What is your best and worst game of the year? (Poll for GOTY Added)

  • Thread starter Thread starter SkierPS3
  • 82 comments
  • 4,937 views

What was the best game of the year?

  • Skyrim

    Votes: 21 24.4%
  • Battlefield 3

    Votes: 21 24.4%
  • Forza 4

    Votes: 6 7.0%
  • Killzone 3

    Votes: 1 1.2%
  • Modern Warfare 3

    Votes: 7 8.1%
  • Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword

    Votes: 2 2.3%
  • Halo Combat Evolved

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Gears of War 3

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Uncharted 3

    Votes: 12 14.0%
  • Portal 2

    Votes: 2 2.3%
  • Other (specify in comments)

    Votes: 14 16.3%

  • Total voters
    86
  • Poll closed .
I'm surprised that Archam City isn't on anyone's radar.

Best: Archam City, iNFAMOUS 2
Worst: Marvel 3, MW3
 
Best for me is hands down BF3.

Worst... Hmm not really sure. Didn't really buy anything bad this year myself.
 
I'm putting down the, always under rated, Dark Souls. It was an absolutely AMAZING experience. I tried Skyrim but just got pissed off at its piss-poor PC port. I've put more hours into Morrowind than any other game and Obvlinion and now Skyrim can just not live up to the Elder Scrolls series to me, they're just re-hashes in my opinion.

Dark Souls was immersive, brilliantly designed, constantly engaging, and the cross-play feature was done even better somehow.

Just an amazing experience no one should miss out on.
 
Dark Souls is stellar, but I throw my vote in for BF3. If I'm objective about it BF3 does have it's problems, I can see why people don't like it and find it frustrating but for me the experience is just full of atmosphere and so is Dark Souls. Both games I struggle to convey to people who don't play them how much I like them, but they're both a little inaccessible for new players so I have to persuade them to do more than just try it.

The only reason I pick BF over Dark Souls is MP, I really like how they have treated MP on Dark Souls with the sort of parallel worlds feel but I wish there was a more fully fledged co-op mode and that is the only thing that stops me playing more of it over BF3. These 2 are definitely my top 2, if I was to throw in a 3rd I would probably say Dirt 3 or the game nobody seemed to love, Crysis 2.
 
TankAss95
I didn't even know it was available in Wii. :dunce:
Yeah stuff like martyrdom and last stand were really annoying.
I remember my friend made an ultimate class:MP5 with red dot
3X special stun
Juggernaut
Dead silence

Honestly we played 1v1 on shipment all the time and he kept on beating me. I used to call him a noob for using juggernaut.

Anyway back on topic MW3 is a great game, and I doubt that anyone really dislikes it like they claim they do. I do agree that it is a disappointment in some areas but SP and Spec Ops alone make it worthy of attention IMO.
Any further comments of such then I suspect the user to be in support of implicit fanboyism. :lol:

I honestly dislike it like I claim to hate it. When I play MP I don't have the slightest bit of fun on it anymore which is why I stopped playing it.
 
Note: Summary at the end if you don't want a long read. Apologies if this is all completely uninteresting, but it's a discussion I enjoy to think and write about.

When I play MP I don't have the slightest bit of fun on it anymore which is why I stopped playing it.

This is my problem to, I loved COD4 because at the time it was fresh for me the last FPS I played online alot was COD Finest Hour on PS2 which I loved to (discounting Socom 1/2/3 for being 3rd person). I liked World at War as well because it was a fresh experience with the engine and some good ol' fashioned bolt rifles, both had problems but both were good fun at the time. MW2 was still fun because I had a good group to play and banter with, thanks GTP for that, and the frustrations didn't usually stop me from pub stomping and causing more frustration then I would receive and even though it was on the ridiculous side it was still fun. I did prefer Bad Company 2 (due to taste) though I played less of it due to time and lack of people to play with, a game which played alone couldn't really shine because without at least 1 extra gun by your side the impact you could have on a match was vastly diminished.

Blops was a little strange, I really liked it much more than MW2 but after a month or 2 I just started to get fed up of the same old. I never played any of them religiously so I didn't burn out to fast, but even though in my mind I know objectively Blops was the best one for me by being balanced, not to frantic, added a bit more gun skill and so on but subjectively I wasn't enjoying myself any more and it was a little odd. To me Blops felt so right and yet so wrong, had it come out any time before MW2 I would have played it so much more but the simple fact of the matter is I was fed up of the same experience by then. It's not surprising to people that know me that I prefered Blops, I like fast action but MW2 with it's danger close, shotgun secondaries and crazy air support was to far, Blops was more toned down and I loved it for that and were I have to play a COD game now, I'd get Blops.

That leaves MW3 as a game which keeps the same core experience I'm now fed up of and adds or brings back, in comparison to Blops, features I don't want or value on maps I don't like the design of. I won't lie I haven't played it Having played it finally all my suspicions were on the money for me, because in 2011 I got an alternative so I don't feel the need to buy COD just so I have an FPS to play with friends. I got Battlefield 3.

