ABS off vs ABS 1

  • Thread starter Thread starter Trux
  • 130 comments
  • 14,220 views
Greetings. Long time listener, first time caller. This site has been great over the years, even in the days of GT4. I am the type that normally just reads and never post anything, but I would like to try and give something back to this site. Most of my gaming time these days is COD, but I mix in some Nascar nights every now and then along with giving the GT Academy a go.

Early when the game came out, someone posted a comment about something Kaz said in the strategy guide or somewhere. They claimed he said ''your apex speed will be faster in the turn with ABS OFF''. So after that i ran with it, I never used any assist of any type.

I could never apply real world motorcycle tuning knowledge to the GT5 world. Adjust this or adjust that never felt right. So i always used some of the great turning minds here to get a proper car setup. Praiano ended up being my go to guy. He has a great list of cars with great tunes.

When the game came out, it seemed everyone just went with ABS 1 and never challenged tuning beyond that. There was a saying that went something like ''if your not driving on Sports Soft, your missing out on a great part of the game''. I think that is because when you drive on Sports Soft, even with ABS 1, you have to go into the corner and brake smoothly because of reduced traction. I feel the effect is simular when you run ABS OFF with Race Softs. I always wondered the amazing things that could happen if some of the great tuning minds would have went ABS OFF.

I have had Logitech Driving Force Pro since GT4. But i prefer the DS3. Maybe because of the years of time I have with controller and unable to leave wheel set up all the time. I use R2 throttle, L2 brake, R1 shift up, R3 up to shift down.

I primarily ran Race Soft 600pp Street cars without Front Downforce. Brings a wide mix of cars together with controllable high performance. I would consider myself average driver ability.

With ABS1 you can brake late and square turn off, feels robotic. With ABS OFF you need to have a more rounded line while allowing for bumps or imperfections in the track. Many of those you will notice with ABS OFF that you would not of noticed with ABS1. Such as the top of the hill of the S turn at laguna or the many challenges of Nurb.

With every car my starting point on Braking Bias was 2F 0R. Made adjustments depending on how the car reacted on different tracks. Race cars with Front Downforce the brakes will need to be stronger. I set those by how much braking power I need at the end of the fastest straight of that track. My primary focus is on Street cars without Front Downforce,

I beleive most all the MR cars work the best with ABS OFF. There are some cars that just do not seem to drive well with or with ABS. I love the Z06 and tryed endlessly to make it work. With this car and many other FR i had an issue with the rear under long heavy high speed braking. Such as the end of the long straight at Fuji GT. When the car slows to around 35mph the rear wants to step out while still in a straight line. It is as if rear tires lift and car wants to pivot on front. I felt i was getting some improvement by adjusting rebound stiffer. But im not a great tuner so i could not pinpoint what was exactly needed.

Most turns on most tracks only require a small amount of braking to begin with. At the end of a long straight such as Fuji, I give 1 full pump of the brakes, then letting out from there to a 40% type of hold quickly going to a 10% or less trail brake into the apex.

One thing I feel about ABS OFF is it changes the feelings of the car in the turn. With ABS ON car feels tight going into the turn, loose coming out. With ABS OFF it kinda seems reversed, loose going into turn, tighter coming out. I beleive it makes the settings of LSD come into play. With ABS ON it seems it kinda voids the LSD settings. ABS OFF it allows your LSD settings to go to work.

When i tryed to turn someone on to ABS OFF, I recommended that you should increase you LSD Braking Decel Sensitivity. The number is not the same for every car, but many of them go 30+ in my feel. Just like when everyone took to ABS1, they also took to LSD Braking Decel Sensitivity to the lowest setting, 5, or close to it. Makes sense because with the lowest setting it turns the sharpest with little to no issue about stability because ABS ON is correcting that factor. But with ABS OFF most cars will be unstable at the middle or end of hard braking and it will be difficult to trail brake. The rear of the car will try and step out.

If you gear down to soon at end of long straight the rear wants to step out. It helps me to gear down later than I know I should.

