Top Gear Written Review - C6 Z06

  • Thread starter Thread starter Elegy
  • 254 comments
  • 12,304 views
Young_Warrior
Actually I have it right infront of me. Caddy xlr onmerc sl chassis. Straight out of top gear magazine.

Then Top Gear is wrong.

Cadillac XLR
GM Y-body platform.


The XLR is a luxury sports car sold by Cadillac and is assembled in Bowling Green, Kentucky. It is based on the same Y-body platform as the Chevrolet Corvette.

And isn't the BLS a car for the European market alone - and not actually on sale yet? Still, the Saab 9-3 is an Opel/Vauxhall Vectra under the skin, so it's a Cadillac based on a Saab, based on an Opel...
 
Ok topgear could very well be wrong but I thought the c6 had leaf springs whilst the xlr boasts Independent, double wishbone all round.

In everyhting Ive read however keeps on mentioning the merc sl albeit I know that theyre competing against one another but its too much of a coincidence that every article I read theyres a direct comparison.
 
Young_Warrior
Actually I have it right infront of me. Caddy xlr onmerc sl chassis. Straight out of top gear magazine.
Uhhh, NO.
Motor Trend
When production cranks up next May, the XLR will be built in the same Bowling Green, Kentucky, plant that assembled the 33,655 Corvettes sold last (calendar) year. It has essentially the same hydroformed frame-rail construction as the Vette. The two will share body and paint shops, but will be assembled on different lines. He also acknowledges that many of the same electronics, suspension, body structure, braking, heater/ventilation/air-conditioning, and even some driveline components will serve in the next-generation C6 Corvette (the current car is internally dubbed C5). Many industry critics jokingly refer to the XLR, which will carry a considerable $30,000 premium above the C5, as the "Vette Version 5.5."

Leone tells us that using this Corvette-derived rear-drive platform was not a certainty from the start. GM's new Sigma chassis, currently used under the '03 CTS sedan and later to be offered under the '04 SRX crossover and '05 Seville, was considered for the XLR. But because the Corvette's underpinnings were conceived from the start for convertible duty, it seemed a more natural match.
So far I'm 80% right to your 20%. And I did apologize for that 20%.
 
i doubt it was top gear that was wrong. magazines dont usually make such a big mistake when it comes to cars. after all they get a press kit from the manufacturer
 
neanderthal
i doubt it was top gear that was wrong. magazines dont usually make such a big mistake when it comes to cars. after all they get a press kit from the manufacturer

It was in the new car section where they list every car on sale in the UK.They usually have mistakes in the back there every now and again as its probably written by one of the back benchers of the top gear magazine.
 
im not saying you were wrong, after all theres a chance I could be wrong. im just doubting the veracity of your tale based on how magazines work. simple.
 
neanderthal
i doubt it was top gear that was wrong. magazines dont usually make such a big mistake when it comes to cars. after all they get a press kit from the manufacturer
Look, please, the XLR is NOT based on any Mercedes product! The XLR and the SL500 are in direct competition for the same market segment (more or less), YES, but the XLR is a real, dyed-in-the-wool, American-engineered GM product that shares some mechanicals with the C6 Corvette.
 
Real caddis
images

images

images




imposters

images

images
 
You've got the break in the wrong place. It goes like this.

Real Caddies:

images

images

images


Imposters:

images

images
 
The XLR is a Corvette, the BLS is a Pontiac G6 but there are Saab componets.
 
Back