The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**

[mazda787]

Can someone rate mine it got skipped

Good lighting and use of warm filter, but there is no sense of motion even though you seem to be in the middle of a race track, the trees are distracting (could be improved with lower F value), and there is too much road in the foreground. 7/10.

Here's mine again:

 

[Snakebitten]

No sammich for Zupplu lol. Thanks for the critique though.👍 Your pic is stunning however.

Exalt1k thanks for the suggestions. I really have no idea what Im doing other than focal, f number and shutter. Ill look into what you suggested. 👍

 

[Appie]

Good lighting and use of warm filter, but there is no sense of motion even though you seem to be in the middle of a race track, the trees are distracting (could be improved with lower F value), and there is too much road in the foreground. 7/10.

Here's mine again:

The picture looks good, but it lacks a bit of emotion and it looks cut.

My verdict is: 7/10

Here is mine

 

[Snakebitten]

I like it. 7/10... That thing blocking the front of the car is messing it up for me visually.

Here's my last attempts for the night. Mode 2 as Exalt1k mentioned:

 

[Zupplu]

Much better photos compared to your first, as the car in subject is in focus. I like the viper picture, but maybe you could try to make it so you can see the brake discs glowing. The two rufs a quite good as well, but are hindered in my opinion from being in the shade.
Overall 7.5/10. Do i get my sammwich now? lol

[url=http://www.flickr.com/photos/zupplu/6656411573/] Autodromo Nazionale Monza_11 by Zupplu, on Flickr[/URL]

 

[FordMKIVJ5]

[url=http://www.flickr.com/photos/zupplu/6656411573/] Autodromo Nazionale Monza_11 by Zupplu, on Flickr[/URL]

The idea is nice but the shot could do with taking the exposure down a tad to tone down the glare, and I feel that the car could be positioned better. 👍 6/10

 

[e_dub64]

I like this photo overall.👍 I like how you got the same cars, but in all different colors. 9/10

Rates please.

 

[m-Simm]

^^^
First pic looks like it's poorly focused but I'm not certain, maybe it's the matter of resolution. Again the problem here is aperture and shutter speed, both needed to crank down more. In term of composition, maybe you need to put the car (subject) bigger. The jagged edge distracts but that's not your fault I know... 6/10.

For second one, I might gave you 8 or above if not the miniature filter. The upper part of the car is completely out of focus and it ruins the nice picture. Camera may slightly moved to left to show more portion of the car's front. Miniature filter is kinda difficult to master so avoid using it unless you're really confident about that. 6.5/10.


Copy of Circuit de Spa-Francorchamps_10 by m-SimmGT, on Flickr

 

[Snakebitten]

Nice sense of speed but since its a GTR its a 1/10 J/K 8/10

Zupplu gets a sammich 👍

 

[richteajames]

Nice picture however for my personal taste it doesn't look clean enough and would be better with a bit higher shutter speed or focus or photo mode 2.
7/10.


Nürburgring 24h by snapey18, on Flickr

Love this, 10/10 for me, well done!

 

[Leicht]

Here is mine

I kinda like it..more to 8-8.5/10

 

[Leicht]

8-8.5/10..It looks realistic :up: LFA is like one of the cars that can never go wrong..

 

[Leicht]

8.5/10 Great sense of space and very nice scene. Wish there was more light though.

I would like someone to critique each picture. I am trying to get that realistic look, so tell me how close or far i am. I play with a bright setting on the tv, so sorry if its a bit dark

1st Picture: It would look more realistic if you really put focus on the back and increase the exposure a litttle bit..but it's really good!

2nd picture: It's too Blurry..need that put that focus on the front of the car!

3rd picture: Again with the focus problem....and increase the exposure

4th picture: It's quite ok actually.

 

[breezy23d]

what do yall think?



http://s1184.photobucket.com/albums/z330/breezy23d/

also feel free to critique my other pics on photobucket

 

[e_dub64]

What y'all think?

 

[lilmann73]

breezy23d
The whole pictures has a sense of realism. I like stationary photos like that. You managed to make good use of detail in the mountains and also of the lense flare. The reflections also seem realistic for how low-detail they are. I do feel, however, that if you bring the E.V. down 0.2 0r 0.3, then it would look a wee bit better and have more details. Also, if you zoom out and pan to the left so there is more road in front of the car, it might look a bit better, like the car was about to start driving hard.
Verdict: 8/10

Now someone rate e_dub64's photo.

 

[Snakebitten]

I think Im getting the hang of the different modes but they don't always work for what I'm going for. Here's my latest attempts:

 

[davelis]

I think Im getting the hang of the different modes but they don't always work for what I'm going for. Here's my latest attempts:

sick porkers

 

[breezy23d]

here are a couple more pics to critique.

 

[Beeblebrox237]

I think Im getting the hang of the different modes but they don't always work for what I'm going for. Here's my latest attempts:

They're good, but a bit boring. I wish there was more sense of action. Try using more complicated compositions. overall, 7.5/10. You're on the right track!

here are a couple more pics to critique.

I like the last one best. I think that the first two would be better if you used panning mode 2 or 3 and decreased the shutter speed. On the other hand, you're compostions seem good. Overall, 8/10.

 

[TheeFrogmanlego]

I'm finally back and my picture, in my opinion its one of my best so please rate guys!
*i was trying to put emphasis on the front of the car and i was going for a abstract color

 

[werty_56-1]

I'm finally back and my picture, in my opinion its one of my best so please rate guys!
*i was trying to put emphasis on the front of the car and i was going for a abstract color

Very cool


(I had to delete most of your links soo you could show your pictures )
Heres mine

 

[EXALT1K]

Zenki & Subbie

 

[TheeFrogmanlego]

thank you, i took the photo down due to flicker giving me an error

 

[TheeFrogmanlego]

nice scooby

 

[werty_56-1]

(I had to delete most of your links soo you could show your pictures )
how do you get a picture up from flicker i totally forgot =/

What do you mean ?

Heres another ...

 

[e_dub64]

Charger 440​

 

[Horde_R35]

e_dub64, i didnt quote you because you have to Rate someones pic so you can post here.

What do you mean ?

Heres another ...

Nice pic mate. Love the filter, the lighting and angle. Could be better in my opinion if the scenery wasnt some much focused. A 8.5/10:tup:






My pic:

By mines_r34 at 2012-01-09

 

[Recon]

^Looks like it would be a good angle but the filter is waaay off. Next time just try panning mode 3 and a low shutter speed.

 

[Beeblebrox237]

Pretty good; I like it. The sense of speed is there, and the composition and angle are great. The only thing I would recommend is that you use a different colored car. The grey sort of blends in with the pavement. 8/10