I try and adjust the LSD Braking Decel Sensitivity to the highest value possible without the car pushing in the turn. Each car has a sweet spot and personal preference. Some cars need to sacrifice some turning ability for braking stability. My best reference was always at Fuji Gt going into turn 1. Full pump of brakes at the braking point, then release to hold about mid value, then trail small value into the turn. If car is not confident, try to add some more LSD Braking Decel Sensitivity. Try adding more than 40. See if it is suitable.
If it will get around turn 1 Fuji Gt, should be good at most anywhere else. To me it is a perfect line in that turn when the rear has slid out just a touch on entry and exit. I rather the car to feel a little tight, because with ABS OFF you can steer with the rear. I do not mean drifting, perhaps the term is powesliding, it is on the edge of traction limits.

In the end it causes you to pay mind to ABS users behind you in the braking zone and allow others space. With ABS OFF bumper taps are more pronounced.

It was great they put in lobby options to turn ABS off finally. The ablility to limit front down force is still missing last I saw.

I hope something there helps someone.
 

Good writeup. Just goes to show that disabling braking assist just shaves yet another layer off this game to get to the purest experience. There's so many things you don't have to consider when you have ABS on 1.
 
Still enjoying the no ABS, today I took the immersion factor up another notch: Nordschleife in the Weds Sport, cockpit view and HUD off. Tons of fun.

Great write up MotorBreath.👍 Welcome to GTPlanet.
 
OK8
I'm really glad to see so many people who enjoy this game without ABS. Many people are sceptical to try it, saying it just makes you slower, but so does turning SFR off. In the end it ends up giving you so, so much more enjoyment and feel.

I do think this a misconception though. Quite often I can run just as fast with no ABS due to the extra weight shift feeling. Sure it means there is one more thing to make a mistake on, but I've manged to take a title without using ABS and the driving style is slightly different but I wouldn't have said it was slower when you've been using no ABS for a while. 👍
 
With all this ABS off talk I am getting pumped up to start a room up in 20 min. We can use my league PGTR for rules which gives the participants a realistic experience because off the non abs usage. We also have fixed brake balances for every car which gives the cars in GT5 some identity when it comes to brakes. This is for the lack of brake upgrades in GT5. 👍 We can set the tires either to comfort soft or sports hard. Let me know who want in the theme will be the car you would love own in real life that is in GT5. This will be fun. Please put your car you want to use so I can give you the brake balance. Hope you guys join. 👍
 
I do think this a misconception though. Quite often I can run just as fast with no ABS due to the extra weight shift feeling. Sure it means there is one more thing to make a mistake on, but I've manged to take a title without using ABS and the driving style is slightly different but I wouldn't have said it was slower when you've been using no ABS for a while. 👍

Very encouraging words. I've been running without ABS from the start and the only time I've actually used it was in a league I was running a couple months ago.

I'm starting a couple new ones in a couple weeks so I might have a crack at it without ABS.

Today has been a really good day in terms of GT5. Very good races on the nordschleife with comfort medium tyres, heavy damage and no ABS. Even after all this time of playing this game, I often still get fresh "oh man I love this game" -moments.
 
OK8
Very encouraging words. I've been running without ABS from the start and the only time I've actually used it was in a league I was running a couple months ago.

I'm starting a couple new ones in a couple weeks so I might have a crack at it without ABS.

Today has been a really good day in terms of GT5. Very good races on the nordschleife with comfort medium tyres, heavy damage and no ABS. Even after all this time of playing this game, I often still get fresh "oh man I love this game" -moments.

Gus aka Gustradmus told me you guys had some intese racing today im jealous I was not there. :grumpy:
 
OK8
Very encouraging words. I've been running without ABS from the start and the only time I've actually used it was in a league I was running a couple months ago.

I'm starting a couple new ones in a couple weeks so I might have a crack at it without ABS.

Yeah, finished on the podium in every race I finished. :D But the car was the '96 Lotus Elise which is very stable under braking. :)
 
Abs higher than 1 is nonsense in this game. No one uses it.

Also TC. When is someone IRL with TC off quicker than someone with TC on? TC is very poorly designed in this game.
 
Joie de vivre!
Abs higher than 1 is nonsense in this game. No one uses it.

