Ferrari 430 Scuderia vs 458

[GTRedline]

Which is prefered? I know most bought the 458, but a lot of people said they wished they got the scuderia. Any thoughts?

 

[Peter3759]

I prefer the Scuderia.

 

[IzoAzlion]

Scud here too.

 

[Lynyrd_Skynyrd]

I have both, I like the scuderia far more.

Lightness > Power

 

[aikitim]

i love my scudiera - took a bit of tuning, but it now pains me to even change car to do another race....

 

[Jrichter]

I bought the 458 very early on and even though this is my favorite car right now IRL, I got bored with it early on if that's even possible.

It performed so flawlessly in anything I entered it in so perhaps this is the reason. I have not upgrading anything yet (except racing soft tires and a full racing exhaust to spice up the engine note) so I'm sure I will be more into it when I start messing with it more. The 512 BB is more interesting to drive for me right now even though the stock vs stock performance doesn't compare.

I haven't bought the Scuderia yet so I can't really compare.

 

[ivatu]

Scuderia FTW!!!!!!!!

 

[Goshin2568]

Well I own a 458, and raced the Scuderia in the Grand Tour challenge, and the Scuderia was just more.... fun.

 

[Novice]

i bought the F430 Scuderia over the 458 Italia. It's no contest tho since the Scuderia is a tuned version of the regular F430.

 

[Jay]

I bought a Scud rather than the 458 (will also buy later) then a Enzo was spanking me in the straights of Monza so I bought a Enzo.

Don't get me wrong, I really do like the Scud but I assume the 458 will be a little bit quicker.

 

[Spacegoat]

I prefer the Scuderia.

+1:tup:

 

[audi S4]

Just wait till Ferrari comes out with the 458 Scuderia!!!! It will happen within the next year or so i predict. No clue what it would be called though??

That car will be savage.

BTW have the 458 and love it. Havnt tried the Scuderia other than when you drive it in the World Tour Special Race.

 

[Cosbuster]

Scuderia FTW

Although I skipped it for an Enzo.

 

[Novice]

i won the cavallino event with the scuderia, under B-spec i should say. so getting it in A-Spec should be easier.

 

[Joey D]

I bought the 458 and wasn't really impressed with it. I had to boost it up over 600hp to compete with the Enzo on the straights of Monza. For a car that was touted in real life to be as good as the Enzo, it comes up a bit short in the game. I wish I would have gone with the Scud to be honest.

 

[X-Power]

I bought the Scuderia, I prefer it's race-inspired appearance.

 

[Gooner17]

Scuderia for sure

It's just...... fun to drive it

 

[Host_Killer]

Just a note... on TopGear the 458 was only upstaged by the Enzo by ONE TENTH... So real world - 458

Enzo 1.19.0
458 1.19.1
430 Scuderia 1.19.7

 

[chimuel]

My fully tuned 458 is amazing.

 

[deviln3]

F430 was my fav car to drive in GT5p.. I'll get it again now, but will also get 458 no doubt

 

[topmounter]

I couldn't take the Enzo with my 430 Scud... until I tuned it.

 

[krakozyabr]

Fully tuned 458 is amazing. Precise and fast with lots of fun if with intermediate racing tires (i don't remember how exactly they are called).

Like 430 Scuderia as a stock car, very interesting to drive. In that case tuned 458 is boring.

 

[kd283]

I have both. my 458 is fully tuned and is my ring basher and is awsome. my scuderia is 575bhp on soft sports everything else is stock and its very nice to drive. also at 75mph plus its very good at drifting