Should I Get Dirt 3?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Crazed_Coupe
  • 35 comments
  • 9,963 views
Messages
1,526
Messages
Crazed_Coupe
First off I know there are many reviews on YouTube but I would like to hear from the "raw" community and see what you guys think about them game.

I've heard/seen that it does look a bit on the arcade side more than a simulator although that's not a huge drawback for me. Does the Logitech G27 work with Dirt 3 as well?
 
Yes! I have to say its a huge improvement over Dirt 2 for sure. The force feedback in my opinion on the G27 is really good. Even the clutch is supported.

I dont have a G27 but a friend of mine does.
 
It depends if you want specialty or variety.

this game has variety, but every event is short and rather simplistic, especially the rally side, the depth of the game imo doesn't give it a lot of replay value.
 
Just got this game today. Very fun. 👍 I would definitely recommend it as something worth the price. If you're into good graphics, Rally, and Rather well Physics, this is the game for you. ;)
 
JJ72
It depends if you want specialty or variety.

this game has variety, but every event is short and rather simplistic, especially the rally side, the depth of the game imo doesn't give it a lot of replay value.

I'd disagree. The game has an awesome online system and it's a lot of fun just rating through your favorite tracks with any number of cars. I love any rally events in Kenya personally. Fantastic game I think.
 
the depth of the game imo doesn't give it a lot of replay value.
Start a new game in Dirt Tour, but use the following rules:

- You may only compete in an event once.
- You may not use flashbacks or restart the race.
- You may not do World Tours, DC Challenges or any additional events that give you reputation.
- Once you unlock the series final, you may not do any more races in that championship.
- Once you unlock the season final, you may not do any other races in that season.

The objective is to get as far into the game as possible with the least amount of reputation. I just finished mine up today, and I got to lvl. 19, completing 51% of the actual game.
 
Dirt 3 is the best racing game I have ever played.

It looks amazing, and sounds amazing. The physics are great, gameplay is great. Online is awesome. Whats not to like? Anyone who dislikes this game is far too obsessed with realism.

So yes, you should buy it :D
 
The main problem with DiRT3 is that you only get half of the game, and the other half is being released as DLC, which you have to pay for. Multiplayer is a blast. However it can quickly get boring. Short races, repetitive track selections, douchebags (circuit racing), cheaters, glitches and the list goes on.

I still recommend it though (pre-owned). It's a fun and tricky game. Great physics, gameplay, graphics and engine sounds.
 
I think you should get it for what everyone has already stated! 👍
 
A bit bummed about the game though, thought I could go online but i had to pay for that feature. That's the only thing stopping me from playing it more often.
 
I would say no. I prefer the 2nd one actually.

Short stages that get re used often. Not much rally.

The steering lock seems far too short on PS3 too. Haven't tried a Fanatec with it though.

Patches may have improved it since I played it though.
 
The main problem with DiRT3 is that you only get half of the game, and the other half is being released as DLC, which you have to pay for. Multiplayer is a blast. However it can quickly get boring. Short races, repetitive track selections, douchebags (circuit racing), cheaters, glitches and the list goes on.

I still recommend it though (pre-owned). It's a fun and tricky game. Great physics, gameplay, graphics and engine sounds.

That's called "exaggeration." :rolleyes: The game ships with about 50 cars and about 10 locations (a few only available for certain modes). The DLC consists of about 14 cars, 1 NEW location only available for Rally, and 1 Recycled DiRT 2 location, only for Rallycross.

I really enjoyed multiplayer. I don't play circuit racing, so I avoid the idiots, but my biggest complaint is the lack of people online. There was quite a few when they had Double XP a week ago, but then it dropped off again.

And for the OP, I haven't seen pre-owned cheap enough yet to buy in the US, and he will need to buy an online pass. Might as well buy new.

I would say no. I prefer the 2nd one actually.

Short stages that get re used often. Not much rally.

The steering lock seems far too short on PS3 too. Haven't tried a Fanatec with it though.

Patches may have improved it since I played it though.

The problem with getting DiRT 2 this late (I did) is even fewer people online than DiRT 3, and most of those people have played the game 23/7. People ranked in the 200s, 400s, up to 680. Absolutely ridiculous. The online for DiRT 2 isn't very good anymore, if you can find a game (70% chance, and it won't be full). And when you do get in a lobby, full of high ranks, be prepared to go up against nothing buy Toyota Stadium trucks and Dallenbachs. :ouch:

It does have a lot more locations, but fewer (and, imo, less appealing) cars to use. Way too many landrush events too, for me.
 
