I suggest you'd get a lot more 'feel' using the analogues right forward for accelerator and rear for brake and left L/R for steering.
However whatever you use you can get a lot of help with braking if you change the settings. I use a higher front brake setting and a lower rear, so a MR car may be 7-3 and a FR 8-2. I tune each car so I get stable braking on a slight curve. I find the default 5-5 setting breaks the back away too easily on almost all cars.