DiRT 3 or NASCAR 2011?

[Suzumiya]

Sorry if this is not in the right section, but I need some advice from people that have played both games. Which one is the better one?

 

[Downhill Dino]

Nascar is boring. Get DiRT 3.

 

[Tempo0010]

Get Dirty dude

 

[nhlkaiser]

Dirt 3 all the way.

 

[mika haka]

there's still alot of bugs in nascar where as no one has come across any in dirt3, also remember dirt 3 requires an online pass (comes with new games). In my opinion dirt 3 is the more fun game, infact the only dissapointment ive had is that dirt 3 is a bit short with alot repetition.

Where as nascars career mode is just one season but racing 43 cars can be quite a fun experience but the game is easy on hard and impossible on very hard. They both offer different types of racing but dirt 3 is definately the more user friendly experience.

 

[Downhill Dino]

Online on DiRT 3. 'Nuff said.

 

[SmittMan]

DiRT or Driver when it comes out.

 

[Spagetti69]

DiRT or Driver when it comes out.

No wheel support in driver though.

 

[Suzumiya]

Which one has the better online play and features?

 

[prisonermonkeys]

How do you judge something as being better than something else?

 

[Downhill Dino]

You just ended the thread...

Not sure though. I guess you'd need a neutral player of course that doesn't lean to any side the slightest bit.

 

[prisonermonkeys]

Well, I can't really say one is better than the other without knowing what he would consider to be something that makes the game better. I admit, I have not played NASCAR 2011, but in describing DIRT 3, I could make reference to the free-roam gymkhana mode as a positive ... but is this something BayneHamlin would consider to be a good feature? Does he want a game that is ultra-realistic? Would DIRT 3's Party Modes be something he is interested in? Questions like that. I could easily describe everything that I think makes DIRT 3 a fantastic game, only to find that it's nothing he's looking for.

 

[MeanElf]

They are also extremely different kinds of games from each other...

 

[Suzumiya]

Well, I can't really say one is better than the other without knowing what he would consider to be something that makes the game better. I admit, I have not played NASCAR 2011, but in describing DIRT 3, I could make reference to the free-roam gymkhana mode as a positive ... but is this something BayneHamlin would consider to be a good feature? Does he want a game that is ultra-realistic? Would DIRT 3's Party Modes be something he is interested in? Questions like that. I could easily describe everything that I think makes DIRT 3 a fantastic game, only to find that it's nothing he's looking for.

Like game modes, stuff like that, and it doesn't have to be ultra realistic.

 

[tribolik]

If you go by game ratings or metacritic then Dirt 3 wins
If its is bugs that you are after then Nascar wins

But the most important thing you have to ask yourself is... do I like oval racing or Rally and freestyle drift and tricks...

To me its a no brainer - F1 2011 - kidding - Dirt 3 would be my choise between the two you mencioned