The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**

  • Thread starter Thread starter MSD Drifter
  • 2,388 comments
  • 199,160 views
my Gallardo at Toscana....

5600314639_a920c00655_b.jpg
[/url][/IMG]
 
^ An 8.9 from me, nice panning with a good sense of speed. Nice composition with a good use of the blur. I just feel that it's a bit dark, perhaps a use of the AE lock would've improved it a bit.

Here's one of mine. The almighty Jay Leno Tank Car! ;)



Eiger Nordwand W Trail - TAAANNKK CAAARR!! by FishyJuice, on Flickr
 
Andrezz
The picture would have looked better if you had picked up the feeling of speed and if the tree would not have been there, so I'll give you 4/10 👍

i'll try that one next time, that audi pics was realistic! 👍
Click to expand...
 
Can I just say this, the whole point of this thread is giving constructive criticism to other peoples photos. Please rate the ones in the post above you, I won't say that you can't comment on a previous shot, because it's always nice to have some opinions on a shot. Or if you do not agree. But a lot of photos posted here get ignored in favor for a shot up 2-3 posts.

On another note, OSE_CAP_SHADOW, your R32 shot looks quite a bit like one of my shots posted here earlier. ;)


Kyoto - Gion - Mazda Éfini RX-7 at the garage. by FishyJuice, on Flickr


And finally, CoolWheels.
Your S2000 shot gets a 7.8/10, good sense of speed, good angle, but it's perhaps a bit boring for me. You should perhaps have tried to use a filter or getting some trees or something in the pic.

I could perhaps get some response to this.


Fuji Speedway - Takata Dome NSX - 2.0 Edit by FishyJuice, on Flickr
 
FishyJuice
Can I just say this, the whole point of this thread is giving constructive criticism to other peoples photos. Please rate the ones in the post above you, I won't say that you can't comment on a previous shot, because it's always nice to have some opinions on a shot. Or if you do not agree. But a lot of photos posted here get ignored in favor for a shot up 2-3 posts.

On another note, OSE_CAP_SHADOW, your R32 shot looks quite a bit like one of my shots posted here earlier. ;)


Kyoto - Gion - Mazda Éfini RX-7 at the garage. by FishyJuice, on Flickr


And finally, CoolWheels.
Your S2000 shot gets a 7.8/10, good sense of speed, good angle, but it's perhaps a bit boring for me. You should perhaps have tried to use a filter or getting some trees or something in the pic.

I could perhaps get some response to this.


Fuji Speedway - Takata Dome NSX - 2.0 Edit by FishyJuice, on Flickr
Click to expand...

Nice! Loving how shiny and real the car looks 👍

This was taken from a recent Online Championship

Autodromo Nazionale Monza_2 by crufixtionboo, on Flickr
 
Rate it!

2qi07s5.jpg

So sad I lost this baby when my savedata got corrupted :guilty:
 
For crying out loud..
Please read the OP (first post)!

You have to rate the photos above you for anyone to rate yours.

parmi, Andrezz, mastretta_mx, Callumfromleeds, please follow the rules.
 
mastretta_mx
Rate it!

2qi07s5.jpg

So sad I lost this baby when my savedata got corrupted :guilty:
Click to expand...
7.5/10

I love the colors, the focal point is good but the angle is too harsh. I find myself turning my head to see it. I think you we so close to having the entire car in the shot that you shouldn't have cut the bumper off.


Here are my pics.
redbull_resized.jpg


Vette_resized.jpg


zonda_resized.jpg


mountains_resized.jpg


nascar_resized.jpg
 
01gt4.6
7.5/10

I love the colors, the focal point is good but the angle is too harsh. I find myself turning my head to see it. I think you we so close to having the entire car in the shot that you shouldn't have cut the bumper off.


Here are my pics.
redbull_resized.jpg


Vette_resized.jpg


zonda_resized.jpg


mountains_resized.jpg


nascar_resized.jpg
Click to expand...
2nd and 4th pic looks nice
8.9/10 8/10
heres mine haha
21ke06u.jpg
 
OSE_CAP_SHADOW
7/10 not so keen on your rim choice



Uploaded with ImageShack.us
Click to expand...

I'm gonna go with a 6/10. I like the photo, I'm just not a big fan of stationary photographs with this game ^^. Also, I'd show a bit more of the car.

Here's a few of mine:

5608261195


5608844138


5608260899
 
Can I post multiple pics? I have a few in the realistic photo thread but I just started photo mode after a long lay off so want to get some feedback.
 
Andrezz
awesome photo 👍 9,5/10

Here's mine:


Suzuka Circuit by screiinshot, on Flickr
Click to expand...

I like the picture, its creative and a great example of using the GT5 Camera's shutter speeds. 👍

I think if I could change anything I would maybe compose the picture differently. I'd also be interested to see it on a histogram to see if the back of that car is off the scale.

Here is one of mine. When taking pictures using the GT5 in-game camera, I get my kicks from trying to make my pictures look as real as possible. And its damn hard with a standard car! I also tried to give the picture a "period" 1970's camera feel. The focal point being slightly out of focus is intentional use of selective/differential focusing :sly: and I have fooled many people into thinking that it was in fact a real car.

I also don't normally like pictures of cars going away from the camera, however I think this one works well although I'm not sure why.


1969 Ford GT40 by chrismercer84, on Flickr

Feel free to check out my other GT5 pictures, they're on Flickr
 
Back