Unlike the previous incarnation, BF3 provides the same immersion and atmosphere I always loved in a Battlefield game which is something that never really fades because you always feel like a small part of a big picture. This time though I felt like my small part was just as important as any other, alone or with friends, so unlike BC2 I'm free to enjoy it as I want, when I want and not when my friends are online. It allows you to run and gun as much as I personally would ever want to (which BC2 didn't) but doesn't restrict you to it like MW3 seems to but it also allows you to fly a jet, blow things up with tanks, provide true meaningful cover fire with an LMG, storm buildings to flush out a stronghold, dart through an enemy set up in a hummer, provide support from mid range with a battle or assault rifle, provide recon or sniper support from half a mile away, set up an ambush for tanks and troops alike, the list could go on. Sure the control and 'feel' of the game aren't as intuitive as COD, it takes longer to get comfortable with your aim but once you get the glove to fit I'd not have it any other way.

BF3 is a game which you have to put time in to, if you don't have that time to put in, it will never truly reward and there are still reasons to prefer COD depending on the type or shooter experience you want, but if you want to really feel like you're in the battlefield the clue is in the name.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Sorry for the rather long little retrospective for the genre on this generation of consoles, and that's discounting other series I dipped in to I could make a whole thread if I wanted to and give my FPS experience as a whole on PS3.

Long story short COD has been to similar year on year for to long now for me, and I'm the kind of person who doesn't bore easy of something I enjoy, I don't think the 'hate' to either BF3 or MW3 is right as both games are great for their own reasons. The mistake not to make in this thread is treating posts as if people are reviewing games, the title of the thread implies what games which you have bought were the best or most disappointing and not what was the best or worst game of the year period. The best is not always the same as most popular, MW3 is the worst for many because of the hype that surrounds it even though there are worse games but people go in expecting something incredible and find something else entirely often. Does that mean it's bad? No, but it's not as good as everyone makes it out to be and for that matter BF3 isn't either. For the people who share similar preferences though they both are the best with no alternative.
 
Last edited:
For ps3 only
Best: mass effect 2
Worst: shift 2, game has so much potential.

My categories vote is

Shooter: Battlefield 3, awesome blend of vehicle and infantry combat.
Action/adventure: Deus ex HR, Decent storyline but excellent gameplay so much freedom.
Racing: F1 2011, Might be a reskin but better handling plus safety car.
Sports: Tiger woods 12, Finally implementing decent move support, still no john daly's.
Fighting: Mortal Kombat, Back to the old school, love it.
Hidden gem of the year: Sniper ghost warrior, apparently crap on the xbox but i love it. Multiplayer is good if a bit campy, but its supposed to be.
 
I think my favorite game this year has been Battlefield 3. It's Singleplayer wasn't as good as MW3, not anywhere close, but it's Multiplayer blows MW3 out of the world. Skyrim was a great game as well, it just never grabbed my attention like Fallout 3 did. Maybe it's just because I have an obsession of apocalyptic worlds?

The worst game this year that came out, let me think for a while. I don't want to say MW3, because I loved the Singleplayer that much. Forza 4 was just incredible, same with Battlefield 3, Skyrim I know is a good game, I just never got hooked to it like I did on Fallout 3. I would have to say TDU2. I enjoyed the game a lot, but it just pales in comparison to Forza 4 or GT5. It felt more like homework to complete all the challenges, some of them just utter pointlessness. So overall, that's my least favorite game of the year.

Speaking about CoD4, that was a great multiplayer. You can still play it also, not too many players, but there's still a few. I loved the overkill perk, AK-47, and AK-74. My two favorite guns! Plus I went 34-2 with an MP5 on one of the maps, something I can't do after any CoD game after MW2.
 
I'm not so much bothered by your "best" choices, but calling Battlefield 3 the worst game of the year is insanity. And uncharted 3 is an amazing game. Fun, deep, and good multiplayer.

To be honest, it's a bit hypocritical to disregard someone elses opinion based solely on your own. MW3 is a decent game and is far from the worst game of the year. It's odd that you picked two outstanding examples of the same genre and made them the best and worst games respectively.

Best for me; Skyrim, need I say more? 60 hours in and haven't started the main quest, thieves guild, Dark Brotherhood, College of Winterhold quest or anything :D
Worst for me; Hunted: The Demon's Forge. Could have been such a good game but was flawed in so many ways.
 
Last edited:
I really want to love Skyrim because I like almost everything about it except one thing, the combat. It somehow lacks finesse to me, at range it's not to bad which would be a strong part of my build when I probably will still get it but the sword play feels sort of meaningless and thoughtless. I was tossing up Dark Souls or Skyrim and settled for Dark Souls because although the combat isn't exactly more complex on the pad there is a certain level of finesse with every fight in the timing of your attacks, dodges and blocks and you are ultimately punished until you learn and adjust to each enemy. I have played Skyrim and it's certainly a step up from previous, but it still doesn't feel satisfying to fight most enemies. In a perfect world I'd have Skyrims expansive environments and quests with Dark Souls style combat, though perhaps with a cut in difficulty to make traversing such a huge scape a bit easier.
 
Is it possible to update a poll? There are several games I want to add to the list.
 
