There seems to be a bit of theme on GTP at the moment... plenty of 'how clever can I sound by finding something really inane and/or irrelevent to compain/moan about' threads. But the people posting in these threads aren't the real GT fans... they'll be off playing the next 'latest game' in a month or so.
As I see it, GT5 is a great game for the core GT fan... it has an outstanding physics model, loads of quality cars and enough tracks to keep us entertained for a loooong time. But most importantly, we have private on-line rooms... sure, the on-line is a bit hit and miss at the moment, but once the novelty has worn off and the 1 month gamers have moved on to their next game the drain on the servers will drop and it will be fine. Because once we've golded the license tests and the challenges, and finished career mode this is what the game is really about... close, clean on-line racing with your mates in interesting cars.
GTP will calm down a bit too... we'll probably lose some of the people who just joined up for a month or 2 to whine and moan, but those members are no loss, and we'll get back to our happy (most of the time!) community.
Your post personifies what I percieve as the fundamental divide between past and present GT fans, and actually past and present gaming.
It appears you give yourself away as the latter, with your comment:
"this is what the game is really about... close, clean on-line racing with your mates in interesting cars."
There has never been "online racing" in a previous GT.
Consequently you must be a GT5 fan, not a GT fan.
The online feature is a facilitation of the physics, tracks, and cars.
It has little to do with
"the game".
That said, I have been racing off an on, in a variety of games, "online" since PGR2.
While it can be fun and enjoyable, it cannot replace or be a substitution for a good in depth Career or single player mode.
Previously GTs strong suit, particularly GT4. This being
"the core experience of the game".
Truly we shall see about[ B]"a loooong time".[/B]
Three months from now, if you are still playing it will have to be "online", since you can probably complete the core aspect of the game 5 times over in that span.