Ok... before i get flamed for being an ass... I am basing this from my experieces in the game... since i HAD to choose one, i went with the scrooby again... if and i reiterate a big IF this is comparing a Spec C and an 05 Moosewang GT.... yes it matters which of the two cars and models you are comparing because if you compare say.... a '99 22B STi and a '99 SVT Cobra, I'd pick the Cobra, or... an earlier STi with a Shelby GT 350, gotta go with the Shelby. This is a very braod subject ramrod... better specify which of the model years you ar comparing. Either way it's like comparing apples and oranges.