Best game of this year has to be Uncharted 3 for me. Worst is nfs shift 2 unleashed of the games i have bought/played this year... (or more likely most disappointing compared to what i expected)
 
If I were to go by a great time waster game, then it would be minecraft, which is the reason who I choose the "Other" option. I'm not a fan of FPS's at all, never played Forza 4 or the Zelda game, and I never had an interest in Skyrim. So I was left with Portal 2 or the Other option. Minecraft would easily be the top indie game of the year but with the hundreds of hours I wasted on it for only a price of $15 from buying it during Alpha, it would be my choice for GOTY. Checked the current price converted from euros, even at $26.62 USD, it's quite worth the money if you don't mind no goal. Well minecraft now does have a goal but that's just to beat the enderdragon in The End. so there is sort of a goal but the main reason why I got it is to be creative and have fun in a adventure with a friend.

Though Portal 2 comes up as a good 2nd top GOTY. Loved the story and the puzzles were good. Another game that is not in this list is a free indie game but it is so well designed and fun like the old 90's arcade driving games. I'm talking about Nitronic Rush. It combines 90's arcade racing with the Tron movie looks(which I admittedly have not watched yet) and techno music. It actually has a story mode and a level for doing all sorts of stents in a 5 minute limit.
 
Only after reading this do I realize I haven't bought a single game this year. Last game I bought was GT5 on December 26th, 4 mile round trip walking in the snow. Nearly died 4 times that day from weather related consequences, all worth it though.
 
The best for me is Skyrim by far. Very addictive, great graphics, great gameplay, a game in which you can submerse yourself in for 3 hours with it feeling like 30 minutes.

Worst game, MW3. Found it totally boring and very very similar to the other Modern warfares.
 
Best : Skyrim - probably, it is the best of the series so far and a well polished product of old formula. If its not broken don't fix it, just make it better. Which they did.

Bad - Test Drive Unlimited 2 - Could have been awesome, but due to insane bugs, the fact that it didnt work most of the time, and a few not so well thought out ideas ultimately killed what could have been a really great game.

Shift 2 - It was a decent game but it just disapointed in too many of the overhyped areas, horrible controls and input lag killed it the most.



Not sure if its fair to say the worst games of the year but they were very disapointing. Your list is missing quite a few great games released this year. Crysis 2, F1 2011, Dirt 3 for example.
 
My game of the year has to be Skyrim. It's just fantastic. A living, breathing world, filled with many different choices, quests, and factions. I love the Art style, the combat feels so much better than Oblivion, and in general a brilliant game.

However, close contenders of mine include Minecraft, Uncharted 3, Battlefield 3, Forza 4, and I think Zelda is a bit of a dark horse here. I haven't played it, but I think it's definitely been overlooked. There are some other games that have also been overlooked, maybe Red Orchestra 2 and Total War SHOGUN 2.

Worst games...hmmm...I will agree to an extent that TDU2 was pretty terrible, there was so much potential but it was ruined by bugs that weren't really fixed.
 
Ive only bought 3 games over the course of this year so i can only base my choices on them so here it goes:

Best game:PES 2012 ,finally pes is fun to play again

Worst game: Dirt 3, not to bad of a game but out of the 3 ive played definally the worst

The other game is MW3 good game but just more of the same really
 
It could have been MW2 if it were actually an MW3. But it isn't, because they're both exactly the same.

I haven't exactly tried any of the top games this year this side of FIFA 12, really. And I'm bored of that. So I don't really have an opinion on it.
 
I voted Skyrim as best, but Forza 4 and Uncharted 3 are right up there. Really, if the vote were for which game I've had the most fun with so far, it would be Forza 4, but really, it's just more Forza 3, so I don't think it deserves to be called "best".

Worst game? Dragon Age 2. They took an incredible game and ruined it. Unforgivable.
 
You need to add a few PC games to that list. Witcher 2 which would be my pick for game of the year, and I would put iracing on the list also after the huge update it had. Also Battlefield 3 is a completely different experience on the PC, and it should be listed seperate from the console version. Mine would be
1. witcher 2
2. iracing
3. BF3 for PC
 
I'd like to change my vote to Skyrim from BF3. I played it for a couple of days on a friend's computer, and it's just an incredible experience.
 
I would've voted Skyward Sword, as I have been enjoying it very well.
Haven't played a good Zelda game since Twilight Princess.
But instead I voted others

Best: Gundam Extreme VS
Even though it is pricy due to importing it from Japan, it is definitely worth every single bit of money that I spent on it. $100.
I no longer have to spend more money on the arcade just to play this game. This + fightstick = EPIC

Worst: Dirt 3
The concept was great overall, but I really couldn't stand the physics and with the very short Rally tracks. So I am sticking with Richard Burns Rally.
 
Last edited:
Only games I got that came out this year were Pokemon Black Version, Pokemon White Version, and Bleach: Soul Resurreccion. Out of those, the Bleach game I thought was the best.

As for worst, I can only put down the Pokemon games even though they were great.

I haven't really been buying many games these past few years, and have started caring less about video game news. I can't name many games that came out this year even.
 
Back