code_kev
Burn, there was no farking burn there!
Nothing deserves 98%, ESPECIALLY
I can't say I agree, especially considering a few of these *tiny* facts.
I don't recall having read that you've played MGS3, at all, so given that, and your bias to Splinter Cell, you cannot accurately guage the worth, value, or rating of this game.
I DO recall you telling me how good Halo, Halo 2, and other Halo related titles are, and considering that all of them rated higher than 9.7 (with Halo 2 getting 9.8, and the freaking MAP PACK getting 9.0...just extra maps and a 9.0?) You're definately showing a little "bias" here.
Also, Splinter Cell, if I'm not mistaken, recieved a 9.7 for all but one installation...but you didn't say anything about that either. Fact is, this game has superior story, superior multiplayer options, and superior presentation, AND a butt load of extras, so how on gods green earth is it not deserving of a higher score than the above mentioned games with a lot less on the features and bonuses side? DIdn't think so.
edit: I think obliviion will most definately be 9.5+ material. THe game just looks too stunning, and given past installations of the series, I think this one will be the one to break the mold, given it's visuals etc...but if it get's past that 98%...are you going to say it's undeserved? I don't think it would be, as it obviously would have left the reviewer with a very good impression and reason to score it as such.