSSMAN
Why bother making the Cien or Sixteen?
They're just going to end up giving it a price tag of a Lamborghini or Maybach without actually having the performance to mimic either.
Just look at the XLR-V. $100,000 for a roadster that can't even steal sells away from BMW or Mercedes. Hell, that overpriced V8 probably can't even steal a sell from Jaguar.
...Well, they aren't building the Cien (yet). The Sixteen has been semi-greenlighted, but will only use a V12, not the full-size engine. Granted, the Cien may still be on the table, given that there have been discussions of a mid-engine variant of the Corvette, which would presumably be a Cadillac model. Light weight and the big V12 would certainly be a decent idea for Porsche 911 and Mercedes SL money...
As for the XLR-V, it was never intended to be a big-time seller, but they have moved enough of them to make GM happy. Most of the engine technology has gone into the STS-V anyway, and I certainly am in the camp in which the STS-V's version of the 4.4L S/C Northstar would be a better idea than the 25 BHP-short XLR-V. But when you really weren't expecting to sell more than 1000 a year, and people are buying them, complaints from average people aren't going to mean much.
JCE3000GTSolution(s) for Cadillac:
* Kill the XLR with a sawwed off shotgun blast to the face
* Build the Sixteen or much more desired Cien concept
* Graft two 6.0L LS2 engines together
* Add one small roots/screw supercharger (~5psi) just for the noise
* Sell it for $120k
* Watch me sell most of my duplicate organs to afford one
* Watch me kill myself drifting around a corner @150mph
Note: the last 2 are subjective and meant for humorous purposes only. The Cien would probaby sell well if the engine technology was there AND it handled well enough to actually compete with the likes of the SL65 AMG.
1) The XLR is a good idea, they just need to fine-tune it. My guess is that they will keep building them. Sales have been good enough, and the press/public seems to have accepted the car well enough.
2) They are doing the Sixteen (as noted earlier), the Cien is still up in the air.
3) The V16 idea is pretty much dead, given that they are doing a V12 based on the LY7 V6. They could do a twin LS2 V16, but the origional concept used twin LS7s, and it was a completely functional design... But the V12 is it, for now...
4) Supercharger? Dunno. Could happen with the V12...
5) $120K is the price range they were considering for both cars, but a good guess puts the 'ULS' (thats what I'm calling it from now-on) in a start range probably in the $70K-ish range, north of $100K for the full-fledged V12 version.
*McLaren*I, though, don't think the XLR should be killed off (it's a good idea by Cadillac to sell a conv.), I just think they should drastically drop its price.
How much is drastically? The XLR starts at $78K, which isn't too bad considering that similarly-equipped models start at about $81K for the XK, about $82K for the 650ci, about $95K for the SL550... The only major competitor to undercut it is the SC430 at about $66K. But the SC430 sucks, so you get what you pay for...
The only change I would demand from Cadillac is more-power for the XLR, given than 320 BHP isn't quite enough anymore. Maybe a "S/C-lite" version would be an acceptable idea?
ToronadoIf they build the Sixteen and do that, you should add:
* Watch it sit on dealer lots.
If they do it with the Cien, it would sell like mad.
Certainly so. Given that the 'ULS' will likely replace the DTS at the top of the heap, they're going to need to spread the wealth around, and keep a low-priced model on-hand. However, if they could produce the Cien as a MR sports car with a 600 BHP V12, they would sell like hot-cakes... Delicious hot, hot-cakes. As I understood the origional post, GM would stand to make the most money on a Cien-type car, but it would cost less to develop an S-Class competitor. Hence the "confirmation" of the 'ULS.'
ultrabeatIf Cadillac tries to take on Mercedes' S-Class (or even Lexus, for that matter) then they are in serious danger of being outclassed.
Unless the quality improves quickly, they might not stand a chance...
Well, in earlier posts I did show the improving interior quality of Cadillac, and given that they are the third-highest rated company in America in terms of quality (behind Lexus and Buick), if anything the others should be worried. The improvements of Cadillac in the past five or so years has been astounding given where they have been in the past 25 or so years. Just the fact alone that they are doing this proves that GM has their balls back, and they certainly won't face the competition without packing some kind of heat.
The General has been surprising a lot of people lately, and this is another good instance where it could work out well. The S-Class may be a spot too hard to shoot for, but even if they benchmarked the S-Class, they would be farther ahead than the majority of the competition, so it may work out well for them...