Is Garfield dead or dying?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zrow
  • 11 comments
  • 2,431 views

Zrow

Sweet, delicious
Premium
Messages
2,734
Messages
AndrewPaul
I don't mean the quality of the strip - that's not up for debate. I was browsing the A.V. Club on the Onion though, and I read about a weird week-long strip Jim Davis did in about 1989 in which Garfield finds himself alone in a house. Did a little Googling and found a good site where you can read all of the strips of that week:

http://garfieldisdead.ytmnd.com/


Kinda funny, kinda creepy, but pretty interesting.



God, this is the second time I've started a thread about Garfield here. What's wrong with me?
 
I don't thing anythings wrong with you,not like me.I had a real Garfield at my home (he is my pet) He has an orange fur and is fat just like Garfield was.(but good thing he just eats his food and occasionally fried chicken and tuna.If he ate Lasagna we would be broke if we had to but it everyday) and he is scared 🤬 just like Garfield too.

About the comic,i think he's not dead.It was just a Halloween prank or something.If he was dead,you would not even live to see The Garfield Movie or even its sequel.
 
Considering the fact that those strips ran almost 18 years ago, I think we can safely assume he didn't die and is not dying.

Davis said he just wanted to do something different that week.
 
I see that now. I thought it made the incredibly banal Garfield comic strip slightly more interesting if there was the possibility that everything we see in the comic strip is just a hallucination by Garfield, who was actually just a cat starving to death in an abandoned old home. Nevermind though.

Thanks to Jim Davis though, who informed us that "no, I'm still boring and unfunny, I just had a rare spark of originality 20 years ago that doesn't have to do with anything".



As an aside, I still think the discovery that if you take out Garfield's dialogue, it becomes a completely different comic is worth checking out.
 
Garfield is ten days older than me. If he dies then so do I.
 
I think this strip was written more to make people appreciate what they have. As you don't fully realize the value of something till you no longer have it.

Fairly depressing though, but happy ending it looks like (Or I missed something)
 
About the comic,i think he's not dead.It was just a Halloween prank or something.If he was dead,you would not even live to see The Garfield Movie or even its sequel.
Apparently, you did not put much thought into the final saying if you think it was a Halloween prank.

If you read what people are analyzing from it, he's playing today's situations in his head, even though it's not happening.
However, see my response to Azuremen, below.
I think this strip was written more to make people appreciate what they have. As you don't fully realize the value of something till you no longer have it.

Fairly depressing though, but happy ending it looks like (Or I missed something)
Exactly.

I believe Jim Davis decided one week to set Garfield into an alternate world where Garfield has been dead and uses the death of Garfield as way of expressing what Davis wants us all to realize. Afterwards, Garfield continues as it was 2 weeks before. It wasn't really the Garfield we all think of, just a 1 time thing in life to remind us with the help of a Comic Strip to realize, as Azuremen said, to appreciate what we have.

In the world that is Garfield, he is alive and fine as every other Comic Strip character. This situation though was one of the more unique ways of comic artists expressing an idea. Throughout time, everyone will occasionally see an artist use his comic strip to portray a message to us that is sometimes different from what we're used to reading. In this case, it was done by the "death" of Garfield.

It's a fantastic idea, imo, as it shows if you grasped what Davis said. If you're relying more on the fact that Garfield "died", then you didn't read deep enough into the strip. It's not about the death of Garfield, it's about the message we should all look at.
 
Well i'm sorry if i Don't like Garfield (or looks like it anyway.I didn't read all of the comics and i didn't even watch their movie cause it sucks!I'm a Calvin and Hobbes kind of person :) ) But thanks *McLaren* and Azuremen for clearing things up.I wasn't even born during that time....
 
Back