2026/27 Premier League & General Football Discussion

  • Thread starter Thread starter Liquid
  • 202 comments
  • 11,058 views
Carrick has been sacked, he probably deserved to go but the way he has been treated in the last few days has been shocking,
The sordid highlight of this whole saga might be BBC Sport catapulting themselves into the running for hypocrites of the year with this headline:


(Not included, the preceding dozen+ articles of the week prior or the "pieces" last month that were barely a step above character assasination)
 
As a Liverpool fan, the schadenfreude of this whole Man U season and situation is glorious. However, as a rational human with the ability to do critical thinking, this is such a silly situation for such a big club to be in.

Carrick saved this club from basically this situation last season with the amazing run to 3rd place. Somehow turning this dying squad into something incredible, with even washed up players like Casemiro suddenly looking like the greatest midfielders in world football again.
Once again, a club legend interim seemed like the right choice to keep over the summer without major options out there, but clearly something happened over the Summer and the players just didn't buy into what Carrick was trying to do. Once again, they have downed tools to get a manager they don't like sacked, and this time the fans have made it clear that they don't like that this has happened. Carrick did not deserve to be sacked, but he needed to go because things weren't going to get better. Well, they could do - if the club could sack players instead. But that's not an option.

United needs a complete rebuild. They need someone who can get the higher-ups to do what the manager wants. It what Amorim was promised and needed, and as soon as he made it public he couldn't get that, he was fired. Carrick was never going to get that either, and he also isn't the kind of manager who can do a rebuild.

Look at Spurs. They've realised this and basically given De Zerbi the keys. Is he the kind of manager who can do it effectively? Not sure but that's the gamble and there weren't many options at the time they needed to sack Tudor. Similarly,
Unai Emery has the keys at Villa and has turned the side into one that can regularly compete in Europe. United just don't have the board willing to let this happen.

United needs this relegation battle to be saved at this point as the wake-up call Tottenham seem to be finally heeding. That said, if Poch suddenly gets results on the new manager bounce, then shame on these players for downing tools at the start of the season.

Also the squad clearly needs a whole rebuild, which will once again be crazy expensive because the only ones worth anything would need to stay (Lammens, Mbuemo, Cunha) while the failures dragging down the squads aren't worth much to anyone any more (Maguire, Dalot, Shaw, Mount etc).

The best thing Poch can do to show he is serious is to strip Bruno of Captaincy. His fickle and poisonous approach despite clear leadership qualities is a net negative for this squad. Give it to someone else - maybe Rashford to try and get him back on side as the best academy graduate of the last 10 years - and see what happens.

After all, it can't get much worse than this...

You may be relying on the Man City verdict being sorted this season to avoid relegation.
 
As a Man Utd fan since I was 6. I hope potch fails. If the only way to get rid of the rot above the manager is relegation then so be it, and conceding goals like we are will ensure that. Teams at the bottom cannot allow goals in like we do. Scoring more than they do is not going to work.
 
You won’t change the owners and management if you still buy tickets, kits and show a profitable business. The fans allowed this to happen with their own wallets.

If the moneys not coming in then it gets sold.
 
Last edited:
The fans support the club and the team, not the owners.
 
You won’t change the owners and management of your still buy tickets, kits and show a profitable business. The fans allowed this to happen with their own wallets.

If the moneys not coming in then it gets sold.
We will always support the club but getting rid of Wilcox et al will be enough.
 
United needs a complete rebuild. They need someone who can get the higher-ups to do what the manager wants. It what Amorim was promised and needed, and as soon as he made it public he couldn't get that, he was fired. Carrick was never going to get that either, and he also isn't the kind of manager who can do a rebuild.
United needs a complete rebuild starting from higher up than the coach. The entire organization needs to be "cleansed".

As long as the club is US owned by people that clearly only focus on PR and income, and have no passion for its history and the sport itself, I seriously doubt anything will change.

United needs to at least be relegated in order for people to wake up.
 
You won’t change the owners and management if you still buy tickets, kits and show a profitable business. The fans allowed this to happen with their own wallets.

If the moneys not coming in then it gets sold.
The fans support the club and the team, not the owners.
It was, ultimately, a fan boycott that got Chansiri out. Well, that and him thinking that the Mayor of Sheffield could get HMRC off his back, but he wouldn't have needed that so much with the 30,000-gates we've been getting weekly since.


Speaking of which, anyone remember a couple of weeks ago where an accidental clash of players resulted in someone dying from "blunt cardiac trauma" and, despite being obviously an accident, the other player got sent off and a (likely moot, as he probably won't want to play again) 12-match ban?

1794824349002.webp


Yellow card.

Viewed at speed it's obviously accidental, and Lowe wasn't seriously injured, but studs to that general region is a Big No No. Except in League One.
 
Swansea manager Vitor Matos is leaving the club to take charge of Strasbourg in French Ligue 1. The news has come out of nowhere and it only broke last night, he has only been at Swansea for less than a year but has done well. We had a really good start to the season and were top of the Championship for a few weeks but four defeats out of the last five sees us in sixth just three points off top.

