Acceleration or Top speed more important?

What is more important? Acceleration or Top speed?

  • Acceleration

    Votes: 19 95.0%
  • Top Speed

    Votes: 1 5.0%

  • Total voters
    20
I'd say accleration because with out good accleration then you car might not have good top speed.

I for one like to get out in front early with my accleration.
 
It all depends on the track you're racing on. Neither one of these things helps you win a race without the other. ;)
 
I'd say accleration because with out good accleration then you car might not have good top speed.

I have to agree, to a point. In my GT-One I get pretty lousy low end acceleration and the pack runs off from me. But I quickly get it back, say in third gear, and run past them full steam and never look back. Maybe I need to tweak on my gears a little, but I don't think it would help much.

I think acceleration is the most important in GT3 because there are few stait aways long enough to max out a fast car anyway. Even SS 11 and Tokyo don't have long enough strait stretches for me to max out half my cars. I usually have to drive the Test Course the oposite direction so I have enough room to get up to max speed.

Acceleration comes in to play everytime you drop a gear for a corner and have to punch it to the floor to get back up to crusing speed. You use acceleration more than you use top speed is what I'm trying to say.

~LoudMusic
 
I voted for acceleration, but the issue really isn't all that black or white. Most tracks need good acceleration to make your way through the twisties...but if you have exceptionally poor top speed, you'll get your doors blown off.

The only tracks where top speed really takes precedence are Super Speedway and Test Course (natch).
 
Well I definetly think that acceleration is more important than top speed, because as mentioned most courses require acceleration after turns to get back up to a higher speed, and few courses will max out cars. Of course balance is essential, a car with a great quarter mile time that can't go over 150 mph is going to get blown away on all the courses with decent straightaways.
 
It has to be a delicate balance of the two. If you can go 200 MPH, but only have the room on the test track to get that high, what good is that in Cote D' Azure? If you can go 0-60 in 2.5 seconds, what is the difference if you car tops out at 130, and the pack averages 150 MPH on a lap?
 
It has to be a delicate balance of the two. If you can go 200 MPH, but only have the room on the test track to get that high, what good is that in Cote D' Azure? If you can go 0-60 in 2.5 seconds, what is the difference if you car tops out at 130, and the pack averages 150 MPH on a lap?

True True:burnout:
 
Originally posted by Tom McDonnell
It has to be a delicate balance of the two. If you can go 200 MPH, but only have the room on the test track to get that high, what good is that in Cote D' Azure? If you can go 0-60 in 2.5 seconds, what is the difference if you car tops out at 130, and the pack averages 150 MPH on a lap?

I agree with Tom also. :burnout:
 
If you can outaccelerate the opposition in the corners and block 'em on the straights, you can win on most tracks.

If you can only do top end, you'll lose on all but two tracks.
 
Originally posted by jervinator
If you can outaccelerate the opposition in the corners and block 'em on the straights, you can win on most tracks.

If you can only do top end, you'll lose on all but two tracks.

Ah, we are of one mind about this (see above post). :D
 
It's the Yin and Yang of racing. As everyone else stated, a fine balance of both ensures a victory.

I think gearing a car for the Max Top speed for the track is important. You don't want to be geared so low that your redlining half way down the fast straightaway, on the other hand, you don't want to be gears so wide that you can't accelerate out of corners.

With age comes wisdom.
With Wisdom comes understanding.
With understanding comes balance.

For a bee without a flower, the bee has no hunny.
For a flower without a bee, there would be no more flowers.

*did someone spike my coffee with gensing again?*
 
Originally posted by Pako
It's the Yin and Yang of racing. As everyone else stated, a fine balance of both ensures a victory.

I think gearing a car for the Max Top speed for the track is important. You don't want to be geared so low that your redlining half way down the fast straightaway, on the other hand, you don't want to be gears so wide that you can't accelerate out of corners.

With age comes wisdom.
With Wisdom comes understanding.
With understanding comes balance.

For a bee without a flower, the bee has no hunny.
For a flower without a bee, there would be no more flowers.

*did someone spike my coffee with gensing again?*

yep, that was me...I thought it would be funny....only now in this late hour do I realize the folly of my actions. :)
 
Originally posted by Pako
It's the Yin and Yang of racing. As everyone else stated, a fine balance of both ensures a victory.

I think gearing a car for the Max Top speed for the track is important. You don't want to be geared so low that your redlining half way down the fast straightaway, on the other hand, you don't want to be gears so wide that you can't accelerate out of corners.

With age comes wisdom.
With Wisdom comes understanding.
With understanding comes balance.

For a bee without a flower, the bee has no hunny.
For a flower without a bee, there would be no more flowers.

*did someone spike my coffee with gensing again?*

First ju get dee sugar
den you get dee power
den you get dee weeeemen.
-Homer Simpson
 
Well it appears I'm the only one to vote for top speed!

You need power for the top end, and you cajole acceleration by dropping all the weight out of the car. It doesn't matter if all the 4wds beat you out of the hairpins, because there's not that many corners that are really tight, and most of them are at the ends of long straights. So I use the top speed to breeze by half the field, then outbrake (with my light car :D ) the rest into the corners. Then block on the exit until the engine's spooled up again.

Just my $0.02
 
Originally posted by risingson77


yep, that was me...I thought it would be funny....only now in this late hour do I realize the folly of my actions. :)

:lol:
 
BOTH BUT ON TEST TRACK TOP SPEED I GOT a 3000gt with 1085 HP and does great and a viper with 10106 HP and they do good:fdevil: :Poke: -> -> :teleport: :teleport: :teleport: :teleport: :teleport: :argue: :cold: :cheers: :thumbsup: :smilewink
 
Originally posted by SuperRAcer
BOTH BUT ON TEST TRACK TOP SPEED I GOT a 3000gt with 1085 HP and does great and a viper with 10106 HP and they do good:fdevil: :Poke: -> -> :teleport: :teleport: :teleport: :teleport: :teleport: :argue: :cold: :cheers: :thumbsup: :smilewink



10,000 hp????? I cant get past 3000. :confused:
 
Acceleration. No question. WHat's the good of going fast if it takes you 1 min. to get there? By the time you're going fast, its time for the next turn.

;)
 
Back