Which One's Better?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Condraz23
  • 5 comments
  • 494 views

Which one would you rather live in?

  • Brave New World

    Votes: 12 92.3%
  • 1984

    Votes: 1 7.7%

  • Total voters
    13

Condraz23

(Banned)
Messages
215
Would you rather live in the society presented by George Orwell's "1984" or Aldous Huxley's "Brave New World"?

Brave New World is a dystopian novel by Aldous Huxley, first published in 1932. Set in London in 2540, the novel anticipates developments in reproductive technology, biological engineering, and sleep-learning that combine to change society. The world it describes could also be a utopia, albeit an ironic one. Humanity is carefree, healthy, and technologically advanced. Warfare and poverty have been eliminated and everyone is permanently happy. The irony is that all of these things have been achieved by eliminating many things from which people currently derive happiness, family, cultural diversity, art, literature, science, religion, and philosophy. It is also a hedonistic society, deriving pleasure from promiscuous sex and drug use, especially the use of soma, a powerful stimulant taken to escape pain and bad memories through hallucinatory fantasies.

George Orwell displays his perception of a dystopia in 1984. Surmised technological advances, such as telescreens, are used to the benefit of the party and to exploit greater control over the masses, not to improve quality of life as intended. Elaborate strategies, such as perpetual warfare, are used to deny the masses, or proles, the education needed to understand the potential for a better life.
 
I'd pick Brave New World, without a second thought. Aperture Golf is much more fun than slave labor, and Soma is tastier than Victory Gin. Even if kids are born in what seem to be described as photographic darkrooms, at least they're not tools for a leader that brainwashes you into hating Oceania and Jews.
 
I think it would be cool to be an Emo kid in Brave New World.
 
Can I say that I really didn't care for either book? I don't know if it is just were we are today, but I found Brave New World to be rather boring and not very interesting, as I had no connection and no real understanding of any of the characters. I guess between the two, 1984 was a better book, but it doesn't sit on my bookshelf for any reason.

...Maybe its because I'm older or because I'm a political science student, but a good Dystopian-future book is Mark Steyn's America Alone. Although it isn't a triller, fictional tale, it sets up the basic idea that the world will be very different in less than 50 years if we continue on the path we are on, and it isn't one that we will like.

So, yeah... My two cents I guess...
 
Can I say that I really didn't care for either book? I don't know if it is just were we are today, but I found Brave New World to be rather boring and not very interesting, as I had no connection and no real understanding of any of the characters. I guess between the two, 1984 was a better book, but it doesn't sit on my bookshelf for any reason.

...Maybe its because I'm older or because I'm a political science student, but a good Dystopian-future book is Mark Steyn's America Alone. Although it isn't a triller, fictional tale, it sets up the basic idea that the world will be very different in less than 50 years if we continue on the path we are on, and it isn't one that we will like.

So, yeah... My two cents I guess...

The question was regarding which setting you'd rather be in. Otherwise, there is no relation to the books or your preference of each story.
 
Back