Also TC. When is someone IRL with TC off quicker than someone with TC on? TC is very poorly designed in this game.

Oh you know what the higher value ABS does, good.

I've been asking what ABS 7 does, what does it do?

Many thanks.
 
Abs higher than 1 is nonsense in this game. No one uses it.

Also TC. When is someone IRL with TC off quicker than someone with TC on? TC is very poorly designed in this game.

Majority the time. Unless they are a inexperience driver.
 
Majority the time. Unless they are a inexperience driver.

Every single driver in F1 uses traction control to some degree. When they removed TC back in the days of Senna, the lap times dropped massively.

Wouldn't consider them to be inexperienced.
 
Every single driver in F1 uses traction control to some degree. When they removed TC back in the days of Senna, the lap times dropped massively.

Wouldn't consider them to be inexperienced.

What is some degree I watch F1 and I though they all drove with no aids just as many other motor sports.
 
What is some degree I watch F1 and I though they all drove with no aids just as many other motor sports.

They ran various electronic aids in the late 80's and early 90's before they were banned. Then reintroduced in 2001.

Although. I don't think you can use F1 as an example as regulation changes and development skew the values rather. :indiff:
 
A completely new scene is forming online, comfort medium, no abs and heavy damage. I've had brilliant races with these settings in the last couple days.
 
I had a room set up like that, Tsukuba only, comfort medium, no brake assists, no other aids allowed, heavy damage, fuel/tire consumptions, penalty. It took half hour to get decent drivers joined in, some of them quit after one race, complaining about brake assist and tires restriction. I had the room set up for only R32-R34 GTR with 485pp limit and no mod allowed as well.

Planning to set up such room this weekend with same gen model cars limitations, eg : Integra DC2/DC5, Subaru WRX GC/GD, Lancer EVO I-IV or V-X, Civic TypeR EK/EP, MX5 NA , NB or NC, and many other possibilities. Of course no mod allowed to make things fair and competitive.
 
OK8
A completely new scene is forming online, comfort medium, no abs and heavy damage. I've had brilliant races with these settings in the last couple days.

And I can attest to this! Fields of 10 at the Ring at night, usually 6-7 making it to the end.

Very clean and courteous driving, with enough skill to go 2 wide in tricky sections with negligible amounts of contact, very nice.

Every bit of input matters, every dab every turn. One tire on the grass, and its curtains.

I was in a NISMO Z33 S-Tune battling for 4th (OK8 the beast is matchless in his RX7, or 512BB, and probably anything for that matter) with a stock Z33 and a Z34, we were bumpers to bumper to bumper for 3/4 of the 2 lap race, literally 5-10 meters apart, intense.

The satisfaction isnt from a win or podium, its the sweaty hands, the rush, the "almost" real sense of nervousness, knowing 1000 things can go wrong, but keeping it together one section at a time and making it in one piece.

There is Hope.
 
And I can attest to this! Fields of 10 at the Ring at night, usually 6-7 making it to the end.

Very clean and courteous driving, with enough skill to go 2 wide in tricky sections with negligible amounts of contact, very nice.

Every bit of input matters, every dab every turn. One tire on the grass, and its curtains.

I was in a NISMO Z33 S-Tune battling for 4th (OK8 the beast is matchless in his RX7, or 512BB, and probably anything for that matter) with a stock Z33 and a Z34, we were bumpers to bumper to bumper for 3/4 of the 2 lap race, literally 5-10 meters apart, intense.

The satisfaction isnt from a win or podium, its the sweaty hands, the rush, the "almost" real sense of nervousness, knowing 1000 things can go wrong, but keeping it together one section at a time and making it in one piece.

There is Hope.
That was so intense yesterday :lol: It was my worst performance ever yesterday. I need to practice the ring at night it is a completely different track at night! I really feel bad for the people talking about they are bored wih GT5. They need to get out their comfort zone and join some online races rather than coming on GTP to complain how bored they are.

OK8
The RX7 is a good car, you should try it :). See you online again soon!
You are a demon on that track are you fast like that on every track? I am so glad you are representing PGTR. With your help, to obtain license, cars, and other goodies it's going to be challenging for the participants to get.
 
