Test of Mercedes SL55 AMG '02

  • Thread starter Thread starter sporkafife
  • 24 comments
  • 7,768 views
Messages
146
Messages
sporkafife
Mercedes SL55 AMG '02

6160964158_35bf1358d4_z.jpg

Hello, today I present to you a test of the Mercedes SL55 AMG '02. Although this car is nearly 10 years old now, I can wholeheartedly assure you that it's no slouch. Under the bonnet (and behind that large flashy grille) lies a 5.5 litre supercharged, AMG tuned V8 good for over 500BHP. Impressive? It needs to be, as this car weighs in at just under 2 tonnes (1955kg to be precise). I chose a track that I thought would suit the car well: The Top Gear Test Track. It is well known for being a power circuit, perfectly suiting this nutty AMG nuclear bomb. However, the tracks difficult corners will also help to weed out any undesired handling artifacts of this 2 tonne 500BHP monster.

6160964854_00c4e7e010_z.jpg

I line the car up ready to start the lap, slowly building up the revs with my right foot. The car is automatic, so I rely entirely on the launch control system to get me moving. The exhaust rumbles away behind me in a surprisingly civilised manner for an AMG. I focus on the run down to the first corner, and wait for the signal to release 500BHP to the rear wheels.

6160968770_4a4a9a47c0_z.jpg

Even the electronic launch control trickery can't contain the savage power of this car and the rear wheels spin up a short trail of smoke. Not the fastest get-away, but impressive nonetheless.

6160965800_898dc0f92f_z.jpg

The run down to the first corner is over after a surprisingly short amount of time. The gearbox in this car may be automatic, but it has no problems dealing with the power that the supercharged V8 can deliver, and the car is doing 115mph before it reaches the braking point for turn 1.

6160968128_9173e3d9f8_z.jpg

The first corner is not the smoothest. As the weight shifts, it is almost possible to hear the front right tire screaming in pain. Due to the weight of the car, there isn't as much front end grip through the corners as you would hope, pulling the whole car wide in a slightly disappointing wave of understeer.

6160429767_5ae9e976ee_z.jpg

On the exit of turn 1, I put my foot down. Unsurprisingly, this brings a small amount of power oversteer which is easily corrected by a flick of corrective lock. However, I begin to fear that the antics in this first corner may be an omen of things to come...

6160969396_1bba981c9b_z.jpg

I brake for Chicago, half expecting this heavy car to simply carry on going. But the brakes seem to do the job of slowing the car down, leaving me suitably impressed.

6160970764_774c2f30ef_z.jpg

Any feeling I had of being impressed is quikly wiped out, as the car understeers like a boat throughout Chicago as the heavy V8 at the front almost drags the entire car onto the grass, leaving the apex laughing at me.

6160433395_5860c30c67_z.jpg

I push down on the gas, hoping to leave the first part of the lap behind me as quickly as possible. I am rewarded by a huge surge off acceleration. The last few disappointing bends had made me forget how fast this thing goes if you put your boot down. 2 tonnes of metal being fired down the road like a slingshot is a pretty awesome feeling. I begin to eye up hammerhead, I would not let the understeer catch me me here.

6160972232_d626a6b17a_z.jpg

I brake smoothly and turn into the hammerhead, clipping the apex perfectly. As soon as I feel the front end starting pulling outwards I mash the accelerator, unleashing 500 furious horses. Enough to maintain a rather impressive powerslide on the exit of hammerhead

6160431249_21970fe78c_z.jpg

I once again start to build up speed, but it would take a braver man than me to take on the follow through at full pelt in this behemoth. I quickly dab the brakes before entering the turn at about 90mph. Despite every cell in my body telling me to lift, I keep the gas pressed down as I head towards the tires.

