Odd # engine VOTE! (Rotary/Radial Nominations)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jim Prower
  • 8 comments
  • 3,687 views

Oddest of the odd?

  • Audi 2.1L "Quattro" I-5

    Votes: 7 30.4%
  • Fiat 2.0L 20V I-5

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Honda RC211V V-5

    Votes: 4 17.4%
  • Mercedes-Benz OM617 I-5

    Votes: 2 8.7%
  • Suzuki G10 1.0L I-3

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • VAG VR5 V-5

    Votes: 3 13.0%
  • Volvo Modular I-5

    Votes: 7 30.4%
  • Wärtsilä RT-flex60C-B Diesel I-9

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    23
  • Poll closed .

Jim Prower

The Big Blue Ford.
Premium
Messages
10,620
Messages
gtp_jimprower
Well, that was a landslide if I’ve ever seen one.

Champions
1&2 Cyl: Ducati V-Twins
4 Cyl: VW/Porsche Air-cooled B-4 and Mitsubishi/DSM 4G63T I-4
6 Cyl: Porsche Air-cooled B-6
8 Cyl: Chrysler 426 Hemi V-8
10 Cyl: Chrysler “Viper” V-10
12 Cyl: BMW/McLaren S70/2,/3 V-12 and Mercedes-Benz AMG/Pagani 7.3L V-12
14+ Cyl: VAG/Bugatti W-16

Runners-up
1&2 Cyl: Harley-Davidson V-Twin
4 Cyl: Subaru EJ20 B-4
6 Cyl: NISSAN RB-Family I-6
8 Cyl: Ferrari F430 4.3L V-8 and Chevrolet Gen I Smallblock V-8
10 Cyl: Porsche Carrera GT V-10
12 Cyl: TVR 7.7L V-12
14+ Cyl: Rolls Royce Vulture X-24

Now, the Nominees for the Odd number engine class are…
Audi 2.1L "Quattro" I-5
Fiat 2.0L 20V I-5 (Coupe)
Honda RC211V V-5
Mercedes-Benz OM617 I-5
Suzuki G10 1.0L I-3 (Geo Metro)
VAG VR5 V-5 (Rabbit)
Volvo Modular I-5 (S60R/V70R)
Wärtsilä RT-flex60C-B Diesel I-9 (Ships)

And now, the final category, Wankels, Piston Rotaries, Radials

What are they?

Wankels

A Wankel rotary engine uses a triangular rotor instead of pistons. Ti gives great power per displacement, but there are reliability problems, and Wankels tend to be high-maintenance, while being somewhat less fuel efficient.

Piston Rotaries

Typical in aircraft or WWI, this engine’s BLOCK was the rotating member. The crank stayed more or less stationary, and the pistons traveled around with the block. There was low vibration, and high power-to weight ration, but conventional designs soon surpassed this type.

Radials

The radial engine is another typically aircraft engine, but this had a standard rotating crank with stationary block. These are typically one row, but later aircraft used up to two rows, and the USSR had a 7-row, 42 cyl. Marine radial engine. These were superseded in fighters by Vee- type engines, but were used in large aircraft until Jet engines came about.

There are other, experimental pistonless Rotaries out there, few of them have made it to production, but if you feel like nominating one, be my guest.

I get the easy one.

MAZDA 13B 2-ROTOR WANKEL ROTARY

I_jul01_2.jpg


  • Staple of Japanese Performance cars
  • Most successful Wankel engine in existence
  • Powers RX-7 and RX-8 (The latter the “Renesis”)
  • Can sound very good at high revs.

Nominations Criteria
  • ONE NOMINATION PER MEMBER. (Including me)
  • May be any number of cylinders or rotors
  • May be race, street, Aircraft, Marine, whatever
  • May only be Pistonless (Wankel) Rotary, Piston Rotary, or Piston Radial
  • Try giving some good reasons.
  • Engines/families are pretty much grouped by Manufacturers’ classifications, and by how interchangeable parts are. Wikipedia will be extensively used in these judgments.

Current Nominees
GM "XP882" Wankel Rotor-4 (Corvette XP882)
Mazda 13B Wankel Rotor-2 (RX-7/RX-8)
Mazda R26B R4 Wankel Rotor-4 (787B)
 
Can we nominate engineering prototypes?

I'd like to nominate the GM 4-rotor, 585 cid, 420 hp from the '73 XP882 Corvette prototype.

EDIT:
 
I nominate Mazda R26B R4, the 4-rotor unit from Le Mans winning Mazda 787B from Group C. it's first and last victory led into banning the rotaries from this historical event.

Displacement: 4x654cc (2.6l)
power: 700bhp@9000rpms
Torque: 607nm@6500rpms
 
Can we nominate engineering prototypes?

Go right ahead!

As for the jets...well, I'll have to do that seperately from the main contest, but sure. I'll probably have a nomination in the "Runner Up" category thread, and do the voting simputaneously with the championship thread.
 
The Volvo I5 is also in the Euro Focus ST and the new Ford mini MPV as well. I would of nominated it but someone beat me to it. Fantastic engine that is.

No nominations for Rotaries and the like because pretty much everything has been mentioned.
 
The Volvo I5 is also in the Euro Focus ST and the new Ford mini MPV as well. I would of nominated it but someone beat me to it. Fantastic engine that is.

No nominations for Rotaries and the like because pretty much everything has been mentioned.

yeah, that was me who did the Volvo I-5. First nomination in that category.

What? No Radial engine from you? how dissappointing. Besides, NSU's engines weren't nominated either, and therer's Piston Rotaries, like the Oberusels used in the Fokker Triplanes.
 
I nominate Mazda R26B R4, the 4-rotor unit from Le Mans winning Mazda 787B from Group C. it's first and last victory led into banning the rotaries from this historical event.

Displacement: 4x654cc (2.6l)
power: 700bhp@9000rpms
Torque: 607nm@6500rpms

Sigh.
Once again, the rotary engine was never banned from le mans. They were restricted in the later years but were never banned.
As for my nominations. Its a either the already mentioned 13B or the 12A.
 
Back