<LongPost>
After reading this thread with great interest, I decided to have a go at the ABS=0 story. At the moment I am running the 24hr of Le Mans, 13 hours into the race.

Before I made the change to turn the ABS off, I was consistently lapping at 3:28 during my racelaps (not the in or out-laps) and I was 2 laps ahead of the R8 in second. (also driving an R8, all aids off, ABS=1, using a G25)

Then it was time to make the move: I turned the ABS off. What a difference! I remember in the beginning when I got GT5, I once tried driving without ABS at 1 but that didn't go too well so I stuck with ABS fixed at 1. But now I forced myself to actually try it.

Well the first two stints didn't go well at all. Lost 1 lap to the other R8 in second (running about 3:33 at racepace) due to all the snap-oversteer and c***-ups I made. But then settled for a brake balance of F5/R2 and started to get a feel for it. I started lapping at 3:40, relatively consistent, though braking much earlier than with ABS=1.
The next stint, the car seemed to come to me and I was running at 3:30 and found that the car was more eager to turn-in and felt more composed mid-corner. I was still braking earlier but could maintain a higher cornering speed. Maybe you think this is just a feeling but I really believe (proven by the 3:26's I lapped) that even though I was braking earlier I was effectively faster with ABS=0 than ABS=1. Yes, I still do get some snap-oversteer and lock-ups from time to time, but the racing is just on a whole new level. 13 hours into the 24 hours it kind of starts getting a tad bit boring (mainly due to the low number of opponents). Now it's interesting again, racing yourself I could call it.

So what is my input in this thread besides my findings. I'm interested in sharing my technique that I am using. I already read in this thread the "pumping" the brake-technique, well, I'm doing something similar.

During a race course I took a couple of years ago, the instructor told me that if you cannot heel-toe because you have not mastered it, or because it is difficult/not possible in the car you are racing, you need to compensate the lack of heel-toeing in your braking.
Bear with me: When you release the clutch, the revs go/shoot up and you get some serious - critical - engine-braking before the revs go down again and you get "normal" engine-braking. This critical effect is nullified when using heel-toe because you blip the revs with the accelerator so that the revs do not go up due to clutch engagement. So to not lock-up the tyres caused by this critical engine-braking, you have to release some of the pressure of the brakes to compensate for the added stopping power supplied by the engine (and added clutch wear :dopey:).
So the technique I use is release a bit of pressure of the brake pedal for a fraction of a second when downshifting, let's call it inverted brake pumping. Works like a charm for me. Though I do admit, on the last part of my braking phase for some of the slowest corners, I also press the accelerator (just a wee bit). Maybe somebody finds this useful, please let me know or maybe you have a better technique, I'm willing to learn :sly:
</LongPost>

TL;DR-version: ABS=0=good

So, bottom line, I believe that driving with ABS=0 is faster. There is a whole lot more than just tyre rotation that is controlled by ABS in GT5, that is a fact. But, and maybe that's a big but being currently limited to the 24hrs I'm running, I do presume that every car behaves differently. I'm quite happy with my R8 running with ABS=0 but that might not be the case in an online shuffle with an unfamiliar car with the rest of the pack running ABS=1.
Maybe someone can shed some light on that matter?
 
Last edited:
<LongPost>
After reading this thread with great interest, I decided to have a go at the ABS=0 story. At the moment I am running the 24hr of Le Mans, 13 hours into the race.

Before I made the change to turn the ABS off, I was consistently lapping at 3:28 during my racelaps (not the in or out-laps) and I was 2 laps ahead of the R8 in second. (also driving an R8, all aids off, ABS=1, using a G25)

Then it was time to make the move: I turned the ABS off. What a difference! I remember in the beginning when I got GT5, I once tried driving without ABS at 1 but that didn't go too well so I stuck with ABS fixed at 1. But now I forced myself to actually try it.