If I buy the game pre-owned I will have to buy an online pass, correct? That is unless the seller hasn't used the code which is very unlikely.
 
If you want a mix of an aggressive online and realistic offline game then buy DiRT but if not there are better games.
 
I liked DiRT ... the first 5 days, then it got too much the same.
--

The plusses:

- Very competitive AI in offline races - aggressive, but fair, x10 times better than GT5's AI, if not more - highest difficulty gives me a lot of competition, which I'm not used to in racing games.
- Physics are good (but not simulation physics at all)
- A lot of game modes online (at least 10 DiRT 3 friends is recommenden so that you can get some good races).

Minus:

- It's repetitive - not enough tracks (different versions at every location, not enough for me)
- Tracks can be cut - bigtime some places.
- Online is a complete demolition derby if you just jump in a quick race.
- DLC... why so much of this? Codies are just milkin' the cow, so to say.
 
Yeah, I agree too little tracks and the world records times are achieved with numerous short cuts.
 
I think I might rent it at a local Redbox first to see if I like it or not considering all the Blockbuster stores are pretty much completely gone around here. :(
 
WeShallNverStop
A bit bummed about the game though, thought I could go online but i had to pay for that feature. That's the only thing stopping me from playing it more often.

Buy it used?
 
That's called "exaggeration." :rolleyes: The game ships with about 50 cars and about 10 locations (a few only available for certain modes). The DLC consists of about 14 cars, 1 NEW location only available for Rally, and 1 Recycled DiRT 2 location, only for Rallycross.
.

So you pay 40 euros for the game and another 40 for what you described as less than a 1/4 of so called extra content... content that was ready to be release when the game was... I got the Monaco rally stage, a few cars and 20 euros out the door... yes Im a sucker but that doesnt make it right and he is right IMO its codies who are exagerating...

Just a question do you work for codies?

As for the OP try Dirt 2 instead - more locations , pretty much the same physics, graphics (filter colors aside) and cars and must be a lot cheaper
 
So you pay 40 euros for the game and another 40 for what you described as less than a 1/4 of so called extra content... content that was ready to be release when the game was... I got the Monaco rally stage, a few cars and 20 euros out the door...

Actually, that's not entirely true. While the actual content may have been ready to use in the game, from my understanding it was not approved by sponsors/manufacturers to be used in the game. Some of these companies are picky on what they allow in the game and how their cars are portrayed; others don't really care that much and will approve it straight away. However, as may or may not have noticed, the real-life liveries on the DLC cars (I think it's just them, but I'm not sure) cannot be used in DiRT Tour. Why? Good question, I don't know, but for some reason they couldn't be approved to use there.

Now, is this all absolutely ludicious? Yes. Is it Codemasters' fault that they have to go through so many hoops to get the content released? No, it's not. You know, they could just not bother with it at all. "Can we have the Lancia Stratos?!?" "Nope, we're too lazy to get the required approvals for it and you guys would just whine about paying for it anyways."

yes Im a sucker but that doesnt make it right and he is right IMO its codies who are exagerating...

No, I agree that it doesn't make it right at all, but you aren't in a great position to whine and cry about it if you paid them for it. Complain with your wallet, not your keyboard on an unrelated forum. If you want to vent, fine, but in the end you had a choice, you didn't have to buy them.

By the way, he is not right, with how he stated it:

The main problem with DiRT3 is that you only get half of the game, and the other half is being released as DLC, which you have to pay for.

As I have said, that is wrong. It is a FACT that more than half of the TOTAL DiRT 3 content that you can have is in the RELEASED game. About 25% (probably less) is actually available as add-on content. That is a fact.

Now, if you want to argue that of the TOTAL price paid, half was for DLC, then by all means, do so, but that's not what he said. As far as the US goes, the DLC will not equal half of the total price paid for all content until the game sells below $40 (it's $60 at most retailers still, $45 at amazon, on sale at Kmart this week for $40, but only this week).

Just a question do you work for codies?

No, but I sure wish I did. :)

As for the OP try Dirt 2 instead - more locations , pretty much the same physics, graphics (filter colors aside) and cars and must be a lot cheaper

More locations - yes. More cars - Nooooooooo. I bought DiRT 2 3 weeks ago, it doesn't have more cars. There are 35, to be exact, which is what the game says. From what I could tell, a LOT of Rally cars were shared with the Trailblazer cars, just modded, not to mention the different variations of buggies and landrush trucks. Not so with DiRT 3.

