you're not right. Don't be contradictory. If you don't care why he made the game, don't buy it. Get a better brain.
Lol.. you are some comedian. Making me laugh like that :-) - No, really, I am laughing my socks off. Thanks!! I can't even begin to reply. Where to begin? It's just funny. "Get a better brain"... priceless!
Seriously though...
We LIKE the game, we've already said that. Is there any reason we can't we buy it and enjoy it even if we think it can be improved upon and are worried for the game's future long term with young upstarts like Forza and Shift snapping at it's heels?
Simple suggestions for improvement are not attacking the game; it would appear you clearly don't understand the concept of +ve criticism or using customer feedback to improve the longevity of a product's shelf life.
Example; I have designed, built and marketed a global network for agents in my industry to work better together, and I am always seeking members of our network to advise me what they don't like about the system, so I can constantly improve upon it and keep the competition at bay; and decrease frustration and, ergo, increase use of the network to secure it's growth.
Look at where complacency has gotten Microsoft? All the young companies in all areas are better than Microsoft or coming up fast... Google, Logitech, et al. Even open source software is getting close or better... see OpenOffice, Mozilla, etc.
My point is, like JohnnyPenso discussed above, with a few simple tweaks here and there PD could elevate this game to dizzying heights of playability; and, frustratingly, you don't seem to be able to:
a) Accept this to be necessary
b) Relate this to any real world sense of business or "product"
Kaz's "vision" (ephemeral as it may be) does not need to be diluted or corrupted in any way by implementing most of the recommendations mentioned above.
Perhaps you can enlighten us with your knowledge on this aspect and we can discuss further how generally improving massively the ergonomics and playability can possibly compromise this "vision"?