As a Liverpool fan, the schadenfreude of this whole Man U season and situation is glorious. However, as a rational human with the ability to do critical thinking, this is such a silly situation for such a big club to be in.
Carrick saved this club from basically this situation last season with the amazing run to 3rd place. Somehow turning this dying squad into something incredible, with even washed up players like Casemiro suddenly looking like the greatest midfielders in world football again.
Once again, a club legend interim seemed like the right choice to keep over the summer without major options out there, but clearly something happened over the Summer and the players just didn't buy into what Carrick was trying to do. Once again, they have downed tools to get a manager they don't like sacked, and this time the fans have made it clear that they don't like that this has happened. Carrick did not deserve to be sacked, but he needed to go because things weren't going to get better. Well, they could do - if the club could sack players instead. But that's not an option.
United needs a complete rebuild. They need someone who can get the higher-ups to do what the manager wants. It what Amorim was promised and needed, and as soon as he made it public he couldn't get that, he was fired. Carrick was never going to get that either, and he also isn't the kind of manager who can do a rebuild.
Look at Spurs. They've realised this and basically given De Zerbi the keys. Is he the kind of manager who can do it effectively? Not sure but that's the gamble and there weren't many options at the time they needed to sack Tudor. Similarly,
Unai Emery has the keys at Villa and has turned the side into one that can regularly compete in Europe. United just don't have the board willing to let this happen.
United needs this relegation battle to be saved at this point as the wake-up call Tottenham seem to be finally heeding. That said, if Poch suddenly gets results on the new manager bounce, then shame on these players for downing tools at the start of the season.
Also the squad clearly needs a whole rebuild, which will once again be crazy expensive because the only ones worth anything would need to stay (Lammens, Mbuemo, Cunha) while the failures dragging down the squads aren't worth much to anyone any more (Maguire, Dalot, Shaw, Mount etc).
The best thing Poch can do to show he is serious is to strip Bruno of Captaincy. His fickle and poisonous approach despite clear leadership qualities is a net negative for this squad. Give it to someone else - maybe Rashford to try and get him back on side as the best academy graduate of the last 10 years - and see what happens.
After all, it can't get much worse than this...
You may be relying on the Man City verdict being sorted this season to avoid relegation.