6160972816_a34818c329_z.jpg

I shoot past the tires at over 120mph, and pull hard to the left. I clip the grass on the inside of the corner, but the suspension easily irons out any bumps. I feel happier with this middle section of the lap, but I don't stop to contemplate it and lay my sights firmly on the finishing line

6160434303_5b0a516cc4_z.jpg

With a car like this, you need to be committed to your lines. Hesitate for a moment, and you will probably find yourself in a ditch. I brake solidly before turning the wheel to the right. I am greeted by a familiar understeer, but I am able to keep it under control with some gentle throttle work.

6160975548_c923c1c7c0_z.jpg

To sum up most of the lap, the car understeers through the final corner.

6160976154_03d957c9c9_z.jpg

I cross the line and bring the car to a stop with a disappointed feeling in my mind. The thought of a 500BHP Mercedes is usually enough to excite anybody. You may think of long powerslides, but unfortunately this car will most likely only bring you understeer. The car does have a perfect 50-50 weight distribution, but the suspension is too soft and the car rolls. Too much weight is shifted to the front outside tire on the entry to a corner and you are dragged wide. In a race, this would result in a less powerful car taking you on the inside line.

Final thought: I wish I loved this car. It seems bonkers on paper, but it's too heavy, too powerful and too soft to be any good around a corner. I guess this car really is just for show offs who like big numbers.

3/10

P.s. This is my first car review, any criticisms and advice will be taken into consideration :)
 
Test drove a SL 63 AMG on a track in CA for an AMG promotion going balls out in it.

Before I got into the car I thought the same thing about it going to be to heavy and too soft, but honestly it was the best car I have ever driven. They did a wonderful job compared to the SL 55 AMG.

I would have to say that it handled better than my STI :grumpy:
 
Awesome read. Bot 3/10 is damned harsh, I would give that to the LP640 maybe, but this car 6/10 AT LEAST.
 
Am I wrong or cars have more body roll now??
6160968128_9173e3d9f8_z.jpg


I've also noticed it doing the Mini seasonal
 
Last edited:
Awesome read. Bot 3/10 is damned harsh, I would give that to the LP640 maybe, but this car 6/10 AT LEAST.

Maybe that was a bit harsh... it was the early hours of the morning when I wrote this up so I didn't put much thought into the score at the end and I was feeling a bit mean :lol: I'd probably say 5/10 now, I would say 6/10 but I drove the Jaguar XKR today which is considerably better lol
 
Great write-up. 👍
Too bad they did SL55 horribly in GT5 - rear left taillight doesn't work and rev-meter is completly broken.

While taking the photos I did realise that the modelling for this car was pretty sub par for most premiums (still looks much better than any other game though lol)
 
Nice review!
Although it's a bit harsh 3/10.. :P
In my opinion considering everything I'd give it a 5/10

I prefer the SL600 but the SL55 AMG is a very fun drift car! :D (I haven't modified my SL55 and don't intend on doing so as it has enough power lol)

Is there not a better section to put this thread in? GTP should really make a car review section as this doesn't really fit in 'Questions and Answers' and reviewing is becoming more and more popular.
 
Are you turning the wheel or hitting the analogstick? Because that last one may give you understeer
 
Great write-up. 👍
Too bad they did SL55 horribly in GT5 - rear left taillight doesn't work and rev-meter is completly broken.
It's a shame. And it's odd considering that the SL55 is one of Kaz's cars.


To OP
Great idea in doing this. Maybe more people will do this testing you're speaking of?


Nice review!
Although it's a bit harsh 3/10.. :P
In my opinion considering everything I'd give it a 5/10

I prefer the SL600 but the SL55 AMG is a very fun drift car! :D (I haven't modified my SL55 and don't intend on doing so as it has enough power lol)

Is there not a better section to put this thread in? GTP should really make a car review section as this doesn't really fit in 'Questions and Answers' and reviewing is becoming more and more popular.
All great points. 👍
 
I'd prolly go for a 6 or 7 out of ten personally.

Hope to buy one in real life one day when i'm rich and famous, would likely end up putting on different rims, better suspension and maybe better brakes.

