The "Rate My Photo" thread! **Read the OP Before You Post**

[J91patriz]

[/URL] Uploaded with ImageShack.us[/IMG]

[/URL] Uploaded with ImageShack.us[/IMG]

Deko of your three pictures my favorite is definitely the first one. The car and lighting fit really well in that context 👍 The other two are not bad but to me they look a bit too gamish (if this term even exists ), expecially if compared with the first one. Overall well done.

 

[MedigoFlame]

^ The first image is placed decently, however the sense of speed is lacking due to the darkness and lack off clarity. The color is contrasted well with the bright blue of the car and the background. I'd give the first one a 6/10.

The second image feels unclear of what the viewer is trying to focus on. If it's on the reflection than I would give it a higher score, however because I'm not sure what the picture is mainly about. If it's on the car, the image somehow feels lacking in detail of it, along with parts cut off. 4.5/10

Here's mine.

 

[lilmann73]

First image:
The angle and lighting is decent, but for me, the car seems a bit too centered. There is not a lot of action in the shot. Perhaps zooming out and panning left or right will make the shot look a bit more exciting.

7/10


Second image:
Basically the same thing as the first image; lighting and angle is good, but not a lot of surroundings to add to the action. Zoom out and pan to the left.

6/10


My images (please me harsh):

 

[Mazziko]

What is that car? Is it a Chrysler ?

 

[lilmann73]

What is that car? Is it a Chrysler ?

Yes, the Chrysler 200. I photoshopped it in.

 

[Mazziko]

Naughty naughty

 

[Jamoru]

First image:
The angle and lighting is decent, but for me, the car seems a bit too centered. There is not a lot of action in the shot. Perhaps zooming out and panning left or right will make the shot look a bit more exciting.

7/10


Second image:
Basically the same thing as the first image; lighting and angle is good, but not a lot of surroundings to add to the action. Zoom out and pan to the left.

6/10


My images (please me harsh):

Like the color tone used in the first image and you did well with Photoshopping the car. 8/10! Second image 7/10. The idea is good, but too crowded for my likings. Needs more focusing on the car, as in, the car is a bit out of the picture if you understand what I mean.

Mine:

 

[driftinziggy]

@Jamoru...I like the idea of this shot but I feel it's a little too grey.. I imagine that's what you wanted.. and maybe find a spot to snap where there's a little more in the background but I like the shot overall.. solid 7.5


Toscana (Tarmac)_39 by driftinziggy2, on Flickr

Toscana (Tarmac)_37 by driftinziggy2, on Flickr

Toscana (Tarmac)_29 by driftinziggy2, on Flickr

 

[Yui-san]

I don't really like the composition on that first shot. The second shot is a bit better, but perhaps some movement might help. As for the third...again, the composition, and I don't really like the lighting. Overall a nice set though. 6.5/10

Lamborghini Aventador LP700-4 @Top Gear Test
Track



Aston Martin V12 Vantage @High Speed Ring



Aston Martin Vanquish V12 @London



Jaguar XJ220 @GVS

​

The more critiques, the better!

 

[schlep16]

Please rate my photo's. I like negative feedback, helps me to excel.

 

[Yui-san]

Please rate my photo's. I like negative feedback, helps me to excel.

Uh...You're suppose to rate the person above you first.

 

[driftinziggy]

@ Yui Thank you for feedback...
1st shot=8 strange sense of motion for my taste but I do like the angle and color
2nd shot=8 like everything but angle... feel like I have to tilt my head
3rd shot=8 I would like this more if you had raised the camera to show more of the background racing by and less of the street below
4th shot= 9 for me ... my favorite of this set I would only change the color of the car to make it stand out more... overall some great photos here



@ shlep follow the rules of the forums please.. I will give some feedback
1st shot= 5 ..not much there.. just a car and not much else no emotion, no vibrancy
2nd shot=7 ... better shot than 1st..
3rd shot= 8 ..I like this picture alot.. I think it has a nice sense of speed while still giving me something to focus on
4th shot= 6... sense of motion is okay but I think it would look better in color

 

[schlep16]

@ Yui Thank you for feedback...
1st shot=8 strange sense of motion for my taste but I do like the angle and color
2nd shot=8 like everything but angle... feel like I have to tilt my head
3rd shot=8 I would like this more if you had raised the camera to show more of the background racing by and less of the street below
4th shot= 9 for me ... my favorite of this set I would only change the color of the car to make it stand out more... overall some great photos here



