Monkey D vs. Project D team battle

  • Thread starter Thread starter battle_stage
  • 310 comments
  • 12,886 views
I think all three members shoulw get their own score, then they should be posted that way. Because say 1 members gets like, i dont know, 13/25, but then the next member gets 25/25, then the third gets 20/25. The first guy will bring the overall score down. I think it should be three different scores, then whoever has the most members that won (2/3) wins the whole dealy.

-Vash
 
I think all three members shoulw get their own score, then they should be posted that way. Because say 1 members gets like, i dont know, 13/25, but then the next member gets 25/25, then the third gets 20/25. The first guy will bring the overall score down. I think it should be three different scores, then whoever has the most members that won (2/3) wins the whole dealy.

That's why it's a TEAM battle. Averaging out the scores will better represent the team as a whole.
 
I agree with Supra Fly. In this way the team that gives a better overall representation will win.

Or we could use a mean score as well, and use that in combination with the 3 other scores. We could then weight it in some way so that the 3 people count 4 a total of 80% of hte whole score and the average score counts for 20%... might be a bit fairer to both ways of scoring...then you give the team a grade...
 
Originally posted by bengee
I agree with Supra Fly. In this way the team that gives a better overall representation will win.

Or we could use a mean score as well, and use that in combination with the 3 other scores. We could then weight it in some way so that the 3 people count 4 a total of 80% of hte whole score and the average score counts for 20%... might be a bit fairer to both ways of scoring...then you give the team a grade...

Weighted score sounds good bengee.

-Vash
 
I just disagree with bascially dropping the lowest performer.

I think just averaging all 3 scores is the easiest, and most fair way of going about it.
 
Originally posted by battle_stage
I just disagree with bascially dropping the lowest performer.

I think just averaging all 3 scores is the easiest, and most fair way of going about it.
Agreed. ;)
 
Originally posted by exhaust_note
Monkey D's lowest performer = exhaust_note
Practice, practice, practice. Use the force, and all that ****. I've got faith in ya brotha.;)
 
Weighted is the same as averaging basically... but individual scores will not determine closer matches... the average of all the players will... i will be more specific later...
 
Back