Well the first two stints didn't go well at all. Lost 1 lap to the other R8 in second (running about 3:33 at racepace) due to all the snap-oversteer and c***-ups I made. But then settled for a brake balance of F5/R2 and started to get a feel for it. I started lapping at 3:40, relatively consistent, though braking much earlier than with ABS=1.
The next stint, the car seemed to come to me and I was running at 3:30 and found that the car was more eager to turn-in and felt more composed mid-corner. I was still braking earlier but could maintain a higher cornering speed. Maybe you think this is just a feeling but I really believe (proven by the 3:26's I lapped) that even though I was braking earlier I was effectively faster with ABS=0 than ABS=1. Yes, I still do get some snap-oversteer and lock-ups from time to time, but the racing is just on a whole new level. 13 hours into the 24 hours it kind of starts getting a tad bit boring (mainly due to the low number of opponents). Now it's interesting again, racing yourself I could call it.

So what is my input in this thread besides my findings. I'm interested in sharing my technique that I am using. I already read in this thread the "pumping" the brake-technique, well, I'm doing something similar.

During a race course I took a couple of years ago, the instructor told me that if you cannot heel-toe because you have not mastered it, or because it is difficult/not possible in the car you are racing, you need to compensate the lack of heel-toeing in your braking.
Bear with me: When you release the clutch, the revs go/shoot up and you get some serious - critical - engine-braking before the revs go down again and you get "normal" engine-braking. This critical effect is nullified when using heel-toe because you blip the revs with the accelerator so that the revs do not go up due to clutch engagement. So to not lock-up the tyres caused by this critical engine-braking, you have to release some of the pressure of the brakes to compensate for the added stopping power supplied by the engine (and added clutch wear :dopey:).
So the technique I use is release a bit of pressure of the brake pedal for a fraction of a second when downshifting, let's call it inverted brake pumping. Works like a charm for me. Though I do admit, on the last part of my braking phase for some of the slowest corners, I also press the accelerator (just a wee bit). Maybe somebody finds this useful, please let me know or maybe you have a better technique, I'm willing to learn :sly:
</LongPost>

TL;DR-version: ABS=0=good

So, bottom line, I believe that driving with ABS=0 is faster. There is a whole lot more than just tyre rotation that is controlled by ABS in GT5, that is a fact. But, and maybe that's a big but being currently limited to the 24hrs I'm running, I do presume that every car behaves differently. I'm quite happy with my R8 running with ABS=0 but that might not be the case in an online shuffle with an unfamiliar car with the rest of the pack running ABS=1.
Maybe someone can shed some light on that matter?

You just have to find people who run ABS 0 then you will be good 👍 Nice post. the BB you ran on your R8 is perfect. I run a leauge and every car has a fixed BB. The R8 that you speak of cannot go any lower than 5/2. 👍
 
Check out this series for some ABS off racing. Practice race this Sunday with the real races starting up in a few weeks.
 
I still don't understand this ABS off thing..
on some cars it's very difficult to control while braking even in a straight line, for example say.. Ferrari 512 BB.. I had to change suspension settings and brake bias to the extreme to make it drivable without ABS.
but on other cars, the ABS off is very easy.. I just ran 650PP nurburgring seasonal Aspec 4 using Toyota GT One, brake bias 6/2 and it feels almost no different than ABS 1.. I could brake while turning FAST and the car still run stable without problems..
 
I still don't understand this ABS off thing..
on some cars it's very difficult to control while braking even in a straight line, for example say.. Ferrari 512 BB.. I had to change suspension settings and brake bias to the extreme to make it drivable without ABS.
but on other cars, the ABS off is very easy.. I just ran 650PP nurburgring seasonal Aspec 4 using Toyota GT One, brake bias 6/2 and it feels almost no different than ABS 1.. I could brake while turning FAST and the car still run stable without problems..

Racing cars already have a lot stiffer suspension to limit the movement of the rear which is ultimately what makes the car feel unstable under braking or when braking and turning at the same time.

For road cars you don't have to change the suspension to make the car feel stable, it's just a matter of bad brake settings. I suggest you try 2/0, 3/1 or 4/1 for your brake balances and see how they feel. For 500pp cars I think 4/1 is good, but for below that I often have 3/1. On some cars even with 3/1 the rear tends to come out too much so you can try 2/0 or 3/0.