@ shlep follow the rules of the forums please.. I will give some feedback
1st shot= 5 ..not much there.. just a car and not much else no emotion, no vibrancy
2nd shot=7 ... better shot than 1st..
3rd shot= 8 ..I like this picture alot.. I think it has a nice sense of speed while still giving me something to focus on
4th shot= 6... sense of motion is okay but I think it would look better in color

Thats ok, thank you. sorry for not following rules.
I like the first shot, coz of the lights
2nd i like coz it looks realistic but it doesnt have abstract of number 1. 3rd i did NOT in colour on purpose, 4th is good, but its been done before.
thats my opn, i like urs to

 

[driftinziggy]

Alright
here are some new ones

Kyoto - Shoren-in_3 by driftinziggy2, on Flickr

Kyoto - Gion_10 by driftinziggy2, on Flickr

 

[BlindArchangel]

The first one is a little dark 6.5/10 I like the second shot the most because of the dramatic lighting. 8/10

 

[Machate-man]

Nice shot J91 the first pic, i like how it has a rough action going on 8/10
the McLaren MP4 I like the mood in it great 8/10work:tup:

Koenigsegg Agera
my first attempt of editing a car into GT5



​

Brilliant, but the driver would make it perfect!

 

[shmogt]

The first one is a little dark 6.5/10 I like the second shot the most because of the dramatic lighting. 8/10

Hi I was wondering if you could post these in my be my photographer thread. Link in my sig. I will be doing a m3 drift tune soon and these shots look like they could work for me.

 

[Horde_R35]

This one looks pretty good. Especially the angle. With more colour would be better. I give it a 8.5/10

By mines_r34 at 2012-02-28​

 

[BlindArchangel]

^ The sense of speed is excellent. I like this picture a lot, I also love the Lancia Delta 9/10

 

[spunwicked]

This is rapidly becoming the "Rate my photo 6-8/10" thread.

 

[Callum B]

^ The sense of speed is excellent. I like this picture a lot, I also love the Lancia Delta 9/10

The first one is excellent 9/10 but the other 3 aren't to purty. For the third I would recommend blurring the background out abit more to create a greater sense of speed

 

[Callum B]

 

[GT-D34DLY310]

In my opinion, the shot was to blurry and i was confused on what to focus on. So i give this shot a 5/10. Next time use panning mode 3 and focus on the object you wish to focus on.

 

[carfanatic45]

In my opinion, the shot was to blurry and i was confused on what to focus on. So i give this shot a 5/10. Next time use panning mode 3 and focus on the object you wish to focus on.

I,ll give that a 10/10 great shot and the angle ang clearity is excellent.Here's mine:

 

[carfanatic45]

In my opinion, the shot was to blurry and i was confused on what to focus on. So i give this shot a 5/10. Next time use panning mode 3 and focus on the object you wish to focus on.

I,ll give that a 10/10 great shot and the angle ang clearity is excellent.Here's mine:

 

[carfanatic45]

I,ll give that a 10/10 great shot and the angle ang clearity is excellent.Here's mine:

sorry didn't mean to post my pics again. For some reason they won't load onto the response? I've tried attaching from my Flickr page but it won't come up right.

 

[driftinziggy]

Am I rating the Subaru?
I'll give it an 7.5/10..the action is nice although it's a bit bright(overexposed?)


Special Stage Route X_86 by driftinziggy2, on Flickr

Mt. Aso (Tarmac)_7 by driftinziggy2, on Flickr

 

[BlindArchangel]

10/10 for both beautiful job driftinziggy

 

[driftinziggy]

Thank u BlindArchangel.. A serious compliment coming from you..

All of those shots are definite 10's
Great use of the warm filter and exposure! If I had to choose a favorite ...Hmmm.. The tunnel shot..Definitely. Just a great shot!
I'm only gonna post one this time so pick it apart!

Special Stage Route X_95 by driftinziggy, on Flickr

 

[Callum B]

Special Stage Route X_95 by driftinziggy, on Flickr

8/10 Would be 10 but I think the Countach makes the frame feel cluttered slightly.

Here are mine: