I just bought it today (Thanks to Lee) And like it. It's not really a huge step up from the Dreamcast though. (The Dreamcast version was nearly PS2 quality though.) One thing that I haven't seen mentioned about the game is the tremendous feeling of speed. On other cars, and yours (outside view) you can see the turbulance form off the edges of the spoilers. Inside the car is a whole different ballgame. The hood rattles with the wind as you gain speed. GT3 has gotten me a little burned this week, and this will be a nice diversion. (Burned out as in too many laps around the same tracks, I'll never burn out on racing games.)
I'd give it an 8 - 8.5 as a stand alone, but only a 7.5 if you own or have played the DC version.
Oh, and you can actually race a 24 hour race. Try using toothpicks and rubber bands on that one...