I will say though that since the OP is in the US, it won't be a walk in the park to find DiRT 2, for a reasonable price. New copies are sold for $30-40, I've seen a few Gamestops selling it used for $25, which is too steep IMO. I ended up getting a copy at a mom-and-pop shop for $10, but only after looking for weeks. I really just got lucky.

It probably is in the OP's best interest to just rent it anyway, no sense in buying it if you won't like it (unless you're just filthy rich, which in that case, can you buy me a new car? :))
 
You must have a diferent Dirt 2 than mine, because mine has more cars, trucks and buggys (if you dont count the dlc)

The Lancia Stratos was in Dirt 1, for your info, so I really dont understand what was the point you where trying to state with your reasoning...

You claim you do not work for them but then claim to know their reasons for releasing the DLC.... I claim to know them better then you (reasons) and it was all about money, nothing more nothing less and the timing was nothing more than fiding the best strategy the make the most profit possible and unless you can quote or directed me to a trusted source well... its just your reasoning against mine...

Now the OP was concerned about spending some money on a game and I gave him a good advice... I had a better time playing Dirt 2 than what I did playing Dirt 3 and it cost me a lot less... 1/3 to be more precise
 
Get DiRT 3. There's no question it's awesome. There aren't quite as many tracks as DiRT 2 but there's also Gymkhama, has better cars in my opinion, looks better, has actual DLC (which is good and bad), online is fun...
 
You must have a diferent Dirt 2 than mine, because mine has more cars, trucks and buggys (if you dont count the dlc)

By definition it does not. It has more versions of the same cars. DiRT 3 has a bigger variety of cars.

The Lancia Stratos was in Dirt 1, for your info, so I really dont understand what was the point you where trying to state with your reasoning...

It was a random car I chose from the DLC. Any car from there could be inserted in its place.

You claim you do not work for them but then claim to know their reasons for releasing the DLC.... I claim to know them better then you (reasons) and it was all about money, nothing more nothing less and the timing was nothing more than fiding the best strategy the make the most profit possible and unless you can quote or directed me to a trusted source well... its just your reasoning against mine...

Okay.

http://twitter.com/#!/Kick_Up/status/86883032694398977

http://twitter.com/#!/Kick_Up/status/81425199941169153

At this point, I don't give a rat's arse what you think or whether you want to believe me or not. You obviously consider them the devil's work and they're out to steal all of your money. You never had to buy them. Of course they want to make money off it, but they also (presumably) wanted to give fans more variety in return.

Now the OP was concerned about spending some money on a game and I gave him a good advice... I had a better time playing Dirt 2 than what I did playing Dirt 3 and it cost me a lot less... 1/3 to be more precise

FYI, you gave him good advice if he lived in Europe. In his situation, buying DiRT 2 for $30+ instead of DiRT 3 is an idiotic decision imo. Unless he can get DiRT 2 for under $20 (not an easy feat) than he should get DiRT 3.

This is, of course, assuming he likes them. If he doesn't, that argument is moot. And I'm not even going to argue the ethical actions of Codemasters anymore.
 
I use gamefly, and I had to stop after 50% the way through, so I sent it back. The original is still the best. I kept trying to get through 3, but I just couldn't. Some things that were good; rewards for not using flashbacks, the paths of completion were deeper. Bad: Lack of tuning ability, the top competitions (X Games) weren't extra tough or long. I also just don't appreciate Gymkhana, so maybe that's where they lost me.
 
I wanted to buy Dirt 1 because it has Pikes Peak hill climb but Game Stop still wants 30 U.S. for it, talk about snorting glue. I'm not going to pay that for one track event.... Gerrrr....
 
Last edited:
I wanted to buy Dirt 1 because it has Pikes Peak hill climb but Game Stop still wants 30 U.S. for it, talk about snorting glue. I'm not going to pay that for one track event.... Gerrrr....

I heard DiRT3 had the hill climb track... is that not true?
 
Okay.

http://twitter.com/#!/Kick_Up/status/86883032694398977

http://twitter.com/#!/Kick_Up/status/81425199941169153

At this point, I don't give a rat's arse what you think or whether you want to believe me or not. You obviously consider them the devil's work and they're out to steal all of your money. You never had to buy them. Of course they want to make money off it, but they also (presumably) wanted to give fans more variety in return.

Right like if redoing an Dirt 2 track and some Dirt 1 cars would cost all that money they cashed in... you can keep your rats arse... no need for it :dopey:
 
Back