Ah, good to see some life in this thread. Haven't been here in a while.
Shuffle! was a lot of fun, I rather liked the insane psychopaths and the drama, since you don't see a lot of it this side of School Days (or Higurashi - now there's something that will make you lose sleep), and it differentiated it from a lot of the typical harem fare.
How far are you in Da Capo? It's certainly not as freaky as Shuffle but it still does delve into the really dramatic at times - although if you've watched any harem-types like this you should be used to it. Yoriko's arc was a real tear-jerker for me, so hopefully you will enjoy that.
I'm jealous of you people who have that much time to watch anime though - I can barely fit an hour or two in my schedule as it is, but that doesn't mean I discriminate. I still watch a lot of shows even though I have no time.
What's everyone's opinion of the anime from this season? I'm following ef - a tale of melodies and absolutely loving it every step of the way (although some might find it too 'artsy').
Clannad AS is still pretty solid, although some of the drama is a bit overblown.
Akane-iro ni Somaku Saka ... I don't like it ... but I watch it anyway. Maybe I'm wondering if it goes the same way as Da Capo - you'll see what I mean

Oh, and Nodame Cantabile Pari-hen ... man, I missed Nodame. Superb slice-of-life / comedy / romance.
Watching Chaos;Head as well and it's pretty solid, although I'm really confused by it. But that's part of the fun!