Been in love with the car ever since i saw one in 2006 folding the roof into the boot - was like a robot. :D
 
Nice review, especially for a first time. But 3/10? Really? I'd give it at least 5 for purely being an AMG, then another 2 or 3 points for the noise (sounds like :drool: IRL, dunno about GT5), but then take 1 point away for the handling. But what you need to bear in mind is that the SL55 isn't a sports car, however much Mercedes may try to claim that. It's a 2 ton cruiser with the engine from a battleship wedged into it. Handling isn't that high on its priority list, as you'd expect.

I might do one, after all, I do review cars like this myself……

Edit: Just remembered, I did one on the SL65, was pretty much like your experience with the 55, only with more POWERR and more handling antics.:lol:
 
Last edited:
On the topic of how you scored the AMG - 3/10
I think you should of driven the old SL500, newer SL500 (R230) and then the SL55 AMG to actually properly appreciate it, as I really do feel it's worthy of more than 3! :P
Wonder what the SL500 would of been like for you if you were to review that, 0/10? Haha :P :D
 
iamjajo
Your car review is incomplete without a lap time for comparison to other vehicles in this class.

The lap time was somewhere in the 1:20 region (from a standing start) and to be honest I was driving more to get a feel for the car than for a hot lap.
 
Your car review is incomplete without a lap time for comparison to other vehicles in this class.
Bull. It's not a rule of car reviews. I recently wrote a series of reviews, not once did I mention a lap time, and they included 5 cars. Sometimes, it's not just about lap times. Sometimes, that just doesn't matter.
 
Bull. It's not a rule of car reviews. I recently wrote a series of reviews, not once did I mention a lap time, and they included 5 cars. Sometimes, it's not just about lap times. Sometimes, that just doesn't matter.

I suppose your reviews were also missing some important information too. If performance doesn't matter, then why review the car? (let alone 5 cars).
 
I suppose your reviews were also missing some important information too. If performance doesn't matter, then why review the car? (let alone 5 cars).
Um…nope. I don't think I'm missing info, rather, it's that you need to learn that the people who write reviews like me, uMadson, C-ZETA, etc all focus on one thing. Driving feel and fun. We (me especially) rate those points as being more important than speed. Speeds nice, as are lap times, but only for comparisons. They aren't the deciding factor. My old reviewing style always had a small lap times comparison between the before and after effects of a tune. I've dropped it now, and it's not made a single difference.

Still, have your say, quoting C-ZETA. And here's a hint. Sometimes, the split times between the two are in the text.
 
The lap time was somewhere in the 1:20 region (from a standing start) and to be honest I was driving more to get a feel for the car than for a hot lap.

Now, you've piqued my interest. That's a pretty good lap time on this track for a stock car. I think I'll buy one and check it out. Thanks!
 
Um…nope. I don't think I'm missing info, rather, it's that you need to learn that the people who write reviews like me, uMadson, C-ZETA, etc all focus on one thing. Driving feel and fun. We (me especially) rate those points as being more important than speed. Speeds nice, as are lap times, but only for comparisons. They aren't the deciding factor. My old reviewing style always had a small lap times comparison between the before and after effects of a tune. I've dropped it now, and it's not made a single difference.

Still, have your say, quoting C-ZETA. And here's a hint. Sometimes, the split times between the two are in the text.

Sorry if you didn't like my feedback on what I'd like to see in car reviews. I was trying to be constructive.
 
Sorry if you didn't like my feedback on what I'd like to see in car reviews. I was trying to be constructive.
:lol: Ohhh!!! That's what you meant by that!!! I read it like someone ranting :lol: Sorry about that, my mistake. Whoops.
 
I love the SL series. People who are trying out this car must understand that it was never designed to be a fast track car, it is sport car which is save and luxury as a S class Mercedes.

Btw: PD must add the W221 S65 AMG...
 
iamjajo
Sorry if you didn't like my feedback on what I'd like to see in car reviews. I was trying to be constructive.

I know, I took your comment on board :) If I was to make another review I'd make sure to at least compare it to a similar car. Plus I might ditch the number rating, it's too difficult to quantify how good a car is and even if you try, somebody else will have a completely different opinion :lol:
 
Back