For optimum braking, the brakes should be strong enough to lock the fronts (never the rears) under hard braking. With these settings, you can control the brakes with your foot and keep it near lockup and you'll get the maximum out of your brakes while still leaving a bit extra brake froce for emergencies (sometimes someone brakes really hard in front of you or you want to pull a spectacular out braking maneuver). Locking the fronts in an emergency situation is not a bad thing if it keeps you from crashing to someone.

Driving without ABS takes practice since it's a much bigger thing than you'd expect, you have to change your style a bit if you've been racing with ABS for a long time. You should never try to turn when braking hard, and you should also pay close attention when coming off the brakes to do it smoothly and try to upset the car as little as possible.

Once you get the hang of these nuances, you'll soon realise why there is a small group of enthusiasts who never use ABS.

Check out this series for some ABS off racing. Practice race this Sunday with the real races starting up in a few weeks.

Hey! Thanks for linking that. Will definitely check it out.
 
Last edited:
OK8
Once you get the hang of these nuances, you'll soon realise why there is a small group of enthusiasts who never use ABS.

Nuances, that's what it's about...good choice of words. I didn't get the hang of no ABS after trying it a couple of times until recently when I committed myself to it and that's what the difference is...the nuances. How hard to brake, how deep to brake, can I brake while turning and how hard? Small adjustments in brake balances make big differences unlike with ABS where any brake balance will work. Different corners require different strategies. You have to drive the car the entire lap and be on your toes on every corner. It's a much more interactive and immersive experience with ABS off.

Bottom line is, you can't just get in and drive like you did with ABS. The car is much more alive, much more responsive and requires attention and concentration. But the reward is huge. It's like a whole different game now. I thought the transition from SRF to nothing but ABS=1 was huge but it was nothing compared to this. I wouldn't even go so far as to say that SRF is nowhere near as strong a driving aid as ABS is, no question. To take ABS off and run consistent lap times equal to your ABS times is incredibly rewarding and the driving is just so much more pure fun!!!
 
@OK8
Thanks a lot for your inputs!
But I actually don't have problems with the braking itself, my main problem is that twitching the back of the car soon after I release the brake.
I know it's because I tend to slightly turn the wheel while braking, but what I've seen in F1 races, those F1 drivers who locks up their tyres even turn their steering wheel to the extreme and then he let off the brake and the car never twitch like in GT5.. I'm still curious if this braking physics in GT5 without ABS is realistic or not?
Or maybe there is a special tuning that can prevent that twitch?
 
@OK8
Thanks a lot for your inputs!
But I actually don't have problems with the braking itself, my main problem is that twitching the back of the car soon after I release the brake.
I know it's because I tend to slightly turn the wheel while braking, but what I've seen in F1 races, those F1 drivers who locks up their tyres even turn their steering wheel to the extreme and then he let off the brake and the car never twitch like in GT5.. I'm still curious if this braking physics in GT5 without ABS is realistic or not?
Or maybe there is a special tuning that can prevent that twitch?

F1 cars stay pretty much rock solid no matter what forces go through them, while with road cars the weight moves around a lot. When you first brake hard, then suddenly take your foot off the brake while turning slightly, all the weight is on the front and the rear goes light.

Releasing the brake when the car is still unstable from hard braking is almost the hardest part of braking without ABS. With really tail heavy cars like the Yellowbird or BTR you have to always be very tender lifting off your foot and feel what the rear is doing by the steering wheel. Without force feedback and very limited movement available for braking (if you're using DS3) I can imagine it to be quite tricky.
 
OK8
F1 cars stay pretty much rock solid no matter what forces go through them, while with road cars the weight moves around a lot. When you first brake hard, then suddenly take your foot off the brake while turning slightly, all the weight is on the front and the rear goes light.

Releasing the brake when the car is still unstable from hard braking is almost the hardest part of braking without ABS. With really tail heavy cars like the Yellowbird or BTR you have to always be very tender lifting off your foot and feel what the rear is doing by the steering wheel. Without force feedback and very limited movement available for braking (if you're using DS3) I can imagine it to be quite tricky.

OK8 I wanna race with you on the ring so I can get a replay, let me know when you are available.
 
Back