Matos was somewhat in demand and he was one of the names linked with the Crystal Palace job but they were always going to go for Thomas Frank. I don't think that Strasbourg is a step up from Swansea and I also don't think that Ligue 1 is a stronger league than the Championship, he has clearly done this for his career and never really card for the club.

The Swansea job is an attractive one as we have good owners who have the money to invest in the club and players. I like to think that we are a club going places and I'll be really interested to see who will get the job next.
 
[...] I don't think that Strasbourg is a step up from Swansea and I also don't think that Ligue 1 is a stronger league than the Championship, [...]
Season 6 What GIF by The Office
 
Strasbourg are 13th in Ligue 1, Swansea are 6th in the Championship.

Its barely a step up, barely!
 
Strasbourg are 13th in Ligue 1, Swansea are 6th in the Championship.

Its barely a step up, barely!
Strasbourg have already played most of the top teams in their league, While Swansea have some tougher games ahead.

Swansea have played 32.6% of their season so far while Strasbourg have played 29.4%.

Ligue 1 has more elite teams as well, PSG, Marseille, Monaco and Lille.

I suppose you’re trying to defend Championship because your favourite team is in relegation zone so you need Championship to seem better than it is.
Edit: Actually I don’t think you believe this, I actually don’t think you know how good football from other teams is outside your bubble.
 
Last edited:
You won’t change the owners and management if you still buy tickets, kits and show a profitable business. The fans allowed this to happen with their own wallets.

If the moneys not coming in then it gets sold.
While a half empty Old Trafford would cause a stir, I don't think it does long lasting damage. The tickets would already be sold, therefore the fans would simply be no-shows, which could constitute a breach of the terms and result in fans losing their season tickets without being able to receive a refund. The club would face the animosity of people seeing a half or mostly empty stadium for a couple of games, before the season tickets were cancelled and ultimately the seats would be resold. As no one would receive a refund, the club would lose money short term due to food, drink and merchandise sales that they take in on match days. Longer term, reselling the tickets while retaining the money they sold the tickets for initially would likely outweigh that. For the fans who would lose the tickets, likely be blacklisted and not get refunds, it's a lot to ask for.
 
While a half empty Old Trafford would cause a stir, I don't think it does long lasting damage. The tickets would already be sold, therefore the fans would simply be no-shows, which could constitute a breach of the terms and result in fans losing their season tickets without being able to receive a refund. The club would face the animosity of people seeing a half or mostly empty stadium for a couple of games, before the season tickets were cancelled and ultimately the seats would be resold. As no one would receive a refund, the club would lose money short term due to food, drink and merchandise sales that they take in on match days. Longer term, reselling the tickets while retaining the money they sold the tickets for initially would likely outweigh that. For the fans who would lose the tickets, likely be blacklisted and not get refunds, it's a lot to ask for.
Unfortunately, I think you're right. In fact the owners would LOVE to resell the season tickets owned by real fans to plastic ones...

The issue being that the casual attendees won't give a **** about the situation so won't boycott anything.

In addition, most of the merchandise income is likely from overseas sales, so any boycott of that in the UK wont get noticed either.

It was the same problem at Reading and elsewhere, no easy resolution as the owners don't give a monkeys. Perhaps they could do what the Reading fans did and bring a load of tennis balls...?
 
Anyone know why a red was given to Leahy in the box in Oxford vs Wycombe last night? Wild game with great goals
 
Funnier still, they don't play at home again until November 22nd, so that'll be a minimum of 399 days and 22 games.
And they drew, with Blackburn Rovers. Burnley have now joined us on 23 successive home games without a win, but over almost a month longer at 399 days. That'll become at least 401 games as their next home game is on Wednesday... against fourth-place Birmingham City.


Also Watford have sacked another manager, so I guess it must be Sunday.
 
Liverpool 4 Man Utd 0. The more things change the more they stay the same. The fact that we can't stop conceding goals is why I'm sure we are going down. Second bottom now.
 
Its certainly debatable as to whether it was a red card but the defending that led to it was appalling. Poch has a huge job on is hands, we in a relegation battle for sure.
 
Its certainly debatable as to whether it was a red card
Shoulder into the back to prevent a goal scoring opportunity, it’s a red, it’s not debatable.
 
Isak had a heavy touch, keeper was always going to get to the ball.
 
Its certainly debatable as to whether it was a red card but the defending that led to it was appalling. Poch has a huge job on is hands, we in a relegation battle for sure.
It's not debatable IMO, he didn't have control of the ball at the moment of the foul so it should've been a yellow and a free kick. And you know what, Liverpool probably score the fee kick and win anyway, but that doesn't get the officials off the hook.

They keep getting worse each season, and for all teams not just United, and not just today. United should've fine better defenceively ebmven afte t going down to 10 men.

And the players are damned if they do, damned if they don't. If they go down they're divers, if they don't the officials don't give them anything.

But it's a shame the game today is marred by yet another major officiating error. However it might have gone regardless, the officials are once again the talking point.
 
Back